Legislation Quick Search
09/25/2021 06:32 AM
Pennsylvania House of Representatives
https://www.legis.state.pa.us/cfdocs/legis/RCC/PUBLIC/listVoteSummaryH.cfm?sYear=2017&sInd=0&cteeCde=24&theDate=06/28/2017&RollCallId=768

House Committee Roll Call Votes

Committee JUDICIARY Date June 28, 2017
Bill/Resolution HB1216 PN1444 A02306 Type of Motion Adopt Amendment
Maker of Motion Rep. Petrarca Seconded by Rep. Costa
Brief Description This amendment moves the immunity provision from the recently repealed animal cruelty law to Title 42, and removes provisions that incorporated the now-obsolete law. The amendment also adds a limitation that the immunity does not apply where the person’s actions constitute gross negligence, recklessness, or willful or wanton misconduct, like in HB 1152. The amendment makes other minor changes to the language to make it more consistent with HB 1152. Finally, the amendment applies to all animals, rather than just dogs and cats.

Majority Members

Marsico, Ron - Chair
YEA
Corbin, Becky
YEA
Delozier, Sheryl M.
YEA
English, Harold A.
YEA
Everett, Garth D.
YEA
Jozwiak, Barry J.
NV
Klunk, Kate A.
YEA
Knowles, Jerry
YEA
Nesbit, Tedd C.
YEA
Pyle, Jeffrey P.
NAY
Saccone, Rick
YEA
Schemel, Paul
YEA
Stephens, Todd
YEA
Toohil, Tarah
YEA
Topper, Jesse
YEA
White, Martina A.
YEA

Minority Members

Petrarca, Joseph A. - Chair
YEA
Bizzarro, Ryan A.
YEA
Briggs, Tim
YEA
Costa, Dom
YEA
Davis, Tina M.
YEA
Dawkins, Jason
YEA
Dean, Madeleine
YEA
McClinton, Joanna E.
YEA
Miller, Dan L.
YEA
Mullery, Gerald J.
YEA
Neuman, Brandon P.
YEA
  
  
  
  
  

Vote Summary

YEAS: 25
NAYS: 1
NV: 1
Result: Passed