Legislation Quick Search
12/02/2021 05:53 AM
Pennsylvania House of Representatives
https://www.legis.state.pa.us/cfdocs/legis/RCC/PUBLIC/listVoteSummaryH.cfm?sYear=2011&sInd=0&cteeCde=16&theDate=04/02/2012&RollCallId=1708

House Committee Roll Call Votes

Committee FINANCE Date April 2, 2012
Bill/Resolution HB2150 PN3019 A09669 Type of Motion Adopt Amendment
Maker of Motion Rep. Boyle Seconded by Rep. Davidson
Brief Description Requires taxpayers to prove "valid business purpose" by "clear and convincing evidence."

Majority Members

Benninghoff, Kerry A. - Chair
NAY
Aument, Ryan P.
NAY
Bear, John C.
NAY
Boyd, Scott W.
NAY
Cox, Jim
NAY
Denlinger, Gordon
NAY
Dunbar, George
NAY
Evankovich, Eli
NAY
Gabler, Matt
NAY
Harris, Adam
NAY
Keller, Fred
NAY
Milne, Duane D.
NAY
Peifer, Michael
NAY
Rapp, Kathy L.
NAY
Scavello, Mario M.
NAY

Minority Members

Mundy, Phyllis - Chair
YEA
Boyle, Kevin J.
YEA
Bradford, Matthew D.
YEA
Briggs, Tim
YEA
Davidson, Margo L.
YEA
DeWeese, H. W.
YEA
Fabrizio, Florindo J.
YEA
Kavulich, Sid M.
YEA
Mirabito, Rick
YEA
Smith, Matthew
YEA
  
  
  
  
  

Vote Summary

YEAS: 10
NAYS: 15
NV: 0
Result: Failed