Test Drive Our New Site! We have some improvements in the works that we're excited for you to experience. Click here to try our new, faster, mobile friendly beta site. We will be maintaining our current version of the site thru the end of 2024, so you can switch back as our improvements continue.

House Committee Roll Call Votes

Committee	JUDICIARY	Date	March 12, 2008
Bill/Resolution	HR559 PN3109	Type of Motion	Report Bill As Committed
Maker of Motion	Rep. Petrarca	Seconded by	Rep. White
Brief Description	A Resolution urging the Pennsylvania Supreme Court to enact a rule of criminal procedure allowing written jury instructions pertaining to the elements of each crime charged and any relevant defenses to be provided to jurors for use as part of the deliberative process by the jury

Majority Members

Caltagirone, Thomas R. - Chair	YEA
Bennington, Lisa	NAY
Frankel, Dan	NV
James, Harold	YEA
Kula, Deberah	NAY
Leach, Daylin	YEA
Lentz, Bryan R.	YEA
Manderino, Kathy	YEA
Pallone, John E.	NAY
Ramaley, Sean M.	NAY
Vitali, Greg	YEA
Wagner, Chelsa	YEA
Walko, Don	NV
White, Jesse	NAY
Williams, Jewell	NV

Minority Members

Marsico, Ron - Chair	NV
Creighton, Tom C.	YEA
Dally, Craig A.	YEA
Evans, John R.	YEA
Gabig, Will	YEA
Grell, Glen R.	YEA
Harper, Kate	YEA
Mackereth, Beverly	YEA
Mantz, Carl W.	NAY
O'Neill, Bernie	YEA
Pickett, Tina	YEA
Rock, Todd	YEA
True, Katie	YEA

Vote Summary

YEAS:	18
NAYS:	6
NV:	4
Result:	Passed