PRINTER'S NO.  656

  

THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF PENNSYLVANIA

  

SENATE BILL

 

No.

625

Session of

2011

  

  

INTRODUCED BY ERICKSON, YUDICHAK, FONTANA, FOLMER, BRUBAKER, WASHINGTON, EICHELBERGER, PIPPY, RAFFERTY, WAUGH, BROWNE, ALLOWAY, BAKER, VOGEL AND DINNIMAN, FEBRUARY 25, 2011

  

  

REFERRED TO STATE GOVERNMENT, FEBRUARY 25, 2011  

  

  

  

AN ACT

  

1

Amending Title 65 (Public Officers) of the Pennsylvania

2

Consolidated Statutes, further providing for short title of

3

chapter, for purpose and for definitions; providing for

4

establishment and operation of nominating committee, for

5

Pennsylvania Public Integrity Commission, for limitations on

6

activities by commissioners and employees, for powers and

7

duties of commission, for authority, qualification, training

8

and identification of investigative employees designated as

9

law enforcement officers, for photo identification, for

10

immunity of witnesses and for enforcement of subpoenas;

11

further providing for restricted activities, for statement of

12

financial interests required to be filed, for investigations

13

by commission and for penalties; providing for costs

14

restitutions and forfeiture; further providing for wrongful

15

use of chapter; providing for disclosure of executive session

16

testimony and investigative records, for privileged

17

statements and reports, for commission disclosure of economic

18

interests and for applicable statutes; and making repeals.

19

The General Assembly of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania

20

hereby enacts as follows:

21

Section 1.  Sections 1101 and 1101.1 of Title 65 of the

22

Pennsylvania Consolidated Statutes are amended to read:

23

§ 1101.  Short title of chapter.

24

This chapter shall be known and may be cited as the [Public

25

Official and Employee Ethics] Pennsylvania Public Integrity

 


1

Commission Act.

2

§ 1101.1.  Purpose.

3

(a)  [Declarations.--The Legislature hereby declares that

4

public office is a public trust and that any effort to realize

5

personal financial gain through public office other than

6

compensation provided by law is a violation of that trust. In

7

order to strengthen the faith and confidence of the people of

8

this Commonwealth in their government, the Legislature further

9

declares that the people have a right to be assured that the

10

financial interests of holders of or nominees or candidates for

11

public office do not conflict with the public trust. Because

12

public confidence in government can best be sustained by

13

assuring the people of the impartiality and honesty of public

14

officials, this chapter shall be liberally construed to promote

15

complete financial disclosure as specified in this chapter.

16

Furthermore, it is recognized that clear guidelines are needed

17

in order to guide public officials and employees in their

18

actions. Thus, the General Assembly by this chapter intends to

19

define as clearly as possible those areas which represent

20

conflict with the public trust.] Legislative intent.--It is the

21

intent of the General Assembly that this chapter promote the

22

following public policy purposes and objectives:

23

(1)  Uncover and investigate public corruption within the

24

Commonwealth:

25

(i)  at all levels of government, including State,

26

county and local; and

27

(ii)  in all branches of government, including

28

legislative, executive and judicial.

29

(2)  Establish a Pennsylvania Public Integrity Commission

30

which serves both a law enforcement role as a criminal

- 2 -

 


1

justice agency concerning specific criminal violations and an

2

educational role for public officials, public employees,

3

district attorneys, other law enforcement entities, the

4

General Assembly and the public.

5

(3)  Encourage the Pennsylvania Public Integrity

6

Commission to work cooperatively with the Attorney General,

7

the Pennsylvania State Police, district attorneys and other

8

law enforcement entities in conducting its mission.

9

(4)  Promote administration of this chapter by the

10

Pennsylvania Public Integrity Commission in a manner which is

11

cognizant of the responsibilities and burdens of public

12

officials and employees who have demonstrated an interest in

13

promoting public confidence in government.

14

(b)  [Recognition.--It is recognized that many public

15

officials, including most local officials and members of the

16

General Assembly, are citizen-officials who bring to their

17

public office the knowledge and concerns of ordinary citizens

18

and taxpayers. They should not be discouraged from maintaining

19

their contacts with their community through their occupations

20

and professions. Thus, in order to foster maximum compliance

21

with its terms, this chapter shall be administered in a manner

22

that emphasizes guidance to public officials and public

23

employees regarding the ethical standards established by this

24

chapter.] Declarations.--The Legislature hereby declares that

25

public office is a public trust and that any effort to realize

26

personal financial gain through public office other than

27

compensation provided by law is a violation of that trust. The

28

Legislature also declares the public would be best served by a

29

Statewide criminal justice agency which focuses on investigating

30

criminal incidents of public corruption. In order to strengthen

- 3 -

 


1

the faith and confidence of the people of this Commonwealth in

2

their government, the Legislature further declares that the

3

people have a right to be assured that the financial interests

4

of holders of or nominees or candidates for public office do not

5

conflict with the public trust. Because public confidence in

6

government can best be sustained by assuring the people of the

7

impartiality and honesty of public officials, this chapter shall

8

be liberally construed to promote complete financial disclosure

9

as specified in this chapter. Furthermore, it is recognized that

10

clear guidelines are needed in order to guide public officials

11

and employees in their actions. Thus, the General Assembly by

12

this chapter intends to define as clearly as possible those

13

areas which represent conflict with the public trust.

14

(c)  [Legislative intent.--It is the intent of the General

15

Assembly that this chapter be administered by an independent

16

commission composed of members who are cognizant of the

17

responsibilities and burdens of public officials and employees

18

and who have demonstrated an interest in promoting public

19

confidence in government.] (Reserved).

20

Section 2.  The definitions of "advice," "business with which

21

he is associated," "candidate," "commission," "conflict" or

22

"conflict of interest," "contract," "findings report," "opinion"

23

and "order" in section 1102 of Title 65 are amended and the

24

section is amended by adding definitions to read:

25

§ 1102.  Definitions.

26

The following words and phrases when used in this chapter

27

shall have, unless the context clearly indicates otherwise, the

28

meanings given to them in this section:

29

"Advice."  Any directive of the chief counsel of the [State

30

Ethics Commission] commission issued under section [1107(11)]

- 4 -

 


1

1102.4(15) (relating to powers and duties of commission) and

2

based exclusively on prior commission opinions, prior opinions

3

of the State Ethics Commission, this chapter, regulations

4

promulgated pursuant to this chapter and court opinions which

5

interpret this chapter.

6

* * *

7

"Business with which [he] a person is associated."  Any

8

business in which the person or a member of the person's

9

immediate family is a director, officer, owner, employee or has

10

a financial interest.

11

"Candidate."  Any individual who seeks nomination or election

12

to public office by vote of the electorate, other than a judge

13

of elections, inspector of elections or official of a political

14

party, whether or not such individual is nominated or elected.

15

An individual shall be deemed to be seeking nomination or

16

election to such office if [he] the individual has:

17

(1)  received a contribution or made an expenditure or

18

given [his] consent for any other person or committee to

19

receive a contribution or make an expenditure for the purpose

20

of influencing [his] the nomination or election to such

21

office, whether or not the individual has announced the

22

specific office for which [he] the individual will seek

23

nomination or election at the time the contribution is

24

received or the expenditure is made; or

25

(2)  taken the action necessary under the laws of this

26

Commonwealth to qualify [himself] the individual for

27

nomination or election to such office.

28

The term shall include individuals nominated or elected as

29

write-in candidates unless they resign such nomination or

30

elected office within 30 days of having been nominated or

- 5 -

 


1

elected.

2

"Commission."  The [State Ethics] Pennsylvania Public

3

Integrity Commission.

4

* * *

5

"Conflict" or "conflict of interest."  Use by a public

6

official or public employee of the authority of [his] the

7

person's office or employment or any confidential information

8

received through [his] holding public office or employment for

9

the private pecuniary benefit of [himself, a member of his

10

immediate family] the person, an immediate family member or a

11

business with which [he] the person or a member of [his] the

12

person's immediate family is associated. The term does not

13

include an action having a de minimis economic impact or which

14

affects to the same degree a class consisting of the general

15

public or a subclass consisting of an industry, occupation or

16

other group which includes the public official or public

17

employee, a member of [his] the person's immediate family or a

18

business with which [he] the person or a member of [his] the

19

person's immediate family is associated.

20

"Contract."  An agreement or arrangement for the acquisition,

21

use or disposal by the Commonwealth or a political subdivision

22

of consulting or other services or of supplies, materials,

23

equipment, land or other personal or real property. The term

24

shall not mean an agreement or arrangement between the State or

25

political subdivision as one party and a public official or

26

public employee as the other party, concerning [his] the public

27

official or public employee's expense, reimbursement, salary,

28

wage, retirement or other benefit, tenure or other matters in

29

consideration of [his] the public official or public employee's 

30

current public employment with the Commonwealth or a political

- 6 -

 


1

subdivision.

2

"Court."  The Commonwealth Court.

3

* * *

4

"Findings report."  An initial report containing findings of

5

fact as determined by the [State Ethics Commission's]

6

commission's investigation but not containing any conclusions of

7

law or any determination of whether there has been a violation

8

of law.

9

* * *

10

"Immunity order."  An order issued under this chapter by the

11

court directing a witness to testify or produce other

12

information over a claim of privilege against self-

13

incrimination.

14

* * *

15

"Opinion."  A directive of the [State Ethics Commission]

16

commission issued pursuant to section [1107(10)] 1102.4(14) 

17

(relating to powers and duties of commission) setting forth a

18

public official's or public employee's duties under this

19

chapter.

20

"Order."  A directive of the [State Ethics Commission]

21

commission issued pursuant to section [1107(13)] 1102.4(17) 

22

(relating to powers and duties of commission) at the conclusion

23

of an investigation which contains findings of fact, conclusions

24

of law and penalties.

25

* * *

26

"Public corruption."  The unlawful activity, under color of

27

or in connection with any public office or employment, of any

28

individual:

29

(1)  employed by an agency as defined in the act of

30

February 14, 2008 (P.L.6, No.3), known as the Right-to-Know

- 7 -

 


1

Law; or

2

(2)  elected by the public, appointed by a governmental

3

body or an appointed official in an agency as defined in the

4

Right-to-Know Law.

5

* * *

6

Section 3.  Title 65 is amended by adding sections to read:

7

§ 1102.1.  Establishment and operation of nominating committee.

8

(a)  Establishment.--When a vacancy exists in the commission,

9

a nominating committee shall be established and selected as

10

provided in this section.

11

(b)  List of current nominees.-–A nominating committee shall

12

compile a list of 15 current nominees to fill a vacancy in the

13

commission. A list of nominees shall not have more than six

14

members of the same political party. After the vacancy in the

15

commission for which the nominating committee was established

16

has been filled, the list of 15 current nominees shall be

17

discarded, and a subsequent vacancy shall not be filled from

18

that list. This section shall not preclude the inclusion of a

19

nominee in a subsequent list of nominees.

20

(c)  Selection and composition.--The nominating committee

21

shall be selected as follows:

22

(1)  The President pro tempore of the Senate shall

23

appoint three members of the nominating committee. One

24

appointee shall be a current or former district attorney.

25

Two appointees shall be current or former deans of a

26

Pennsylvania law school accredited by the American Bar

27

Association.

28

(2)  The Minority Leader of the Senate shall appoint two

29

members of the nominating committee. One appointee shall be a

30

current or former dean of a Pennsylvania law school

- 8 -

 


1

accredited by the American Bar Association. One appointee

2

shall be a member or employee of a nonprofit, nonpartisan

3

citizen's lobbying organization that has been in existence

4

for no fewer than 30 years.

5

(3)  No more than three members of the nominating

6

committee shall be members of the same political party.

7

(d)  Chairperson.--The members of the nominating committee

8

shall select a chairperson of the committee from among the

9

members.

10

(e)  Term.--The members of the nominating committee shall

11

serve until the vacancy in the commission for which the

12

nominating committee was created has been filled. Nothing in

13

this section shall preclude the reappointment of a member of a

14

nominating committee to a subsequent nominating committee.

15

(f)  Expenses.--The members of a nominating committee shall

16

serve without compensation but shall be entitled to reasonable

17

travel, hotel and other necessary expenses from the funds of the

18

commission as approved by the commission. The expenses shall not

19

exceed the applicable per diem rates established by the United

20

States General Services Administration.

21

(g)  Support.--The commission shall provide administrative

22

assistance to a nominating committee.

23

(h)  Vacancies.--Vacancies in a nominating committee before

24

the expiration of its term shall be filled for the remainder of

25

the term in the same manner as original appointments.

26

(i)  Removal.--The appointing authority of a member of a

27

nominating committee may remove that member for good cause.

28

(j)  Procedure.--The following shall apply to a nominating

29

committee procedure:

30

(1)  A majority of the members of a nominating committee

- 9 -

 


1

constitutes a quorum. A member of a nominating committee

2

shall participate at a meeting of the committee in person or

3

by teleconference or video conference for the purposes of

4

meeting a quorum.

5

(2)  Voting shall be direct, including voting by

6

teleconference or video conference. Voting by proxy shall not

7

be permitted.

8

(k)  Meetings.--A nominating committee shall meet as needed

9

at the call of the chairperson.

10

§ 1102.2.  Commission.

11

(a)  Continuation of State Ethics Commission.--The commission

12

is a successor to and a continuation of the State Ethics

13

Commission established under the act of October 4, 1978

14

(P.L.883, No.170), referred to as the Public Official and

15

Employee Ethics Law. The commission shall be an independent

16

administrative body consisting of seven members who shall be

17

known as commissioners.

18

(b)  Continuation of commissioners of the State Ethics

19

Commission.--Upon the effective date of this section, the

20

current commissioners of the State Ethics Commission shall

21

continue to serve as administrators of this chapter with all of

22

the duties, powers, rights and responsibilities of commissioners

23

of the commission until no fewer than four commissioners are

24

appointed under subsection (c).

25

(c)  Composition.--The commissioners shall be appointed by

26

the Governor, subject to the consent of two-thirds of the

27

members elected to the Senate, from the list of current nominees

28

prepared by a nominating committee under section 1102.1

29

(relating to establishment and operation of nominating

30

committee). The commission shall not have more than three

- 10 -

 


1

commissioners of the same political party.

2

(d)  Term.--The original commissioners shall be appointed as

3

follows:

4

(1)  Three shall be appointed for a term of one year.

5

(2)  Three shall be appointed for a term of two years.

6

(3)  One shall be appointed for a term of three years.

7

After the original commissioners are appointed, appointments  

8

shall be for a term of three years.

9

(e)  Vacancy and reappointment.--A vacancy shall be filled

10

for the remainder of the unexpired term in the same manner as an

11

original appointment. Upon the expiration of a term, a

12

commissioner shall continue to hold office until a successor has

13

been duly appointed, but not longer than six months after the

14

expiration of the commissioner's appointed term. A commissioner

15

may be reappointed to serve one three-year term if included on

16

the list of current nominees for that vacancy provided by a

17

nominating committee under section 1102.1.

18

(f)  Chairperson.--The commissioners shall meet on an annual

19

basis to select a chairperson of the commission from among the

20

commissioners.

21

(g)  Compensation and expenses.--A commissioner shall receive

22

$100-a-day compensation for every meeting of the commission at

23

which the commissioner participates in person and a quorum of

24

the commission is present. A commissioner shall be entitled to

25

reasonable travel, hotel and other necessary expenses as

26

approved by the commission, but the expenses shall not exceed

27

the applicable per diem rates established by the United States

28

General Services Administration.

29

(h)  Removal.--Except as authorized under this subsection, a

30

commissioner shall not be removed from office during his term. A

- 11 -

 


1

commissioner may be removed from office in the following

2

circumstances:

3

(1)  Upon clear and convincing evidence of misfeasance or

4

malfeasance in office or neglect of duty by a commissioner,

5

the Governor may remove a commissioner prior to the

6

expiration of the term. The Governor shall provide the

7

commissioner who is removed with a statement of the reasons

8

for the removal.

9

(2)  A commissioner who fails to attend, in person or by

10

teleconference or video conference, three consecutive

11

meetings shall forfeit the position on the commission unless

12

the chairperson, upon written request from the commissioner,

13

finds the commissioner should be excused for good cause.

14

A commissioner who is removed may petition the court for

15

reinstatement. The court shall hold an expedited hearing and

16

render a decision within 30 days after the hearing or as soon

17

thereafter as may be practicable. A decision of the court that

18

is adverse to a commissioner who is removed shall result in a

19

vacancy that shall be filled under this chapter.

20

(i)  Procedure.--All of the following shall apply to

21

commission procedure:

22

(1)  A majority of the commissioners constitutes a

23

quorum. A commissioner must participate at a meeting of the

24

commission in person or by teleconference or video conference

25

for the purpose of meeting a quorum.

26

(2)  Voting must be direct, including voting by

27

teleconference or video conference. Voting by proxy shall not

28

be permitted.

29

(j)  Meetings.--The commission shall meet no fewer than once

30

every two months and at additional times as necessary to conduct

- 12 -

 


1

the business of the commission.

2

§ 1102.3.  Limitations on activities by commissioners and

3

employees.

4

(a)  General rule.--No individual while a member or employee

5

of the commission shall:

6

(1)  Hold another public office or be a candidate for

7

another public office.

8

(2)  Hold office in a political party or political

9

committee.

10

(3)  Actively participate in, contribute to or solicit

11

contributions for a political campaign, political party,

12

political committee or candidate.

13

(4)  Publicly endorse a candidate.

14

(b)  Exception.--Nothing in this section shall preclude a

15

member or employee of the commission from actively participating

16

in, contributing to or soliciting contributions for a candidate

17

for Federal office or elective office outside of this

18

Commonwealth.

19

§ 1102.4.  Powers and duties of commission.

20

In addition to other powers and duties prescribed by law, the

21

commission shall:

22

(1)  Prescribe and publish rules and regulations to carry

23

out the provisions of this chapter, including regulations

24

controlling or defining the following:

25

(i)  Calling of meetings.

26

(ii)  Investigative responsibilities of commission

27

members and employees.

28

(iii)  Written procedures to be utilized by the

29

commission's investigative management staff in planning

30

and supervising investigations and inquiries.

- 13 -

 


1

(iv)  Dissemination of materials, including

2

dissemination to the Governor and members or committees

3

of the General Assembly.

4

(v)  Appropriate use of commission property,

5

including vehicles.

6

(vi)  Maintenance of confidentiality of information.

7

(vii)  Other procedures and acts necessary for the

8

proper functioning of the commission.

9

(2)  As a criminal justice agency, inquire into public

10

corruption and the activities of persons engaged in and

11

associated with public corruption. The commission shall make

12

a written report of every completed public corruption

13

investigation which may include recommendation for

14

legislative or administrative action. Except for those

15

reports provided to another law enforcement agency, if a

16

public corruption report is critical of a named individual

17

not indicted for a criminal offense, the named individual

18

shall be allowed to submit a response to the allegations

19

contained in the report which shall be made part of the

20

report.

21

(3)  Hold hearings, take testimony, issue subpoenas and

22

require the attendance and testimony of witnesses and the

23

production of documentary evidence relative to any

24

investigation which the commission may conduct in accordance

25

with the powers given it. The subpoenas shall be signed by

26

the chairperson, the chief counsel and one other commissioner

27

and shall be served by a person authorized to serve subpoenas

28

under the laws of this Commonwealth.

29

(4)  Refer criminal violations to a district attorney,

30

the Attorney General of Pennsylvania, the Attorney General of

- 14 -

 


1

the United States or a United States Attorney for

2

investigation or prosecution.

3

(5)  During April of each calendar year, submit an annual

4

report on the status of public corruption in this

5

Commonwealth to a joint public hearing of the Judiciary

6

Committee of the Senate and the Judiciary Committee of the

7

House of Representatives. The commission shall submit other

8

public corruption reports and present the reports at public

9

hearings of the committees of the Senate and the House of

10

Representatives having oversight responsibilities or

11

appropriate legislative jurisdiction of the subject matter of

12

the reports. If a report is critical of a named individual

13

not indicted for a criminal offense, the named individual

14

shall be allowed to submit a response to the allegations

15

contained in the report which shall be made part of the

16

report.

17

(6)  Prescribe forms for statements and reports required

18

to be filed by this chapter and furnish such forms to persons

19

required to file such statements and reports.

20

(7)  Prepare and publish guidelines setting forth

21

recommended uniform methods of accounting and reporting for

22

use by persons required to file statements and reports by

23

this chapter.

24

(8)  Accept and file any information voluntarily supplied

25

that exceeds the requirements of this chapter.

26

(9)  Inspect statements of financial interests which have

27

been filed in order to ascertain whether any reporting person

28

has failed to file such a statement or has filed a deficient

29

statement. If, upon inspection, it is determined that a

30

reporting person has failed to file a statement of financial

- 15 -

 


1

interests or that any statement which has been filed fails to

2

conform with the requirements of section 1105 (relating to

3

statement of financial interests), then the commission shall

4

in writing notify the person. Such notice shall state in

5

detail the deficiency and the penalties for failure to file

6

or for filing a deficient statement of financial interests.

7

(10)  Provide that statements and reports filed with the

8

commission be made available for public inspection and

9

copying during regular office hours and provide that copying

10

facilities be made available at a charge not to exceed actual

11

cost and advise other State and local agencies of the

12

provisions of this paragraph.

13

(11)  Compile and maintain an index of all reports and

14

statements filed with the commission to facilitate public

15

access to such reports and statements and instruct other

16

State and local agencies which receive and file financial

17

interest statements in the maintenance of systems which

18

facilitate public access to such statements.

19

(12)  Prepare and publish annual summaries of statements

20

and reports filed with the commission.

21

(13)  Preserve statements and reports filed with the

22

commission for a period of five years from date of receipt

23

and advise other State and local agencies which receive and

24

store financial interest statements to preserve such

25

statements for a period of five years from date of receipt.

26

(14)  Issue to any person upon such person's request or

27

to the appointing authority or employer of that person upon

28

the request of such appointing authority or employer an

29

opinion with respect to such person's duties under this

30

chapter. The commission shall, within 14 days, either issue

- 16 -

 


1

the opinion or advise the person who made the request whether

2

an opinion will be issued. A person who acts in good faith on

3

an opinion issued to that person by the commission shall not

4

be subject to criminal or civil penalties for so acting,

5

provided that the material facts are as stated in the opinion

6

request. The commission's opinions shall be public record and

7

may from time to time be published. The person requesting the

8

opinion may, however, require that the opinion shall contain

9

such deletions and changes as shall be necessary to protect

10

the identity of the persons involved.

11

(15)  Provide written advice to any person or the

12

appointing authority or employer of such person upon the

13

person's request with respect to such person's duties under

14

this chapter. Such advice shall be provided within 21 working

15

days of the request, provided that the time may be extended

16

for good cause. It shall be a complete defense in any

17

enforcement proceeding initiated by the commission and

18

evidence of good faith conduct in any other civil or criminal

19

proceeding if the requester, at least 21 working days prior

20

to the alleged violation, requested written advice from the

21

commission in good faith, disclosed truthfully all the

22

material facts and committed the acts complained of either in

23

reliance on the advice or because of the failure of the

24

commission to provide advice within 21 days of the request or

25

such later extended time. The person requesting the advice

26

may, however, require that the advice shall contain such

27

deletions and changes as shall be necessary to protect the

28

identity of the persons involved.

29

(16)  Initiate an inquiry under section 1108(a) (relating

30

to investigations of violations of this chapter by

- 17 -

 


1

commission) where a complaint has not been filed but where

2

there is a reasonable belief that a conflict may exist.

3

(17)  Issue findings, reports and orders relating to

4

investigations initiated pursuant to section 1108 which set

5

forth the alleged violation, findings of fact and conclusions

6

of law. An order may include a referral for prosecution. Any

7

order resulting from a finding that a public official or

8

public employee has obtained a financial gain in violation of

9

this chapter may require the restitution plus interest of

10

that gain to the appropriate governmental body. The

11

commission or the Office of Attorney General shall have

12

standing to apply to the court to seek enforcement of an

13

order requiring such restitution. This restitution

14

requirement shall be in addition to any other penalties

15

provided for in this chapter.

16

(18)  Prepare and publish special reports, educational

17

materials and technical studies to further the purposes of

18

this chapter.

19

(19)  Transmit, free of charge, copies of each order,

20

advice and opinion which have become a matter of public

21

record quarterly to the law library of each county, one

22

public library in each county, the State Library, the State

23

Senate Library, each authority appointing commission members

24

under this chapter, the Pennsylvania Association of County

25

Commissioners, the Pennsylvania Association of Boroughs, the

26

Pennsylvania State Association of Township Supervisors, the

27

Pennsylvania State Association of Township Commissioners, the

28

Pennsylvania School Boards Association and the Pennsylvania

29

League of Cities.

30

(20)  Hold at least two public hearings each year, of

- 18 -

 


1

which at least one shall be held in Harrisburg and at least

2

one shall be held in a location other than Harrisburg, to

3

seek input from persons and organizations that represent any

4

individual subject to the provisions of this chapter and from

5

other interested parties.

6

(21)  Call upon the department heads of State government

7

and State agencies through its chairperson for information

8

and assistance as needed to carry out the functions of the

9

commission.

10

(22)  Account to the Governor, the Auditor General and

11

the General Assembly at the end of each fiscal year for

12

moneys received and disbursed.

13

(23)  Appoint and fix the compensation of an executive

14

director and a chief counsel. The executive director shall be

15

responsible for the administrative operations of the

16

commission and shall perform other duties as may be delegated

17

or assigned by the commission, except that the commission

18

shall not delegate the making of regulations to the executive

19

director. The chief counsel shall be the chief legal officer

20

of the commission. The commission may obtain the services of

21

experts and consultants as necessary to carry out its duties

22

pursuant to this chapter.

23

(24)  Appoint and fix the compensation of other employees

24

as the commission may find necessary for the proper

25

performance of the functions of the commission. The

26

commission shall designate which investigative employees of

27

the commission shall be law enforcement officers as provided

28

in section 1102.5 (relating to authority, qualification,

29

training and identification of investigative employees

30

designated as law enforcement officers). Other employees of

- 19 -

 


1

the commission shall be civilians.

2

(25)  Pay expenses incurred by the executive director,

3

chief counsel or other employees on the presentation of

4

itemized vouchers and approval by the commission.

5

(26)  Perform other acts necessary for the proper

6

functioning of the commission.

7

§ 1102.5.  Authority, qualification, training and identification

8

of investigative employees designated as law 

9

enforcement officers.

10

(a)  Authority.--An investigative employee of the commission

11

designated as a law enforcement officer shall have the law

12

enforcement power and authority, anywhere within this

13

Commonwealth, to enforce the following laws:

14

(1)  This chapter.

15

(2)  The act of July 10, 1968 (P.L.316, No.154), known as

16

the Legislative Code of Ethics.

17

(3)  Crimes related to public office or public employment

18

as defined in section 2 of the act of July 8, 1978 (P.L.752,

19

No.140), known as the Public Employee Pension Forfeiture Act,

20

except Federal offenses.

21

(b)  Qualifications.--An investigative employee shall be

22

qualified for appointment and designation as a law enforcement

23

officer if the employee:

24

(1)  Has successfully completed a Federal or State law

25

enforcement training program determined by the Commissioner

26

of Pennsylvania State Police to be of sufficient scope and

27

duration to provide the participant with basic law

28

enforcement training.

29

(2)  Has not been convicted of a felony or an offense

30

graded a serious misdemeanor, as defined by the act of

- 20 -

 


1

January 29, 2004 (P.L.4, No.2), known as the Confidence in

2

Law Enforcement Act.

3

(3)  Has not been convicted of an offense in a

4

jurisdiction, state or country outside this Commonwealth in

5

accordance with the laws of that jurisdiction, state or

6

country and the offense is equivalent to an offense specified

7

in paragraph (2), regardless of its grading in that

8

jurisdiction, state or country.

9

(c)  Continuing education.--With the assistance of the

10

Commissioner of Pennsylvania State Police, the commission shall

11

develop a program of ongoing law enforcement education for

12

investigative employees designated as law enforcement officers.

13

(d)  Firearms.--

14

(1)  The commission shall develop regulations and

15

procedures for the use and possession of firearms by

16

investigative employees designated as law enforcement

17

officers, including the type of firearms permitted and the

18

circumstances under which an investigative employee would be

19

permitted to possess or use a firearm.

20

(2)  No commission investigative employee may possess or

21

use a firearm in the course of the employee's commission

22

duties unless he holds a current valid certification in the

23

use and handling of firearms under one of the following:

24

(i)  53 Pa.C.S. Ch. 21 Subch. D (relating to

25

municipal police education and training).

26

(ii)  The act of February 9, 1984 (P.L.3, No.2),

27

known as the Deputy Sheriffs' Education and Training Act.

28

(iii)  Another firearms program determined by the

29

Commissioner of Pennsylvania State Police to be of

30

sufficient scope and duration as to provide the

- 21 -

 


1

participant with basic training in the use and handling

2

of firearms.

3

(e)  Badge.--Every investigative employee of the commission

4

designated as a law enforcement officer shall possess a metallic

5

badge with the words "Public Integrity Commission Officer"

6

inscribed on it.

7

§ 1102.6.  Photo identification.

8

Regardless of whether or not they have been designated law

9

enforcement officers, individuals appointed as investigative

10

employees of the commission shall have photo identification

11

cards issued by the commission containing the following:

12

(1)  A photo of the individual taken within the previous

13

24 months.

14

(2)  The name of the individual.

15

(3)  The signature of the individual.

16

(4)  The words "Public Integrity Commission."

17

(5)  The date of issuance of the photo identification

18

card.

19

§ 1102.7.  Immunity of witnesses.

20

(a)  General rule.--Notwithstanding 42 Pa.C.S. § 5947

21

(relating to immunity of witnesses), immunity orders shall be

22

available under this section in proceedings before the

23

commission involving an investigation into public corruption.

24

(b)  Request and issuance.--The commission may request an

25

immunity order from a judge of the court and that judge shall

26

issue the order when in the judgment of the commission the

27

following criteria are satisfied:

28

(1)  The testimony or other information from a witness

29

may be necessary to the public interest.

30

(2)  A witness has refused or is likely to refuse to

- 22 -

 


1

testify or provide other information on the basis of using

2

the privilege against self-incrimination.

3

(c)  Order to testify.--Whenever a witness refuses to testify

4

or provide other information in a proceeding specified in

5

subsection (a) on the basis of the privilege against self-

6

incrimination and the person presiding at the proceeding

7

communicates to the witness an immunity order, the witness shall

8

not refuse to testify based on his privilege against self-

9

incrimination.

10

(d)  Limitation on use.--No testimony or other information

11

compelled under an immunity order or information directly or

12

indirectly derived from the testimony or other information shall

13

be used against a witness in a criminal case except the

14

information may be used:

15

(1)  in a prosecution under 18 Pa.C.S. § 4902 (relating

16

to perjury) or 4903 (relating to false swearing);

17

(2)  in a contempt proceeding for failure to comply with

18

an immunity order; or

19

(3)  as evidence in a proceeding where the witness is not

20

a criminal defendant where otherwise admissible.

21

(e)  Civil contempt.--Persons failing to comply with an

22

immunity order may be adjudged in civil contempt and committed

23

to the county jail until complying with the order, provided that

24

the proceeding or the investigation or report involving a

25

proceeding where the refusal to comply with an immunity order

26

has been completed. Persons may purge themselves of contempt by

27

complying with the order before the commission notwithstanding

28

the completion of the investigation or report.

29

(f)  Criminal contempt.--In addition to civil contempt as

30

provided in subsection (e), a person who fails to comply with an

- 23 -

 


1

immunity order shall be guilty of criminal contempt and upon

2

conviction be sentenced to pay a fine of not more than $5,000 or

3

to imprisonment for not more than one year, or both.

4

(g)  Notice, consultation and opportunity to object.--Prior

5

to seeking an immunity order, the commission shall require its

6

chief counsel to consult with the district attorney of an

7

affected county, the Attorney General and the United States

8

Attorney of an affected district in order to prevent

9

interference with an ongoing investigation. The results of the

10

consultation shall be reported to the commission before an

11

immunity order is sought under this section. The commission

12

shall give notice to a district attorney of an affected county,

13

the Attorney General or the United States Attorney of an

14

affected district of a request for an immunity order to be

15

submitted to a judge of the court. The foregoing officers may

16

appear as a party and request a reasonable delay or denial of

17

the grant of immunity if an immediate grant would jeopardize an

18

investigation or prosecution. In a proceeding under this

19

section, the judge may delay or deny the request for immunity if

20

the judge  determines, in the exercise of judicial discretion,

21

that an immunity order will jeopardize an actual or pending

22

investigation or prosecution.

23

§ 1102.8.  Enforcement of subpoenas.

24

(a)  Application.--Upon the failure of a person subpoenaed

25

under section 1102.4(3) (relating to powers and duties of

26

commission) to obey the command of the subpoena or to be sworn

27

or affirmed or to testify, an application may be made to the

28

court for the enforcement of the subpoena.

29

(b)  Contempt.--If a person who has been ordered by the court

30

to comply with a subpoena issued under section 1102.4(3) fails

- 24 -

 


1

to obey the command of the order, an application may be made to

2

the court for the person to be brought before the court

3

authorized to proceed against the person for civil contempt of

4

court.

5

Section 4.  Sections 1103 and 1104 of Title 65 are amended to

6

read:

7

§ 1103.  Restricted activities.

8

(a)  Conflict of interest.--No public official or public

9

employee shall engage in conduct that constitutes a conflict of

10

interest.

11

(b)  Seeking improper influence.--No person shall offer or

12

give to a public official, public employee or nominee or

13

candidate for public office or a member of his or her immediate

14

family or a business with which [he] the public official, public

15

employee or nominee or candidate for public office is associated

16

anything of monetary value, including a gift, loan, political

17

contribution, reward or promise of future employment based on

18

the offeror's or donor's understanding that the vote, official

19

action or judgment of the public official or public employee or

20

nominee or candidate for public office would be influenced

21

thereby.

22

(c)  Accepting improper influence.--No public official,

23

public employee or nominee or candidate for public office shall

24

solicit or accept anything of monetary value, including a gift,

25

loan, political contribution, reward or promise of future

26

employment, based on any understanding of that public official,

27

public employee or nominee that the vote, official action or

28

judgment of the public official or public employee or nominee or

29

candidate for public office would be influenced thereby.

30

(d)  Honorarium.--No public official or public employee shall

- 25 -

 


1

accept an honorarium.

2

(e)  Contingent and severance payments.--

3

(1)  No person shall solicit or accept a severance

4

payment or anything of monetary value contingent upon the

5

assumption or acceptance of public office or employment.

6

(2)  This subsection shall not prohibit:

7

(i)  Payments received pursuant to an employment

8

agreement in existence prior to the time a person becomes

9

a candidate or is notified by a member of a transition

10

team, a search committee or a person with appointive

11

power that [he] the person is under consideration for

12

public office or makes application for public employment.

13

(ii)  Receipt of a salary, fees, severance payment or

14

proceeds resulting from the sale of a person's interest

15

in a corporation, professional corporation, partnership

16

or other entity resulting from termination or withdrawal

17

therefrom upon the assumption or acceptance of public

18

office or employment.

19

(3)  Payments made or received pursuant to paragraph (2)

20

(i) and (ii) shall not be based on the agreement, written or

21

otherwise, that the vote or official action of the

22

prospective public official or employee would be influenced

23

thereby.

24

(f)  Contract.--No public official or public employee or

25

[his] spouse or child of the public official or public employee 

26

or any business in which the person [or his], spouse or child is

27

associated shall enter into any contract valued at $500 or more

28

with the governmental body with which the public official or

29

public employee is associated or any subcontract valued at $500

30

or more with any person who has been awarded a contract with the

- 26 -

 


1

governmental body with which the public official or public

2

employee is associated unless the contract has been awarded

3

through an open and public process, including prior public

4

notice and subsequent public disclosure of all proposals

5

considered and contracts awarded. In such a case, the public

6

official or public employee shall not have any supervisory or

7

overall responsibility for the implementation or administration

8

of the contract. Any contract or subcontract made in violation

9

of this subsection shall be voidable by a court of competent

10

jurisdiction if the suit is commenced within 90 days of the

11

making of the contract or subcontract.

12

(g)  Former official or employee.--No former public official

13

or public employee shall represent a person, with promised or

14

actual compensation, on any matter before the governmental body

15

with which [he] the former public official or public employee 

16

has been associated for one year after [he] the former public

17

official or public employee leaves that body.

18

(h)  Misuse of statement of financial interest.--No person

19

shall use for any commercial purpose information copied from

20

statements of financial interests required by this chapter or

21

from lists compiled from such statements.

22

(i)  Former executive-level employee.--No former executive-

23

level State employee may for a period of two years from the time

24

that [he] the executive-level State employee terminates

25

employment with this Commonwealth be employed by, receive

26

compensation from, assist or act in a representative capacity

27

for a business or corporation that [he] the former executive-

28

level State employee actively participated in recruiting to this

29

Commonwealth or that [he] the former executive-level State

30

employee actively participated in inducing to open a new plant,

- 27 -

 


1

facility or branch in this Commonwealth or that he actively

2

participated in inducing to expand an existent plant or facility

3

within this Commonwealth, provided that the above prohibition

4

shall be invoked only when the recruitment or inducement is

5

accomplished by a grant or loan of money or a promise of a grant

6

or loan of money from the Commonwealth to the business or

7

corporation recruited or induced to expand.

8

(j)  Voting conflict.--Where voting conflicts are not

9

otherwise addressed by the Constitution of Pennsylvania or by

10

any law, rule, regulation, order or ordinance, the following

11

procedure shall be employed. Any public official or public

12

employee who in the discharge of [his] official duties would be

13

required to vote on a matter that would result in a conflict of

14

interest shall abstain from voting and, prior to the vote being

15

taken, publicly announce and disclose the nature of [his] the 

16

interest as a public record in a written memorandum filed with

17

the person responsible for recording the minutes of the meeting

18

at which the vote is taken, provided that whenever a governing

19

body would be unable to take any action on a matter before it

20

because the number of members of the body required to abstain

21

from voting under the provisions of this section makes the

22

majority or other legally required vote of approval

23

unattainable, then such members shall be permitted to vote if

24

disclosures are made as otherwise provided herein. In the case

25

of a three-member governing body of a political subdivision,

26

where one member has abstained from voting as a result of a

27

conflict of interest and the remaining two members of the

28

governing body have cast opposing votes, the member who has

29

abstained shall be permitted to vote to break the tie vote if

30

disclosure is made as otherwise provided herein.

- 28 -

 


1

§ 1104.  Statement of financial interests required to be filed.

2

(a)  Public official or public employee.--Each public

3

official of the Commonwealth shall file a statement of financial

4

interests for the preceding calendar year with the commission no

5

later than May 1 of each year that [he] the public official 

6

holds such a position and of the year after [he leaves such a]

7

leaving the position. Each public employee and public official

8

of the Commonwealth shall file a statement of financial

9

interests for the preceding calendar year with the department,

10

agency, body or bureau [in which he] where the public employee

11

is employed or to which [he] the public official is appointed or

12

elected no later than May 1 of each year that [he holds such a

13

position] the position is held by the public official or public

14

employee and of the year after [he leaves such a] leaving the 

15

position. Any other public employee or public official shall

16

file a statement of financial interests with the governing

17

authority of the political subdivision [by which he is] where 

18

employed [or within which he is], appointed or elected no later

19

than May 1 of each year [that he holds such a] when holding the 

20

position and of the year after [he leaves such a] leaving the 

21

position. Persons who are full-time or part-time solicitors for

22

political subdivisions are required to file under this section.

23

(b)  Candidate.--

24

(1)  Any candidate for a State-level public office shall

25

file a statement of financial interests for the preceding

26

calendar year with the commission on or before the last day

27

for filing a petition to appear on the ballot for election. A

28

copy of the statement of financial interests shall also be

29

appended to such petition.

30

(2)  Any candidate for county-level or local office shall

- 29 -

 


1

file a statement of financial interests for the preceding

2

calendar year with the governing authority of the political

3

subdivision in which [he is a candidate] the candidate is

4

running on or before the last day for filing a petition to

5

appear on the ballot for election. A copy of the statement of

6

financial interests shall also be appended to such petition.

7

(3)  No petition to appear on the ballot for election

8

shall be accepted by the respective State or local election

9

officials unless the petition has appended thereto a

10

statement of financial interests as set forth in paragraphs

11

(1) and (2). Failure to file the statement in accordance with

12

the provisions of this chapter shall, in addition to any

13

other penalties provided, be a fatal defect to a petition to

14

appear on the ballot.

15

(c)  Nominee.--Each State-level nominee for public office

16

shall file a statement of financial interests for the preceding

17

calendar year with the commission and with the official or body

18

that is vested with the power of confirmation at least ten days

19

before the official or body shall approve or reject the

20

nomination. Each nominee for a county-level or local office

21

shall file a statement of financial interests for the preceding

22

calendar year with the governing authority of the political

23

subdivision in which he or she is a nominee and, if different,

24

with the official or body that is vested with the power of

25

confirmation at least ten days before the official or body shall

26

approve or reject the nomination.

27

(d)  Failure to file required statement.--No public official

28

shall be allowed to take the oath of office or enter or continue

29

upon [his duties] the duties of the office, nor shall [he] the

30

public official receive compensation from public funds, unless

- 30 -

 


1

[he] the public official has filed a statement of financial

2

interests as required by this chapter.

3

(e)  Public inspection and copying.--All statements of

4

financial interests filed pursuant to the provisions of this

5

chapter shall be made available for public inspection and

6

copying during regular office hours, and copying facilities

7

shall be made available at a charge not to exceed actual cost.

8

Section 5.  Sections 1106 and 1107 of Title 65 are repealed:

9

[§ 1106.  State Ethics Commission.

10

(a)  Continuation of commission.--The State Ethics Commission

11

established under the act of October 4, 1978 (P.L.883, No.170),

12

referred to as the Public Official and Employee Ethics Law, is

13

continued and shall be composed of seven members. The President

14

pro tempore of the Senate, the Minority Leader of the Senate,

15

the Speaker of the House and the Minority Leader of the House

16

shall each appoint one member. Three members shall be appointed

17

by the Governor without confirmation. No more than two of the

18

members appointed by the Governor shall be of the same political

19

party. No appointee shall have served as an officer in a

20

political party for one year prior to his appointment.

21

(b)  Term of service.--Members of the commission shall serve

22

for terms of three years, except that members shall continue to

23

serve until their successors are appointed and qualified.

24

(c)  Maximum number of terms.--No member shall be appointed

25

to more than two full three-year terms on the commission.

26

(d)  Prohibited activities.--No individual while a member or

27

employee of the commission shall:

28

(1)  hold or campaign for any other public office;

29

(2)  hold office in any political party or political

30

committee;

- 31 -

 


1

(3)  actively participate in or contribute to any

2

political campaign;

3

(4)  directly or indirectly attempt to influence any

4

decision by a governmental body other than a court of law or

5

as a representative of the commission on a matter within the

6

jurisdiction of the commission; or

7

(5)  be employed by the Commonwealth or a political

8

subdivision in any other capacity, whether or not for

9

compensation.

10

(e)  Vacancy.--A majority of the commission by resolution

11

shall declare vacant the position on the commission of any

12

member who takes part in activities prohibited by subsection

13

(d). An individual appointed to fill a vacancy occurring other

14

than by the expiration of a term of office shall be appointed

15

for the unexpired term of the member he succeeds and is eligible

16

for appointment to two full three-year terms thereafter. Any

17

vacancy occurring on the commission shall be filled within 30

18

days in the manner in which that position was originally filled.

19

(f)  Election of chairman and vice chairman.--The commission

20

shall elect a chairman and a vice chairman. The vice chairman

21

shall act as chairman in the absence of the chairman or in the

22

event of a vacancy in that position.

23

(g)  Quorum.--Four members of the commission shall constitute

24

a quorum, and, except as provided in section 1108(g) (relating

25

to investigations by commission), the votes of a majority of the

26

members present are required for any action or recommendation of

27

the commission. The chairman or any four members of the

28

commission may call a meeting provided that advance written

29

notice is mailed to each member and to any person who requests

30

notice of such meetings.

- 32 -

 


1

(h)  Compensation.--Members of the commission shall be

2

compensated at a rate of $250 per day and shall receive

3

reimbursement for their actual and necessary expenses while

4

performing the business of the commission.

5

(i)  Staff.--The commission shall employ an executive

6

director, a chief counsel and such other staff as are necessary

7

to carry out its duties pursuant to this chapter. The executive

8

director shall be responsible for the administrative operations

9

of the commission and shall perform such other duties as may be

10

delegated or assigned to him by the commission, except that the

11

commission shall not delegate the making of regulations to the

12

executive director. The chief counsel shall be the chief legal

13

officer of the commission. The commission may obtain the

14

services of experts and consultants as necessary to carry out

15

its duties pursuant to this chapter. The State Treasurer and the

16

Attorney General shall make available to the commission such

17

personnel, facilities and other assistance as the commission may

18

request.

19

(j)  Regulations.--The commission shall develop regulations

20

that provide for a code of conduct to govern the activities and

21

ethical standards of its members, which code shall subject the

22

members of the commission to no less than is required for public

23

officials or public employees under this chapter.

24

§ 1107.  Powers and duties of commission.

25

In addition to other powers and duties prescribed by law, the

26

commission shall:

27

(1)  Prescribe and publish rules and regulations to carry

28

out the provisions of this chapter.

29

(2)  Prescribe forms for statements and reports required

30

to be filed by this chapter and furnish such forms to persons

- 33 -

 


1

required to file such statements and reports.

2

(3)  Prepare and publish guidelines setting forth

3

recommended uniform methods of accounting and reporting for

4

use by persons required to file statements and reports by

5

this chapter.

6

(4)  Accept and file any information voluntarily supplied

7

that exceeds the requirements of this chapter.

8

(5)  Inspect statements of financial interests which have

9

been filed in order to ascertain whether any reporting person

10

has failed to file such a statement or has filed a deficient

11

statement. If, upon inspection, it is determined that a

12

reporting person has failed to file a statement of financial

13

interests or that any statement which has been filed fails to

14

conform with the requirements of section 1105 (relating to

15

statement of financial interests), then the commission shall

16

in writing notify the person. Such notice shall state in

17

detail the deficiency and the penalties for failure to file

18

or for filing a deficient statement of financial interests.

19

(6)  Provide that statements and reports filed with the

20

commission be made available for public inspection and

21

copying during regular office hours and provide that copying

22

facilities be made available at a charge not to exceed actual

23

cost and advise other State and local agencies of the

24

provisions of this paragraph.

25

(7)  Compile and maintain an index of all reports and

26

statements filed with the commission to facilitate public

27

access to such reports and statements and instruct other

28

State and local agencies which receive and file financial

29

interest statements in the maintenance of systems which

30

facilitate public access to such statements.

- 34 -

 


1

(8)  Prepare and publish annual summaries of statements

2

and reports filed with the commission.

3

(9)  Preserve statements and reports filed with the

4

commission for a period of five years from date of receipt

5

and advise other State and local agencies which receive and

6

store financial interest statements to preserve such

7

statements for a period of five years from date of receipt.

8

(10)  Issue to any person upon such person's request or

9

to the appointing authority or employer of that person upon

10

the request of such appointing authority or employer an

11

opinion with respect to such person's duties under this

12

chapter. The commission shall, within 14 days, either issue

13

the opinion or advise the person who made the request whether

14

an opinion will be issued. No person who acts in good faith

15

on an opinion issued to him by the commission shall be

16

subject to criminal or civil penalties for so acting,

17

provided that the material facts are as stated in the opinion

18

request. The commission's opinions shall be public records

19

and may from time to time be published. The person requesting

20

the opinion may, however, require that the opinion shall

21

contain such deletions and changes as shall be necessary to

22

protect the identity of the persons involved.

23

(11)  Provide written advice to any person or the

24

appointing authority or employer of such person upon their

25

request with respect to such person's duties under this

26

chapter. Such advice shall be provided within 21 working days

27

of the request, provided that the time may be extended for

28

good cause. It shall be a complete defense in any enforcement

29

proceeding initiated by the commission and evidence of good

30

faith conduct in any other civil or criminal proceeding if

- 35 -

 


1

the requester, at least 21 working days prior to the alleged

2

violation, requested written advice from the commission in

3

good faith, disclosed truthfully all the material facts and

4

committed the acts complained of either in reliance on the

5

advice or because of the failure of the commission to provide

6

advice within 21 days of the request or such later extended

7

time. The person requesting the advice may, however, require

8

that the advice shall contain such deletions and changes as

9

shall be necessary to protect the identity of the persons

10

involved.

11

(12)  Initiate an inquiry pursuant to section 1108(a)

12

(relating to investigations by commission) where a complaint

13

has not been filed but where there is a reasonable belief

14

that a conflict may exist.

15

(13)  Issue findings, reports and orders relating to

16

investigations initiated pursuant to section 1108 which set

17

forth the alleged violation, findings of fact and conclusions

18

of law. An order may include recommendations to law

19

enforcement officials. Any order resulting from a finding

20

that a public official or public employee has obtained a

21

financial gain in violation of this chapter may require the

22

restitution plus interest of that gain to the appropriate

23

governmental body. The commission or the Office of Attorney

24

General shall have standing to apply to the Commonwealth

25

Court to seek enforcement of an order requiring such

26

restitution. This restitution requirement shall be in

27

addition to any other penalties provided for in this chapter.

28

(14)  Hold hearings, take testimony, issue subpoenas and

29

compel the attendance of witnesses.

30

(15)  Make recommendations to law enforcement officials

- 36 -

 


1

either for criminal prosecution or dismissal of charges

2

arising out of violations of this chapter.

3

(16)  Prepare and publish special reports, educational

4

materials and technical studies to further the purposes of

5

this chapter.

6

(17)  Prepare and publish prior to June 1 of each year an

7

annual report summarizing the activities of the commission.

8

(18)  Transmit, free of charge, copies of each order,

9

advice and opinion which has become a matter of public record

10

quarterly to the law library of each county, one public

11

library in each county, the State Library, the State Senate

12

Library, each authority appointing commission members under

13

this chapter, the Pennsylvania Association of County

14

Commissioners, the Pennsylvania Association of Boroughs, the

15

Pennsylvania State Association of Township Supervisors, the

16

Pennsylvania State Association of Township Commissioners, the

17

Pennsylvania School Boards Association and the Pennsylvania

18

League of Cities.

19

(19)  Hold at least two public hearings each year, of

20

which at least one shall be held in Harrisburg and at least

21

one shall be held in a location other than Harrisburg, to

22

seek input from persons and organizations who represent any

23

individual subject to the provisions of this chapter and from

24

other interested parties.]

25

Section 6.  Sections 1108 and 1109(c) and (f) of Title 65 are

26

amended to read:

27

§ 1108.  Investigations of violations of this chapter by

28

commission.

29

(a)  Preliminary inquiry.--Upon a complaint signed under

30

penalty of perjury by any person or upon its own motion, the

- 37 -

 


1

commission[, through its executive director,] shall conduct a

2

preliminary inquiry into any alleged violation of [this chapter]

3

section 1103 (relating to restricted activities), 1104 (relating

4

to statement of financial interests required to be filed),

5

1105(a) (relating to statement of financial interests) or this

6

section. The commission shall keep information, records and

7

proceedings relating to a preliminary inquiry confidential. The

8

commission shall, however, have the authority to refer the case

9

[to law enforcement officials] for prosecution during a

10

preliminary inquiry or anytime thereafter without providing

11

notice to the subject of the inquiry. The commission shall

12

complete its preliminary inquiry within 60 days of its

13

initiation.

14

(b)  Termination of preliminary inquiry.--If a preliminary

15

inquiry fails to establish reason to believe that [this chapter

16

has] section 1103, 1104, 1105(a) or this section has been

17

violated, the commission shall terminate the inquiry and so

18

notify the complainant and the person who had been the subject

19

of the inquiry. If the commission determines that a complaint is

20

frivolous, it shall so state.

21

(c)  Initiation of investigation.--If a preliminary inquiry

22

establishes reason to believe that [this chapter has] section

23

1103, 1104, 1105(a) or this section has been violated, the

24

commission may, through its executive director, initiate an

25

investigation to determine if there has been a violation. The

26

commission shall keep information, records and proceedings

27

relating to an investigation confidential until a final

28

determination is made, except as otherwise provided in

29

subsection (g). No investigation may be commenced until the

30

person who is the subject of the investigation has been notified

- 38 -

 


1

and provided a general statement of the alleged violation or

2

violations of this chapter and other applicable statutes with

3

respect to such investigation. Service of notice is complete

4

upon mailing which shall be by certified or registered mail. The

5

commission shall notify the complainant within 72 hours of the

6

commencement of an investigation, and, thereafter, the

7

commission shall advise the complainant and the person who is

8

the subject of the investigation of the status of the

9

investigation at least every 90 days until the investigation is

10

terminated. The commission shall, within 180 days of the

11

initiation of an investigation, either terminate the

12

investigation pursuant to subsection (d) or issue a findings

13

report pursuant to subsection (e). Upon a showing by the

14

executive director of the need for extension of this period, the

15

commission may extend an investigation for up to two 90-day

16

periods, provided that each 90-day extension shall be approved

17

by a majority vote of members present. In no event shall a

18

findings report be issued later than 360 days after initiation

19

of an investigation.

20

(d)  Termination of investigation.--If an investigation

21

conducted under this [chapter] section indicates that no

22

violation has been committed, the commission shall immediately

23

terminate the investigation and send written notice of such

24

determination to the complainant and the person who was the

25

subject of the investigation.

26

(e)  Findings report.--The commission, upon the completion of

27

an investigation under this section, shall issue a findings

28

report to the subject of the investigation setting forth the

29

pertinent findings of fact. The subject shall have the right to

30

respond to said findings and to request an evidentiary hearing

- 39 -

 


1

on said matter. The commission shall grant any request for a

2

hearing. Said hearing shall be held in Harrisburg or, at the

3

request of the subject, in either Philadelphia or Pittsburgh.

4

Any response to the findings report must either admit or deny by

5

corresponding number and letter the pertinent facts set forth.

6

The subject of the investigation shall have access to any

7

evidence intended to be used by the commission at the hearing

8

and any exculpatory evidence developed by the commission in the

9

course of its investigation. Matters not specifically denied in

10

the response shall be deemed admitted. The response must be

11

filed within 30 days of the issuance of the findings report

12

unless the time period is extended by the commission for good

13

cause shown. Hearings conducted upon request shall be instituted

14

within 45 days after the filing of the response.

15

(f)  Final order.--Within 30 days of the receipt by the

16

commission of the hearing record or, if no hearing is to be

17

held, within 30 days of the receipt by the commission of the

18

response to the findings report, the commission shall issue an

19

order which shall be final. Upon receipt of a final order, the

20

subject shall have the right to file a petition for

21

reconsideration in accordance with the regulations of the

22

commission.

23

(g)  Procedure for hearing.--Hearings conducted pursuant to

24

this section concerning an allegation that section 1103, 1104,

25

1105(a) or this section has been violated shall be closed to the

26

public unless the subject requests an open hearing. Any person

27

who appears before the commission shall have all of the due

28

process rights, privileges and responsibilities of a party or

29

witness appearing before an administrative agency of this

30

Commonwealth. All witnesses summoned for such hearings shall

- 40 -

 


1

receive reimbursement for reasonable expenses in accordance with

2

42 Pa.C.S. § 5903 (relating to compensation and expenses of

3

witnesses). At the conclusion of a hearing concerning an alleged

4

violation and in a timely manner, the commission shall

5

deliberate on the evidence and determine whether there has been

6

a violation of [this chapter] section 1103, 1104, 1105(a) or

7

this section. At least four members of the commission present at

8

a meeting must find a violation by clear and convincing proof.

9

The names of the members finding a violation and the names of

10

those dissenting and abstaining shall be listed in the order.

11

The determination of the commission, in the form of a final

12

order and findings of fact, shall be a matter of public record.

13

(h)  Availability of final orders, files and records.--Orders

14

which become final in accordance with the provisions of this

15

section shall be available as public documents, but the files

16

and records of the commission relating to the case shall remain

17

confidential.

18

(i)  Appeal.--Any person aggrieved by an opinion or order

19

which becomes final in accordance with the provisions of this

20

[chapter] section who has direct interest in such opinion or

21

order shall have the right to appeal therefrom in accordance

22

with law and general rules.

23

(j)  Retaliation prohibited.--No public official or public

24

employee shall discharge any official or employee or change his

25

official rank, grade or compensation or deny him a promotion or

26

threaten to do so for filing a complaint with or providing

27

information to the commission or testifying in any commission

28

proceeding. No member of the commission and no employee of the

29

commission shall discharge any employee of the commission or

30

change his official rank, grade or compensation or threaten to

- 41 -

 


1

do so for providing any information about the internal

2

operations of the commission, not required by law to be kept

3

secret, to any legislator or legislative staff member or

4

testifying in any legislative proceeding.

5

(k)  Confidentiality.--As a general rule, no person shall

6

disclose or acknowledge to any other person any information

7

relating to a complaint, preliminary inquiry, investigation,

8

hearing or petition for reconsideration which is before the

9

commission. However, a person may disclose or acknowledge to

10

another person matters held confidential in accordance with this

11

subsection when the matters pertain to any of the following:

12

(1)  final orders of the commission as provided in

13

subsection (h);

14

(2)  hearings conducted in public pursuant to subsection

15

(g);

16

(3)  for the purpose of seeking advice of legal counsel;

17

(4)  filing an appeal from a commission order;

18

(5)  communicating with the commission or its staff, in

19

the course of a preliminary inquiry, investigation, hearing

20

or petition for reconsideration by the commission;

21

(6)  consulting with a law enforcement official or agency

22

for the purpose of initiating, participating in or responding

23

to an investigation or prosecution by the law enforcement

24

official or agency;

25

(7)  testifying under oath before a governmental body or

26

a similar body of the United States of America;

27

(8)  any information, records or proceedings relating to

28

a complaint, preliminary inquiry, investigation, hearing or

29

petition for reconsideration which the person is the subject

30

of; or

- 42 -

 


1

(9)  such other exceptions as the commission by

2

regulation may direct.

3

(l)  Frivolous complaints and wrongful disclosure.--If a

4

public official or public employee has reason to believe the

5

complaint for a violation of section 1103, 1104, 1105(a) or this

6

section is frivolous as defined by this chapter, or without

7

probable cause and made primarily for a purpose other than that

8

of reporting a violation of this chapter, or a person publicly

9

disclosed or caused to be disclosed that a complaint against the

10

public official or public employee has been filed with the

11

commission, the public official or public employee shall notify

12

the commission and the commission, through its executive

13

director, shall conduct an investigation.

14

(m)  Limitation of time.--The commission may conduct an

15

investigation under this section within five years after the

16

alleged occurrence of any violation of this chapter.

17

§ 1109.  Penalties.

18

* * *

19

(c)  Treble damages.--Any person who obtains financial gain

20

from violating any provision of [this chapter] section 1103

21

(relating to restricted activities), 1104 (relating to statement

22

of financial interests required to be filed), 1105(a) (relating

23

to statement of financial interests) or 1108 (relating to

24

investigations of violations of this chapter by commission), in

25

addition to any other penalty provided by law, shall pay a sum

26

of money equal to three times the amount of the financial gain

27

resulting from such violation into the State Treasury or the

28

treasury of the political subdivision. Treble damages shall not

29

be assessed against a person who acted in good faith reliance on

30

the advice of legal counsel.

- 43 -

 


1

* * *

2

(f)  Civil penalty.--In addition to any other civil remedy or

3

criminal penalty provided for in this chapter, the commission

4

may, after notice has been served in accordance with section

5

[1107(5)] 1102.4(9) (relating to powers and duties of

6

commission) and upon a majority vote of its members, levy a

7

civil penalty upon any person subject to this chapter who fails

8

to file a statement of financial interests in a timely manner or

9

who files a deficient statement of financial interests, at a

10

rate of not more than $25 for each day such statement remains

11

delinquent or deficient. The maximum penalty payable under this

12

paragraph is $250.

13

* * *

14

Section 7.  Title 65 is amended by adding a section to read:

15

§ 1109.1.  Costs, restitution and forfeiture.

16

The commission shall be entitled to an equitable share, as

17

determined by the court, of:

18

(1)  Assets seized or forfeited as a result, in whole or

19

part, of an investigation by the commission.

20

(2)  Award of costs of prosecution or other fees or costs

21

awarded as a result of a conviction for any criminal offense

22

based, in whole or part, on an investigation by the

23

commission.

24

Section 8.  Section 1110 of Title 65 is amended to read:

25

§ 1110.  Wrongful use of chapter.

26

(a)  Liability.--A person who signs a complaint alleging a

27

violation of [this chapter] section 1103 (relating to restricted

28

activities), 1104 (relating to statement of financial interests

29

required to be filed), 1105(a) (relating to statement of

30

financial interests) or 1108 (relating to investigations of

- 44 -

 


1

violations of this chapter by commission) against another is

2

subject to liability for wrongful use of this chapter if:

3

(1)  the complaint was frivolous, as defined by this

4

chapter, or without probable cause and made primarily for a

5

purpose other than that of reporting a violation of this

6

chapter; or

7

(2)  he publicly disclosed or caused to be disclosed that

8

a complaint against a person had been filed with the

9

commission.

10

(b)  Probable cause.--A person who signs a complaint alleging

11

a violation of [this chapter] section 1103, 1104, 1105(a) or

12

1108 has probable cause for doing so if he reasonably believes

13

in the existence of the facts upon which the claim is based and

14

either:

15

(1)  reasonably believes that under those facts the

16

complaint may be valid under this chapter; or

17

(2)  believes to this effect in reliance upon the advice

18

of counsel, sought in good faith and given after full

19

disclosure of all relevant facts within his knowledge and

20

information.

21

(c)  Commission procedures.--When the commission determines

22

that a complainant has violated the provisions set forth in

23

subsection (a), the commission, upon receiving a written request

24

from the subject of the complaint, shall provide the name and

25

address of the complainant to said subject. If the commission

26

determines that a complainant has not violated the provisions of

27

subsection (a), the commission shall notify the subject

28

accordingly. The subject shall have the right to appeal the

29

commission's determination, and the commission shall schedule an

30

appeal hearing. The subject shall show cause why the complainant

- 45 -

 


1

violated the provisions of this section. If the commission

2

grants the appeal, the commission shall immediately release the

3

complainant's name and address to the subject. If the commission

4

denies the appeal, it shall present evidence why the

5

complainant's name and address shall not be released.

6

(d)  Damages.--When the essential elements of an action

7

brought pursuant to this section have been established, the

8

plaintiff is entitled to recover for the following:

9

(1)  The harm to his reputation by a defamatory matter

10

alleged as the basis of the proceeding.

11

(2)  The expenses, including any reasonable attorney

12

fees, that he has reasonably incurred in proceedings before

13

the commission.

14

(3)  Any specific pecuniary loss that has resulted from

15

the proceedings.

16

(4)  Any emotional distress that has been caused by the

17

proceedings.

18

(5)  Any punitive damages according to law in appropriate

19

cases.

20

Section 9.  Title 65 is amended by adding sections to read:

21

§ 1110.1.  Disclosure of executive session testimony and

22

investigative records.

23

No testimony taken in executive session, a part thereof, or a

24

summary thereof and no investigative record, a part thereof, or

25

a summary thereof, may be released or disclosed to a person

26

either orally or in writing by a commissioner or employee of the

27

commission without the authorization of the commission.

28

§ 1110.2.  Privileged statements and reports.

29

A statement or disclosure of information made by a

30

commissioner or an employee of the commission during the course

- 46 -

 


1

of a hearing or official proceeding and a report issued by the

2

commission before the General Assembly or to another law

3

enforcement agency shall be absolutely privileged. The privilege

4

shall be an absolute defense to an action for invasion of

5

privacy, defamation or other civil or criminal action.

6

§ 1110.3.  Commission disclosure of economic interests.

7

(a)  Disclosure statement.--As of the date of appointment to

8

the commission and on or before March 15 of each following year,

9

each commissioner shall file with the Governor, the Secretary of

10

the Senate and the Chief Clerk of the House of Representatives

11

for the preceding calendar year a sworn statement of economic

12

interests. The economic interests statement shall contain the

13

information required under subsection (e). Once the economic

14

interests statement has been filed under this chapter, the

15

statement shall be updated annually by filing a supplemental

16

statement. The economic interests of a spouse or child of a

17

commissioner who is under 18 years of age shall be deemed an

18

economic interest of a commissioner.

19

(b)  Record.--The Governor, the Secretary of the Senate and

20

the Chief Clerk of the House of Representatives shall maintain

21

the economic interests statements filed by commissioners as

22

public records which shall be open for public examination and

23

copying, at cost, at all reasonable times. The economic

24

interests statements shall remain on file for five years from

25

the initial date of filing.

26

(c)  Requirements.--The commission shall promulgate

27

regulations to be published in the Pennsylvania Bulletin

28

regarding economic disclosure requirements for employees of the

29

commission.

30

(d)  Penalties.--In addition to other penalties imposed by

- 47 -

 


1

law for false swearing, neglect or refusal of a commissioner or

2

employee to file a complete and accurate economic interests

3

statement under the requirements of this section or the willful

4

filing of an inaccurate statement shall constitute misfeasance

5

in office in the case of commissioners and shall constitute

6

grounds for dismissal in the case of employees.

7

(e)  Contents.--The sworn economic interests statement shall

8

contain:

9

(1)  The identity of offices and directorships by name.

10

(2)  An identifying description of real estate in this

11

Commonwealth in which the commissioner or a member of the

12

commissioner's household has an interest, direct or indirect,

13

including an option to buy, provided that a commissioner's

14

primary place of residence shall not be included.

15

(3)  The name of each creditor to whom the commissioner

16

or a member of the commissioner's household owes money in

17

excess of $6,500, the category of the amount owed and the

18

interest rate, provided that loans or credit extended between

19

members of the immediate family and a mortgage upon the

20

commissioner's primary place of residence shall not be

21

included.

22

(4)  The name of each business, insurance policy or trust

23

in which the commissioner or a member of the commissioner's

24

household has a financial interest and the nature and

25

category of the amount of the interest.

26

(5)  The source, by name, and category of the amounts of

27

income in excess of $1,300, including capital gains, whether

28

or not taxable, received by the commissioner or a member of

29

the commissioner's household during the preceding year.

30

(6)  A list of businesses with which a commissioner is

- 48 -

 


1

associated that do business with or are regulated by the

2

Commonwealth and a description of the nature of the business

3

or regulation.

4

(7)  A salary, fee, commission or other income, listed in

5

dollar amount or value, received by a commissioner from a

6

political subdivision of this Commonwealth or an agency of

7

the Commonwealth, other than the commission, including the

8

name of the political subdivision or agency or from an entity

9

which maintains a person required to be registered as a

10

lobbyist under any law requiring the registration.

11

(f)  Amounts.--Where an amount is required to be reported by

12

category, the individual shall report whether the amount is less

13

than $5,000, at least $5,000 but less than $10,000, at least

14

$10,000 but less than $25,000 or $25,000 or more. An amount of

15

stock may be reported by number of shares instead of by category

16

of dollar value.

17

(g)  Additional disclosure.--No provision of this chapter

18

shall be interpreted to prevent a person from filing more

19

information or more detailed information than required on an

20

economic interests statement.

21

§ 1111.1.  Applicable statutes.

22

The provisions of Chs. 7 (relating to open meetings) and 11

23

(relating to ethics standards and financial disclosure) shall

24

apply to the commission except as otherwise provided in this

25

chapter.

26

Section 10.  This act shall take effect in 60 days.

- 49 -