PRINTER'S NO.  2939

  

THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF PENNSYLVANIA

  

HOUSE BILL

 

No.

2113

Session of

2012

  

  

INTRODUCED BY VITALI, HANNA, FRANKEL, GEORGE, STURLA, B. BOYLE, K. BOYLE, BRADFORD, BRIGGS, V. BROWN, CALTAGIRONE, COHEN, D. COSTA, CURRY, DAVIS, DAVIDSON, DELISSIO, FREEMAN, GERBER, GOODMAN, HARPER, HICKERNELL, HORNAMAN, JOSEPHS, MAHONEY, MUNDY, M. O'BRIEN, PARKER, PAYTON, QUINN, SAMUELSON, SANTARSIERO, K. SMITH AND YOUNGBLOOD, JANUARY 10, 2012

  

  

REFERRED TO COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES AND ENERGY, JANUARY 10, 2012  

  

  

  

AN ACT

  

1

Amending Title 35 (Health and Safety) of the Pennsylvania

2

Consolidated Statutes, consolidating the Air Pollution

3

Control Act; providing for air contaminant emissions, for

4

exemptions from air pollution requirements for unconventional

5

gas production processes prohibited and for permit fees; and

6

making a related repeal.

7

The General Assembly of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania

8

hereby enacts as follows:

9

Section 1.  Title 35 of the Pennsylvania Consolidated

10

Statutes is amended by adding a chapter to read:

11

CHAPTER 21

12

AIR POLLUTION CONTROL

13

Subchapter

14

A.  Preliminary Provisions

15

B.  Regulatory Program

16

SUBCHAPTER A

17

PRELIMINARY PROVISIONS

 


1

Sec.

2

2101.  Scope of chapter.

3

2102.  Declaration of policy.

4

2103.  Definitions.

5

§ 2101.  Scope of chapter.

6

This chapter relates to air pollution control.

7

§ 2102.  Declaration of policy.

8

The General Assembly finds and declares as follows:

9

(1)  It is the policy of the Commonwealth to protect the

10

air resources of this Commonwealth to the degree necessary

11

for the:

12

(i)  protection of public health, safety and well-

13

being of its citizens;

14

(ii)  prevention of injury to plant and animal life

15

and to property;

16

(iii)  protection of the comfort and convenience of

17

the public and the protection of the recreational

18

resources of this Commonwealth;

19

(iv)  development, attraction and expansion of

20

industry, commerce and agriculture; and

21

(v)  implementation of the provisions of the Clean

22

Air Act in this Commonwealth.

23

(2)  Interstate pollution transport commissions

24

established under the Clean Air Act should develop pollution

25

control strategies via a process which involves public review

26

and opportunity for comment.

27

(3)  The public should be involved in developing and

28

committing the Commonwealth to the adoption of particular

29

pollution control strategies through review of State

30

implementation plans required to be submitted by the Clean

- 2 -

 


1

Air Act.

2

(4)  The department should have adequate staff and

3

technical resources needed to comply with the Clean Air Act.

4

The department shall be required to explore the role private

5

industry can play in developing and implementing the clean

6

air programs as a mechanism to ensure that the Commonwealth

7

meets Clean Air Act deadlines.

8

(5)  States should not be penalized for missing Clean Air

9

Act deadlines when the delay is the result of the Federal

10

Government not finalizing guidance to states on implementing

11

the act. The Commonwealth and other states must be given a

12

reasonable opportunity to meet Clean Air Act deadlines.

13

(6)  The purpose of this subchapter is to provide

14

additional and cumulative remedies to abate the pollution of

15

the air of this Commonwealth.

16

§ 2103.  Definitions.

17

The following words and phrases when used in this chapter

18

shall have the meanings given to them in this section unless the

19

context clearly indicates otherwise:

20

"Administrator."  The Administrator of the United States

21

Environmental Protection Agency.

22

"Air contaminant."  Smoke, dust, fume, gas, odor, mist,

23

radioactive substance, vapor, pollen or any combination of them.

24

"Air contamination."  The presence in the outdoor atmosphere

25

of an air contaminant which contributes to any condition of air

26

pollution.

27

"Air contamination source."  Any place, facility or

28

equipment, stationary or mobile, at, from or by reason of which

29

there is emitted into the outdoor atmosphere any air

30

contaminant.

- 3 -

 


1

"Air pollution."  The presence in the outdoor atmosphere of

2

any form of contaminant, including the discharging from stacks,

3

chimneys, openings, buildings, structures, open fires, vehicles,

4

processes or any other source of any smoke, soot, fly ash, dust,

5

cinders, dirt, noxious or obnoxious acids, fumes, oxides, gases,

6

vapors, odors, toxic, hazardous or radioactive substances, waste

7

or any other matter in a place, manner or concentration inimical

8

or which may be inimical to the public health, safety or welfare

9

or which is or may be injurious to human, plant or animal life

10

or to property or which unreasonably interferes with the

11

comfortable enjoyment of life or property.

12

"Approved air pollution control agency."  An air pollution

13

control agency of any political subdivision of the Commonwealth

14

which has been granted approval by the Environmental Quality

15

Board.

16

"Board" or "EQB."  The Environmental Quality Board.

17

"Clean Air Act."  (Public Law 95-95, 42 U.S.C. § 7401 et

18

seq.).

19

"Department."  The Department of Environmental Resources of

20

the Commonwealth.

21

"Environmental Protection Agency" or "EPA."  The United

22

States Environmental Protection Agency or the Administrator of

23

the United States Environmental Protection Agency.

24

"Gasoline-dispensing facility."  A facility from which

25

gasoline is transferred to motor vehicle fuel tanks.

26

"Hearing board."  The Environmental Hearing Board.

27

"Person."  Any individual, public or private corporation for

28

profit or not for profit, association, partnership, firm, trust,

29

estate, department, board, bureau or agency of the Federal

30

Government or the Commonwealth, political subdivision,

- 4 -

 


1

municipality, district, authority or any other legal entity

2

which is recognized by law as the subject of rights and duties.

3

"Plan approval."  The written approval from the Department of

4

Environmental Resources which authorizes a person to construct,

5

assemble, install or modify any stationary air contamination

6

source or install on the source any air pollution control

7

equipment or device.

8

"Region."  Any geographical subdivision of this Commonwealth

9

whose boundaries shall be determined by the Environmental

10

Quality Board.

11

"Small business stationary source."  A stationary source

12

that:

13

(1)  is owned or operated by a person that employs 100 or

14

fewer individuals;

15

(2)  is a small business as defined in the Small Business

16

Act (Public Law 85-536, 15 U.S.C. § 78a et seq.);

17

(3)  is not a major stationary source;

18

(4)  does not emit 50 tons per year of any regulated

19

pollutant; and

20

(5)  emits less than 75 tons per year of all regulated

21

pollutants.

22

"State implementation plan."  The plan or plan revision that

23

a state is authorized and required to submit under section 110

24

of the Clean Air Act (Public Law 95-95, 42 U.S.C. § 7410) to

25

provide for attainment of the national ambient air quality

26

standards.

27

"Stationary air contamination source."  Any air contamination

28

source other than that which, when operated, moves in a given

29

direction under its own power.

30

SUBCHAPTER B

- 5 -

 


1

REGULATORY PROGRAM

2

Sec.

3

2111.  (Reserved).

4

2112.  (Reserved).

5

2113.  (Reserved).

6

2114.  Administration.

7

2114.1.  Agricultural regulations prohibited.

8

2114.2.  Permissible actions.

9

2114.3.  Evaluation.

10

2115.  Environmental Quality Board.

11

2116.  Environmental Hearing Board.

12

2116.1. Plan approvals and permits.

13

2116.2.  Emergency procedure.

14

2116.3.  Fees.

15

2116.4.  Fee for certain ozone areas.

16

2116.5.  Acid deposition control.

17

2116.6.  Hazardous air pollutants.

18

2116.7.  Control of volatile organic compounds from gasoline-

19

dispensing facilities.

20

2117.  Public hearings.

21

2117.1.  Compliance review.

22

2117.2.  Permit compliance schedules.

23

2117.3.  Responsibilities of owners and operators.

24

2117.4. Interstate transport commission.

25

2117.5.  Public review of State implementation plans.

26

2117.6.  Advice to department.

27

2117.7.  Small Business Compliance Assistance Program.

28

2117.8.  Compliance Advisory Committee.

29

2117.9.  Small Business Ombudsman.

30

2117.10.  Transportation management associations.

- 6 -

 


1

2117.11.  Notice of sanctions.

2

2117.12.  Missed Federal deadlines.

3

2118.  Unlawful conduct.

4

2119.  Penalties.

5

2119.1.  Civil penalties.

6

2119.2.  Disposition of fees, fines and civil penalties.

7

2119.3.  Continuing violations.

8

2120.  (Reserved).

9

2120.1.  Enforcement orders.

10

2120.2.  Appealable actions.

11

2120.3.  Limitation on action.

12

2131.  Powers reserved to the department under existing laws.

13

2132.  Powers reserved to political subdivisions.

14

2132.1.  Construction.

15

2133.  Public nuisance.

16

2133.1.  Search warrant.

17

2133.2.  Confidential information.

18

2133.3.  Air contaminant emissions.

19

2133.4.  Exemptions from air pollution requirements for

20

unconventional gas production processes prohibited.

21

2133.5.  (Reserved).

22

2133.6.  Action to abate nuisance and restrain violation.

23

§ 2111.  (Reserved).

24

§ 2112.  (Reserved).

25

§ 2113.  (Reserved).

26

§ 2114.  Administration.

27

The department shall have the power and its duty shall be to:

28

(1)  Implement the provisions of the Clean Air Act in

29

this Commonwealth.

30

(2)  Enter any building, property, premises or place and

- 7 -

 


1

inspect any air contamination source for the purpose of

2

investigating an actual or a suspected source of air

3

pollution or for the purpose of ascertaining the compliance

4

or noncompliance with this subchapter, a regulation

5

promulgated under this subchapter or any plan approval,

6

permit or order of the department. In connection with the

7

inspection or investigation, samples of air, air

8

contaminants, fuel, process material or other matter may be

9

taken for analysis, a duplicate of the analytical report

10

shall be furnished promptly to the person who is suspected of

11

causing air pollution or air contamination.

12

(3)  Have access to, and require the production of,

13

books, papers and records, including, but not limited to,

14

computerized information in a format as the department may

15

reasonably prescribe pertinent to any matter under

16

investigation.

17

(4)  Require the owner or operator of any air

18

contamination source to establish and maintain records and

19

make reports and furnish the information, including

20

computerized information, in a format as the department may

21

reasonably prescribe.

22

(5)  Require the owner or operator of any air

23

contamination source to install, use and maintain air

24

contaminant monitoring equipment or methods as the department

25

may reasonably prescribe.

26

(6)  Require the owner or operator of any air

27

contamination source to sample the emissions of the source in

28

accordance with methods and procedures and at locations and

29

intervals of time as the department may reasonably prescribe,

30

and to provide the department with the results of the

- 8 -

 


1

samples.

2

(7)  Enter upon any property on which an air

3

contamination source may be located and make tests upon the

4

source as are necessary to determine whether the air

5

contaminants being emitted from the air contamination source

6

are being emitted at a rate in excess of a rate provided for

7

by this subchapter, any regulation promulgated under this

8

subchapter or any plan approval, permit or order of the

9

department or otherwise causing air pollution. If the

10

department determines that a source test is necessary, it

11

shall give reasonable written or oral notice to the person

12

owning, operating or otherwise in control of the source, that

13

the department will conduct a test on the source. After the

14

test, the person to whom the notice is given shall provide

15

reasonably safe access to the testing area and sampling

16

ports, facilities, electrical power and water, as the

17

department shall specify in its notice.

18

(8)  Receive, initiate and investigate complaints,

19

institute and conduct surveys and testing programs, conduct

20

general atmospheric sampling programs, make observations of

21

conditions which may or do cause air pollution, make tests or

22

other determinations at air contamination sources and assess

23

the degree of abatement required.

24

(9)  Do the following in regard to orders:

25

(i)  Issue orders to any person owning or operating

26

an air contamination source or owning or possessing land

27

on which the source is located, if the source is

28

introducing or is likely to introduce air contaminants

29

into the outdoor atmosphere in excess of any rate

30

provided for by this subchapter, any regulation

- 9 -

 


1

promulgated under this subchapter or any plan approval or

2

permit applicable to the source, or at a level as to

3

cause air pollution. Any order may require the cessation

4

of any operation or activity which is introducing air

5

contaminants into the outdoor atmosphere so as to cause

6

air pollution, the reduction of emissions from the air

7

contamination source, modification or repair of the

8

source or air pollution control device or equipment or

9

certain operating and maintenance procedures with respect

10

to the source or air pollution control device or

11

equipment, institution of a reasonable process change,

12

installation of air pollution control devices or

13

equipment, or any or all of the requirements as the

14

department deems necessary. Orders may specify a time for

15

compliance, require submission of a proposed plan for

16

compliance and require submission of periodic reports

17

concerning compliance. If a time for compliance is given,

18

the department may, in its discretion, require the

19

posting of a bond in the amount of twice the money to be

20

expended in reaching compliance.

21

(ii)  All department orders shall be in writing,

22

contain a statement of the reasons for their issuance and

23

be served either personally or by certified mail. Within

24

30 days after service of any order the person to whom the

25

order is issued or any other person aggrieved by the

26

order may file with the hearing board an appeal setting

27

forth with particularity the grounds relied upon. An

28

appeal to the hearing board of the department's order

29

shall not act as a supersedeas except that upon

30

application and for cause shown, the hearing board may

- 10 -

 


1

issue a supersedeas.

2

(10)  Institute, in a court of competent jurisdiction,

3

proceedings to compel compliance with this subchapter, any

4

regulation promulgated under this subchapter or any plan

5

approval, permit or order of the department.

6

(11)  Act as the agent for the board in holding public

7

hearings when so directed by the board.

8

(12)  Institute prosecutions under this subchapter.

9

(13)  Recommend the minimum job qualifications of

10

personnel employed by county and municipal air pollution

11

control agencies hereafter created.

12

(14)  Require the submission of, and consider for

13

approval, plans and specifications of air pollution control

14

equipment, devices or process changes and inspect the

15

installations or modifications to ensure compliance with the

16

plans which have been approved.

17

(15)  Conduct or cause to be conducted studies and

18

research with respect to air contaminants, their nature,

19

causes and effects, and with respect to the control,

20

prevention, abatement and reduction of air pollution and air

21

contamination.

22

(16)  Evaluate motor vehicle emission control programs,

23

including vehicle emission standards, clean alternative

24

fuels, oxygenated fuels, reformulated fuels, vehicle miles of

25

travel, congestion levels, transportation control measures

26

and other transportation control strategies with respect to

27

their effect upon air pollution and determine the need for

28

modifications of the programs.

29

(17)  Determine by means of field studies and sampling

30

the degree of air pollution existing in any part of the

- 11 -

 


1

Commonwealth.

2

(18)  Prepare and develop a general comprehensive plan

3

for the control and abatement of existing air pollution and

4

air contamination and for the abatement, control and

5

prevention of any new air pollution and air contamination,

6

recognizing varying requirements for the different areas of

7

this Commonwealth, and to submit a comprehensive plan to the

8

board for its consideration and approval.

9

(19)  Encourage the formulation and execution of plans in

10

conjunction with air pollution control agencies or civil

11

associations of counties, cities, boroughs, towns and

12

townships of this Commonwealth where any sources of air

13

pollution or air contamination may be located, and enlist the

14

cooperation of those who may be in control of the sources for

15

the control, prevention and abatement of air pollution and

16

air contamination.

17

(20)  Encourage voluntary efforts and cooperation by all

18

persons concerned in controlling, preventing, abating and

19

reducing air pollution and air contamination.

20

(21)  Conduct and supervise educational programs with

21

respect to the control, prevention, abatement and reduction

22

of air pollution and air contamination, including the

23

preparation and distribution of information relating to the

24

means of controlling and preventing air pollution and air

25

contamination.

26

(22)  Develop and conduct, in cooperation with local

27

communities, demonstration programs relating to air

28

contaminants, air pollution and air contamination and the

29

control, prevention, abatement and reduction of air pollution

30

and air contamination.

- 12 -

 


1

(23)  Provide advisory technical consultative services to

2

local communities for the control, prevention, abatement and

3

reduction of air pollution and air contamination.

4

(24)  Cooperate with the appropriate agencies of the

5

United States or of other states or any interstate agencies

6

with respect to the control, prevention, abatement and

7

reduction of air pollution and, as appropriate, formulate

8

interstate air pollution control compacts or agreements for

9

the submission to the General Assembly.

10

(25)  Serve as the agency of the Commonwealth for the

11

receipt of money from the Federal Government or other public

12

or private agencies, and expend money for studies and

13

research with respect to air contaminants, air pollution and

14

the control, prevention, abatement and reduction of air

15

pollution.

16

(26)  Develop and submit to the Environmental Protection

17

Agency a procedure to implement and enforce the regulations

18

which the Environmental Protection Agency promulgates under

19

section 183(e) of the Clean Air Act to reduce emissions from

20

consumer and commercial products, provided the department

21

will receive credits for the reductions attributed to the

22

Federal consumer and commercial products regulations under

23

section 182 of the Clean Air Act regulations, and the

24

department has the resources to implement and enforce the

25

program.

26

(27)  Do any and all other acts and things not

27

inconsistent with any provision of this subchapter, which it

28

may deem necessary or proper for the effective enforcement of

29

this subchapter and the regulations promulgated under this

30

subchapter.

- 13 -

 


1

§ 2114.1.  Agricultural regulations prohibited.

2

(a)  Applicability.--Except as may be required by the Clean

3

Air Act or the regulations promulgated under the Clean Air Act,

4

this subchapter shall not apply to the production of

5

agricultural commodities and the Environmental Quality Board

6

shall not have the power nor the authority to promulgate

7

regulations relating to air contaminants and air pollution

8

arising from the production of agricultural commodities.

9

(b)  Definitions.--As used in this section, the term

10

"production of agricultural commodities" shall include:

11

(1)  The commercial propagation, production, harvesting

12

or drying on the premises of the farm operation or the

13

disposal of residual materials resulting from the commercial

14

propagation, production, harvesting or drying on the premises

15

of the farm operation of the following:

16

(i)  Field crops, including corn, wheat, oats, rye,

17

barley, hay, potatoes and dry beans.

18

(ii)  Fruits, including apples, peaches, grapes,

19

cherries and berries.

20

(iii)  Vegetables, including tomatoes, snap beans,

21

cabbage, carrots, beets, onions, mushrooms, sweet corn

22

and green peas.

23

(iv)  Horticultural specialties, including nursery

24

stock, ornamental shrubs, ornamental trees and flowers.

25

(v)  Livestock and livestock products, including

26

cattle, sheep, hogs, goats, horses, poultry, furbearing

27

animals, milk, eggs and furs.

28

(vi)  Timber, wood and other wood products derived

29

from trees.

30

(vii)  Aquatic plants and animals and their by-

- 14 -

 


1

products.

2

(2)  The processing of agricultural commodities

3

propagated, produced, harvested or dried under paragraph (1)

4

or the disposal of residual materials resulting from the

5

processing. This paragraph shall apply to agricultural

6

commodities propagated, produced, harvested or dried on the

7

premises of the farm operation.

8

(3)  The commercial production, processing or storage of

9

compost, except for compost including, all or in part,

10

biosolids originating at a municipal sewage treatment

11

facility, to be predominantly used in the commercial

12

propagation or production of any agricultural commodity

13

identified under paragraph (1), regardless of whether the

14

compost is being produced, processed or stored on a different

15

premises than the premises in which the compost is being

16

used.

17

(4)  The use of any material whose production, processing

18

or storage is exempt from this subchapter under paragraph (3)

19

in the commercial propagation or production of any

20

agricultural commodity identified under paragraph (1), or any

21

odor or malodor or fugitive air emission resulting from the

22

production, processing or storage of any material so

23

exempted.

24

§ 2114.2.  Permissible actions.

25

(a)  Regulations.--In implementing the requirements of

26

section 109 of the Clean Air Act, the board may promulgate, by

27

regulation, only those control measures or other requirements

28

which are reasonably required, in accordance with the Clean Air

29

Act deadlines, to achieve and maintain the ambient air quality

30

standards or to satisfy related Clean Air Act requirements,

- 15 -

 


1

unless otherwise specifically authorized or required by this

2

subchapter or specifically required by the Clean Air Act.

3

(b)  Limitation.--Control measures or other requirements

4

promulgated under subsection (a) shall be no more stringent than

5

those required by the Clean Air Act unless authorized or

6

required by this subchapter or specifically required by the

7

Clean Air Act. This requirement shall not apply if the board

8

determines that it is reasonably necessary for a control measure

9

or other requirement to exceed minimum Clean Air Act

10

requirements in order for the Commonwealth:

11

(1)  to achieve or maintain ambient air quality

12

standards;

13

(2)  to satisfy related Clean Air Act requirements as

14

they specifically relate to the Commonwealth;

15

(3)  to prevent an assessment or imposition of Clean Air

16

Act sanctions; or

17

(4)  to comply with a final decree of a Federal court.

18

(c)  Prohibition.--The board may not by regulation promulgate

19

an ambient air quality standard for a specific pollutant which

20

is more stringent than the air quality standard which the EPA

21

has adopted for the specific pollutant under section 109 of the

22

Clean Air Act.

23

(d)  Challenges.--In any challenge to the enforcement of

24

regulations promulgated to achieve and maintain the ambient air

25

quality standards or to satisfy related Clean Air Act

26

requirements, the person challenging the regulation shall have

27

the burden to demonstrate that the control measure or other

28

requirement or the stringency of the control measure or

29

requirement is not reasonably required to achieve or maintain

30

the standard or to satisfy related Clean Air Act requirements.

- 16 -

 


1

(e)  Preenforcement review.--No person may file a

2

preenforcement review challenge under this section based in any

3

manner upon the standards set forth in subsection (b).

4

(f)  Applicability.--This section shall not apply to

5

regulations approved as a final rulemaking by the board prior to

6

September 8, 1992, or to any ambient air quality standards

7

promulgated by the board if no standard has been promulgated by

8

the EPA.

9

(g)  Construction.--This section shall not be construed to

10

weaken or otherwise affect site-specific standards or other

11

requirements for individual sources or facilities in place prior

12

to September 8, 1992.

13

§ 2114.3.  Evaluation.

14

Beginning five years after July 9, 1992, and every five years

15

thereafter, the department shall conduct and submit to the

16

General Assembly an evaluation of the effectiveness of the

17

programs adopted to implement the Clean Air Act. The evaluation

18

shall include:

19

(1)  A determination of whether the limitation imposed in

20

section 2114.2 (relating to permissible actions) has hindered

21

in any way the Commonwealth's efforts to comply with the

22

Clean Air Act and a recommendation on whether that provision

23

should be changed.

24

(2)  The specific steps taken to implement the Clean Air

25

Act and progress made toward meeting the emission reductions

26

required by the act and recommendations on any additional

27

steps which must be taken.

28

(3)  An evaluation of the funding available to implement

29

the Clean Air Act programs and whether that funding is

30

sufficient or inadequate and recommendations on if

- 17 -

 


1

adjustments should be made.

2

(4)  An analysis of the costs imposed on mobile and

3

stationary air contamination sources to implement the

4

requirements of the Clean Air Act, including on individuals

5

and companies. The analysis of costs shall also consider the

6

benefits of compliance with the Clean Air Act requirements

7

and the public health, environmental and economic costs to

8

the Commonwealth for failing to meet the requirements,

9

including the impact of sanctions.

10

(5)  An evaluation, in consultation with the Department

11

of Community and Economic Development and the Office of Small

12

Business Ombudsman, of the adequacy of measures taken by the

13

Commonwealth to assist small businesses in complying with the

14

Clean Air Act.

15

(6)  A summary of the activities undertaken by the

16

Citizens Advisory Council and the air technical advisory

17

committee under section 2117.6 (relating to advice to

18

department).

19

(7)  An evaluation of the effectiveness of the Northeast

20

Ozone Transport Commission in meeting the mandates of the

21

Clean Air Act and recommendations on any changes that could

22

make the commission more effective.

23

(8)  An assessment of the impact of missing Federal

24

deadlines identified under section 2117.12 (relating to

25

missed Federal deadlines) has had or will have on the State

26

implementation of the Clean Air Act programs.

27

§ 2115.  Environmental Quality Board.

28

(a)  Powers and duties.--The board shall have the power and

29

its duty shall be to:

30

(1)  Promulgate regulations, for the prevention, control,

- 18 -

 


1

reduction and abatement of air pollution, applicable

2

throughout this Commonwealth or to parts or regions or

3

subregions specifically designated in the regulation which

4

shall be applicable to all air contamination sources

5

regardless of whether the source is required to be under

6

permit by this subchapter. Regulations may establish maximum

7

allowable emission rates of air contaminants from the

8

sources, prohibit or regulate the combustion of certain

9

fuels, prohibit or regulate open burning, prohibit or

10

regulate any process or source or class of processes or

11

sources, require the installation of specified control

12

devices or equipment or designate the control efficiency of

13

air pollution control devices or equipment required in

14

specific processes or sources or classes of processes or

15

sources. Regulations shall be promulgated under the

16

provisions of the act of July 31, 1968 (P.L.769, No.240),

17

referred to as the Commonwealth Documents Law, upon notice

18

and after public hearings as the board deems appropriate. In

19

exercising its authority to promulgate regulations, the board

20

may, and to the extent deemed desirable by it shall, consult

21

with a council of technical advisers properly qualified by

22

education or experience in air pollution matters, appointed

23

by the board and to serve at the pleasure of the board, to

24

consist of the number of advisers as the board may appoint,

25

but the technical advisers shall receive no compensation

26

other than their actual and necessary expenses for their

27

services to the board.

28

(2)  Establish and publish maximum quantities of air

29

contaminants that may be permitted under various conditions

30

at the point of use from any air contaminant source in

- 19 -

 


1

various areas of this Commonwealth so as to control air

2

pollution.

3

(3)  By regulation, classify air contaminant sources,

4

according to levels and types of emissions and other

5

characteristics which relate to air pollution.

6

Classifications made under this subsection shall apply to the

7

entire Commonwealth or any part. Any person who owns or

8

operates an air contaminant source of any class to which the

9

regulations of the board under this subsection apply, shall

10

make reports containing information as may be required by the

11

board concerning location, size and height of air contaminant

12

outlets, processes employed, fuels used and the nature and

13

time periods or duration of emissions, and other information

14

as is relevant to air pollution and available or reasonably

15

capable of being assembled.

16

(4)  Recommend to the Secretary of Transportation

17

performance or specification standards, or both, for emission

18

control systems and devices on motor vehicles.

19

(5)  Promulgate regulations for the protection of public

20

health and safety for periods when the accumulation of air

21

contaminants in any area is attaining or has attained levels

22

which, if sustained or exceeded, could lead to an acute

23

threat to the health of the public. Regulations shall contain

24

appropriate procedures to protect public health and safety

25

during the periods.

26

(6)  Promulgate regulations for the approval and the

27

rescission and suspension of approval of local air pollution

28

control agencies.

29

(7)  Promulgate regulations designed to reduce emissions

30

from motor vehicles, including centrally clean-fueled fleets,

- 20 -

 


1

clean alternative fuels, oxygenated fuels, reformulated

2

fuels, vehicle miles of travel, transportation control

3

measures and other transportation control strategies.

4

Regulations shall be developed in consultation with the

5

Department of Transportation. The board shall not promulgate

6

regulations mandating the sale or use of any set of

7

specifications for motor fuel prescribed by the State of

8

California under 42 U.S.C. § 7545(c)(4)(B) (relating to

9

regulation of fuels) unless the set of specifications is

10

required under the Clean Air Act or the regulations

11

promulgated under the Clean Air Act.

12

(8)  Promulgate regulations to implement the provisions

13

of the Clean Air Act. The regulations promulgated to

14

implement the provisions of the Clean Air Act shall be

15

consistent with the requirements of the Clean Air Act and the

16

regulations promulgated under the Clean Air Act.

17

(9)  Promulgate regulations to exempt sources or

18

categories of sources of minor significance from the

19

provisions of section 2116.1 (relating to plan approvals and

20

permits).

21

(10)  Promulgate regulations establishing provisions to

22

allow changes within a permitted facility or one operating

23

under section 2116.1(b)(3) without requiring a permit

24

revision if the changes are not modifications under any

25

provision of 42 U.S.C. Ch. 85 Subch. I (relating to programs

26

and activities) and the changes do not exceed the emissions

27

allowable under the permit, whether expressed in the permit

28

as a rate of emissions or in terms of total emissions,

29

provided that the facility provides the department and the

30

administrator with written notification in advance of the

- 21 -

 


1

proposed changes which shall be a minimum of seven days,

2

unless the board provides in its regulations a different time

3

frame for emergencies.

4

(11)  In its discretion, by regulation, require revisions

5

to permits for major sources to incorporate applicable

6

standards and regulations promulgated under the Clean Air Act

7

and promulgated by the board after the issuance of the permit

8

as required by section 502(b)(9) of the Clean Air Act.

9

(12)  In its discretion, by regulation promulgate rules

10

containing reasonable procedures consistent with the need for

11

expeditious action by the department on plan approvals and

12

operating permit applications to make available to the public

13

any plan approval or operating permit application, compliance

14

plan, plan approval, operating permit and monitoring or

15

compliance report as required by section 502(b)(8) of the

16

Clean Air Act.

17

(13)  Promulgate, by regulation, alternative volatile

18

organic compound emission limitations for aerospace coatings

19

and solvents, including extreme performance coatings, which

20

are required to be used by the United States Department of

21

Defense, the United States Department of Transportation and

22

the National Aeronautic and Space Administration or to meet

23

military and aerospace specifications, provided the

24

alternative limitations are authorized by the Clean Air Act.

25

(b)  Limitation.--In promulgating regulations containing

26

transportation control measures, the board shall not have the

27

authority to promulgate any regulation limiting or expanding any

28

municipalities' authority under the Municipal Planning Code to

29

regulate land development, subdivision approval, zoning

30

revision, building permit or any other development activity

- 22 -

 


1

unless specifically required by the Clean Air Act.

2

§ 2116.  Environmental Hearing Board.

3

The hearing board shall have the power and its duty shall be

4

to hear and determine all appeals from appealable actions of the

5

department as defined in the act of July 13, 1988 (P.L.530,

6

No.94), known as the Environmental Hearing Board Act, in

7

accordance with the provisions of this subchapter. Any and all

8

action taken by the hearing board with reference to any appeal

9

shall be in the form of an adjudication, and all action shall be

10

subject to the provisions of 2 Pa.C.S. (relating to

11

administrative law and procedure).

12

§ 2116.1.  Plan approvals and permits.

13

(a)  Plan approval.--No person shall construct, assemble,

14

install or modify any stationary air contamination source, or

15

install on the source any air pollution control equipment or

16

device unless the person has applied to and received written

17

plan approval from the department to do so: Provided, however,

18

That no written approval shall be necessary with respect to

19

normal routine maintenance operations, nor to any source,

20

equipment or device used solely for the supplying of heat or hot

21

water to one structure intended as a one-family or two-family

22

dwelling, nor where construction, assembly, installation or

23

modification is specifically authorized by the regulations of

24

the department to be conducted without written approval. All

25

applications for approval shall be made in writing and shall be

26

on forms and contain information as the department shall

27

prescribe and shall have appended to the applications detailed

28

plans and specifications related to the proposed installation.

29

(b)  Permit required.--

30

(1)  No person shall operate any stationary air

- 23 -

 


1

contamination source unless the department shall have issued

2

to the person a permit to operate the source under the

3

provisions of this section in response to a written

4

application for a permit submitted on forms and containing

5

information as the department may prescribe or where

6

construction, assembly, installation modification is

7

specifically authorized by the regulations of the department

8

to be conducted without written approval. The department

9

shall provide public notice and the right to comment on all

10

permits prior to issuance or denial and may hold public

11

hearings concerning any permit.

12

(2)  A permit may be issued after July 9, 1992, to any

13

applicant for a stationary air contamination source requiring

14

construction, assembly, installation or modification if the

15

requirements of subsection (a) have been met and there has

16

been performed upon the source a test operation or evaluation

17

which shall satisfy the department that the air contamination

18

source will not discharge into the outdoor atmosphere any air

19

contaminants at a rate in excess of that permitted by

20

applicable regulation of the board, or in violation of any

21

performance or emission standard or other requirement

22

established by the EPA or the department for the source and

23

which will not cause air pollution.

24

(3)  A stationary air contamination source operating

25

lawfully without a permit for which fees are required by

26

section 2116.3 (relating to fees) or the regulations

27

promulgated under this subchapter have been paid is

28

authorized to continue to operate without a permit until 120

29

days after the department provides notice to the source that

30

a permit is required or until November 1, 1996, whichever

- 24 -

 


1

occurs first. If the applicant submits a complete permit

2

application within the time frames in this subsection and the

3

department fails to issue a permit through no fault of the

4

applicant, the source may continue to operate if the fees

5

required by section 2116.3 or the regulations promulgated

6

under this subchapter have been paid and the source is

7

operated in conformance with this subchapter, the Clean Air

8

Act and the regulations promulgated under both this

9

subchapter and the Clean Air Act. For any performance or

10

emission standard or other requirement established by the EPA

11

or the department for the source subsequent to January 8,

12

1960, but prior to the permit issuance date, the permit may

13

contain a compliance schedule authorizing the source to

14

operate out of compliance and requiring the source to achieve

15

compliance as soon as possible but not later than the time

16

required by this subchapter, the Clean Air Act or the

17

regulations promulgated under either this subchapter or the

18

Clean Air Act. For purposes of this subsection, a source is

19

operating lawfully without a permit if it is a source for

20

which no permit was previously required and the source is

21

operating in compliance with applicable regulatory

22

requirements.

23

(4)  For repermitting of any stationary air contamination

24

source which is operating under a valid permit on January 8,

25

1960, or which has received a permit under the provisions of

26

paragraphs (2) and (3) and which is required to meet

27

performance or emission standards or other requirements

28

established subsequent to the issuance of the existing

29

permit, the new permit may contain a compliance schedule

30

authorizing the source to operate out of compliance and

- 25 -

 


1

requiring the source to achieve compliance as soon as

2

possible but not later than the time required by this

3

subchapter, the Clean Air Act or the regulations promulgated

4

under either this subchapter or the Clean Air Act.

5

(b.1)  Terms and conditions.--A permit or plan approval

6

issued under subsection (a) or (b) may contain terms and

7

conditions as the department deems necessary to assure the

8

proper operation of the source. The board shall by regulation

9

establish a permit shield for permits issued under the authority

10

delegated to the Commonwealth by the EPA under Title V of the

11

Clean Air Act. The program shall be consistent with the

12

requirements of section 504(f) of the Clean Air Act and the

13

regulations promulgated under the Clean Air Act. Each permittee,

14

on a schedule established by the department, shall submit

15

reports to the department containing information as the

16

department may prescribe relative to the operation and

17

maintenance of the source.

18

(b.2)  Permit term.--A permit issued or reissued under

19

subsection (b) shall be issued for a five-year term unless a

20

shorter term is required to comply with the Clean Air Act and

21

regulations promulgated under the Clean Air Act or the permittee

22

requests a shorter term, except that a permit for acid

23

deposition control shall be issued for a five-year term. A

24

permit may be terminated, modified, suspended or revoked and

25

reissued for cause. The terms and conditions of an expired

26

permit are automatically continued pending the issuance of a new

27

permit if the permittee has submitted a timely and complete

28

application for a new permit and paid the fees required by

29

section 2116.3 or the regulations promulgated under this

30

subchapter and the department is unable, through no fault of the

- 26 -

 


1

permittee, to issue or deny a new permit before the expiration

2

date of the previous permit. Failure of the department to issue

3

or deny a new permit prior to the expiration date of the

4

previous permit shall be an appealable action as described in

5

section 2120.2 (relating to appealable actions). The hearing

6

board may require that the department take action on an

7

application without additional delay.

8

(b.3)  Procedures.--The board shall by regulation establish

9

adequate, streamlined and reasonable procedures for

10

expeditiously determining when applications are complete and for

11

expeditious review of applications. The department shall approve

12

or disapprove a complete application, consistent with the

13

procedures established by the board for consideration of

14

applications, within 18 months after the date of receipt of the

15

complete application except that the department shall establish

16

a phased schedule for acting on permit applications submitted

17

within the first full year after the effective date of the Title

18

V permit program established to implement the requirements of

19

the Clean Air Act. The schedule shall assure that at least one-

20

third of the permits shall be acted upon by the department

21

annually over a period not to exceed three years after that

22

effective date. Failure of the department to issue or deny a

23

permit by a deadline established by this subsection shall be an

24

appealable action as described in section 2120.2. The hearing

25

board may require that the department take action on an

26

application without additional delay.

27

(b.4)  Reactivation.--

28

(1)  During the term of a permit, a permittee may

29

reactivate any source under the permit that has been out of

30

operation or production for a period of one year or more,

- 27 -

 


1

provided that the permittee has submitted a reactivation plan

2

to and received written approval from the department. The

3

reactivation plan shall describe the measures that will be

4

taken to ensure the source will be reactivated in compliance

5

with all applicable permit requirements. A reactivation plan

6

may be submitted to and approved by the department at any

7

time during the term of a permit. The department shall take

8

action on the reactivation plan within 30 days unless the

9

department determines that additional time is needed based on

10

the size or complexity of the reactivated source.

11

(2)  A reactivation plan may also be submitted to and

12

approved by the department as part of the plan approval or

13

permit application process. An owner or operator who has an

14

approved reactivation plan shall notify the department prior

15

to the reactivation of the source.

16

(b.5)  Regulations to implement Clean Air Act.--The board

17

shall promulgate the regulations required by subsections (b.1),

18

(b.3) and (i) as part of the regulatory package to implement the

19

operating permit program required by Title V of the Clean Air

20

Act.

21

(c)  Termination, modification, suspension or revocation of

22

plan approval or permit.--A plan approval or permit issued under

23

this section may be terminated, modified, suspended or revoked

24

and reissued if:

25

(1)  the permittee constructs or operates the source

26

subject to the plan approval or permit in such a manner as to

27

be in violation of this subchapter, the Clean Air Act, the

28

regulations promulgated under either this subchapter or the

29

Clean Air Act, a plan approval or permit or in such a manner

30

as to cause air pollution;

- 28 -

 


1

(2)  the permittee fails to properly or adequately

2

maintain or repair any air pollution control device or

3

equipment attached to or otherwise made a part of the source;

4

(3)  the permittee has failed to submit a report required

5

by a plan approval or operating permit under this section; or

6

(4)  the Environmental Protection Agency determines that

7

the permit is not in compliance with the requirements of the

8

Clean Air Act or the regulations promulgated under the Clean

9

Air Act.

10

(d)  Refusal to grant plan approval or issuance of permit.--

11

(1)  The department may refuse to grant plan approval for

12

any stationary air contamination source subject to the

13

provisions of subsection (a) or to issue a permit to any

14

source if:

15

(i)  the department determines the source is likely

16

to cause air pollution or to violate this subchapter, the

17

Clean Air Act or the regulations promulgated under either

18

this subchapter or the Clean Air Act applicable to the

19

source; or

20

(ii)  in the design of the source, no provision is

21

made for adequate verification of compliance, including

22

source testing or alternative means to verify compliance.

23

(2)  The department may also refuse to issue a permit or

24

may for cause terminate or revoke and reissue a permit to a

25

person if:

26

(i)  the EPA determines that the permit is not in

27

compliance with the requirements of the Clean Air Act or

28

the regulations promulgated under the Clean Air Act; or

29

(ii)  the applicant has constructed, installed,

30

modified or operated any air contamination source or

- 29 -

 


1

installed any air pollution control equipment or device

2

on the source contrary to the plans and specifications

3

approved by the department.

4

(e)  Written notice to affected person.--

5

(1)  If the department refuses to grant an approval or to

6

issue or reissue a permit under this section or terminates,

7

modifies, suspends or revokes a plan approval or permit

8

already issued, the action shall be in the form of a written

9

notice to the person affected. The notice shall inform the

10

person of the action taken by the department and provide a

11

full and complete statement of the reasons for the action.

12

(2)  The notice shall be served upon the person affected,

13

either personally or by certified mail, and the action stated

14

in the notice shall be final and not subject to review

15

unless, within 30 days of the service of the notice, any

16

person affected by the action appeals to the hearing board,

17

stating with particularity the grounds relied upon.

18

(3)  The hearing board shall hear the appeal under the

19

provisions of the regulations relating to practice and

20

procedure before the hearing board and shall issue an

21

adjudication affirming, modifying or overruling the action of

22

the department.

23

(f)  Establishment of general plan approval and permit

24

program.--

25

(1)  The department may by regulation establish a general

26

plan approval and a general permit program. After the program

27

is established, the department may grant general plan

28

approval or a general permit for any category of stationary

29

air contamination source if the department determines that

30

the sources in the category are similar in nature and can be

- 30 -

 


1

adequately regulated using standardized specifications and

2

conditions.

3

(2)  An applicant proposing to use a general plan

4

approval or general permit shall notify the department and

5

must receive written approval prior to the proposed use.

6

(3)  The department shall take action on a notification

7

within 30 days.

8

(g)  Stationary sources at multiple temporary locations.--

9

(1)  The department may by regulation establish a plan

10

approval and permit program for stationary sources operated

11

at multiple temporary locations. After the program is

12

established, the department may grant a plan approval or

13

issue a single permit to any stationary air contamination

14

source that may be operated at multiple temporary locations.

15

(2)  The approval or permit shall require the owner or

16

operator to notify the department and municipality where the

17

operation shall take place in advance of each change in

18

location and may require a separate application and permit or

19

approval fee for operations at each location.

20

(3)  An applicant proposing to use the plan approval or

21

permit authorized by this subsection shall notify the

22

department and must receive written approval prior to the

23

proposed use.

24

(4)  The department shall take action on a request within

25

30 days.

26

(h)  Comprehensive plan approval and operating permit

27

programs.--The department shall establish comprehensive plan

28

approval and operating permit programs which meet the

29

requirements of this subchapter and the Clean Air Act.

30

(i)  Changes without permit revision.--The board shall by

- 31 -

 


1

regulation establish provisions to allow changes within a

2

permitted facility or one operating under subsection (b)(3)

3

without requiring a permit revision, if:

4

(1)  the changes are not modifications under any

5

provision of 42 U.S.C. Ch. 85 Subch. I (relating to programs

6

and activities);

7

(2)  the changes do not exceed the emissions allowable

8

under the permit whether expressed in the permit as a rate of

9

emissions or in terms of total emissions; and

10

(3)  the facility provides the administrator and the

11

department with written notification at least seven days in

12

advance of the proposed changes, unless the board provides in

13

its regulations a different time frame for emergencies.

14

(j)  Availability or documents to public.--The department

15

shall make available to the public any permit application,

16

compliance plan, permit and monitoring or compliance report

17

required by this subchapter.

18

(k)  Permit revisions.--

19

(1)  The department shall require revision to any permit

20

to incorporate applicable standards and regulations

21

promulgated under the Clean Air Act after the issuance of the

22

permit. Revisions shall occur as expeditiously as

23

practicable, but not later than 18 months after the

24

promulgation of the standards and regulations.

25

(2)  No revision shall be required if the effective date

26

of the standards or regulations is a date after the

27

expiration of the permit term or if less than three years

28

remain on the permit.

29

(3)  The permit revision shall be treated as a permit

30

renewal if it complies with the requirements of this

- 32 -

 


1

subchapter regarding renewals.

2

§ 2116.2.  Emergency procedure.

3

(a)  Generalized condition of air pollution.--Any other

4

provision of law to the contrary notwithstanding, if the

5

department finds, in accordance with the regulations of the

6

board promulgated under the provisions of section 2115(a)(5)

7

(relating to Environmental Quality Board), that:

8

(1)  a generalized condition of air pollution exists; and

9

(2)  it creates an emergency requiring immediate action

10

to protect human health or safety,

11

the department, with the concurrence of the Governor, shall

12

order or direct persons causing or contributing to the air

13

pollution to immediately reduce or discontinue the emission of

14

air contaminants.

15

(b)  Absence of generalized condition of air pollution.--In

16

the absence of a generalized condition of air pollution, if the

17

department finds that emissions from the operation of one or

18

more air contamination sources are creating an imminent danger

19

to human health or safety, the department may, without regard to

20

the provisions of section 2114 (relating to administration),

21

order the persons responsible for the operation of the air

22

contamination sources in question to immediately reduce or

23

discontinue the emission of air contaminants.

24

(c)  Hearing.--

25

(1)  An order issued under subsection (a) or (b) shall

26

fix a place and time, not later than 24 hours after issuance

27

of the order, for a hearing to be held before the hearing

28

board.

29

(2)  Within 24 hours after the commencement of the

30

hearing, and without adjournment, the hearing board shall

- 33 -

 


1

affirm, modify or set aside the order of the department.

2

(d)  Construction.--This section shall not be construed to

3

limit any power which the Governor or any other officer may have

4

to declare an emergency and act on the basis of the declaration.

5

§ 2116.3.  Fees.

6

(a)  Authorization.--This section authorizes:

7

(1)  The establishment of fees sufficient to cover the

8

indirect and direct costs of administering the air pollution

9

control plan approval process, operating permit program

10

required by Title V of the Clean Air Act, other requirements

11

of the Clean Air Act and the indirect and direct costs of

12

administering the Small Business Stationary Source Technical

13

and Environmental Compliance Assistance Program, Compliance

14

Advisory Committee and Office of Small Business Ombudsman.

15

(2)  The board by regulation to establish fees to support

16

the air pollution control program authorized by this

17

subchapter and not covered by fees required by section 502(b)

18

of the Clean Air Act.

19

(b)  Annual interim air emission fee.--

20

(1)  The board shall establish an annual interim air

21

emission fee of $14 per ton on emissions of sulfur dioxide,

22

nitrogen oxides, particulate matter of ten microns or less

23

and volatile organic compounds to cover the reasonable direct

24

and indirect costs of developing and administering the air

25

pollution control operating permit program required by Title

26

V of the Clean Air Act, other requirements of the Clean Air

27

Act and the reasonable indirect and direct costs of

28

administering the Small Business Stationary Source Technical

29

and Environmental Compliance Assistance Program, Compliance

30

Advisory Committee and the Office of Small Business Ombudsman

- 34 -

 


1

to be collected during fiscal year 1992-1993 for actual

2

emissions occurring in calendar year 1991, for fiscal year

3

1993-1994 covering actual emissions occurring in calendar

4

year 1992 and for fiscal year 1994-1995 covering actual

5

emissions occurring during calendar year 1993.

6

(2)  The interim fee shall not apply to air emissions of

7

less than 100 tons for any of the listed pollutants, provided

8

that when emissions exceed 100 tons, the entire amount of all

9

air emissions for any of the listed pollutants up to 5,500

10

tons shall be chargeable emissions for interim fee purposes.

11

(c)  Permanent annual air emission fee.--

12

(1)  The board shall establish by regulation a permanent

13

annual air emission fee as required for regulated pollutants

14

by section 502(b) of the Clean Air Act to cover the

15

reasonable direct and indirect costs of administering the

16

operating permit program required by Title V of the Clean Air

17

Act, other related requirements of the Clean Air Act and the

18

reasonable indirect and direct costs of administering the

19

Small Business Stationary Source Technical and Environmental

20

Compliance Assistance Program, Compliance Advisory Committee

21

and the Office of Small Business Ombudsman to be collected

22

starting in fiscal year 1995-1996 for air emissions occurring

23

during calendar year 1994.

24

(2)  In no case shall the amount of the permanent fee be

25

more than that which is necessary to comply with section

26

502(b) of the Clean Air Act.

27

(3)  The permanent fee shall not apply to emissions of

28

more than 4,000 tons for any regulated pollutant. In the

29

event a final regulation containing the permanent annual air

30

emission fee is not effective by July 1, 1995, the permanent

- 35 -

 


1

annual air emission fee for sources subject to the Title V

2

operating permit program shall be the adjusted minimum dollar

3

amount set under section 502(b) of the Clean Air Act until

4

the final regulation is effective.

5

(d)  Factors to consider in establishing permanent air

6

emission fee.--Unless precluded by the Clean Air Act, the board

7

shall establish a permanent air emission fee which considers:

8

(1)  The size of the air contamination source.

9

(2)  The resources necessary to process the application

10

for plan approval or an operating permit.

11

(3)  The complexity of the plan approval or operating

12

permit.

13

(4)  The quantity and type of emissions from the sources.

14

(5)  The amount of fees charged in neighboring states.

15

(6)  The importance of not placing existing or

16

prospective sources in this Commonwealth at a competitive

17

disadvantage.

18

(7)  Other relevant factors.

19

(e)  Interim fees for stationary air contamination sources.--

20

Until alternative fees are established by the board under

21

subsection (c), stationary air contamination sources shall pay

22

the following interim fees:

23

(1)  Two hundred dollars for the processing of an

24

application for an operating permit.

25

(2)  Two hundred dollars for annual operating permit

26

administration fee.

27

(f)  Prohibition.--No emissions fee established under

28

subsection (b), (c) or (j) shall be payable by any State entity,

29

instrumentality or political subdivision in relation to any

30

publicly owned or operated facility.

- 36 -

 


1

(g)  Deposit of fees into restricted account.--

2

(1)  Any fees imposed under this section in areas with

3

approved local air pollution control programs shall be

4

deposited in a restricted account established by the

5

governing body authorizing the local program for use by that

6

program to implement the provisions of this subchapter for

7

which they are responsible.

8

(2)  The governing body shall annually submit to the

9

department an audit of the account in order to ensure that

10

the funds were properly spent.

11

(h)  Duty to report emissions and pay fee.--

12

(1)  Unless the board establishes a different payment

13

schedule by regulation, a facility subject to the emission

14

fees established in subsections (b) and (c) shall report its

15

emissions and pay the fee within 120 days after receipt of a

16

reporting form from the department or by September 1 of each

17

year for the emission from the preceding year, whichever

18

occurs first.

19

(2)  An air contamination source that fails to pay the

20

fees within the time frame established by this subchapter or

21

by regulation:

22

(i)  Shall pay a penalty of 50% of the fee amount,

23

plus interest on the fee amount computed in accordance

24

with section 6621(a)(2) of the Internal Revenue Code of

25

1986 (Public Law 99-514, 26 U.S.C. § 1 et seq.) from the

26

date the fee was required to be paid.

27

(ii)  May have its permit terminated or suspended.

28

The fee, penalty and interest may be collected following the

29

process for assessment and collection of a civil penalty

30

contained in section 2119.1 (relating to civil penalties).

- 37 -

 


1

(i)  Annual increase to permanent air emission fee.--

2

(1)  The permanent air emission fee imposed under

3

subsection (c) shall be increased in each year after

4

implementation of the fee by regulation by the percentage, if

5

any, by which the Consumer Price Index for the most recent

6

calendar year exceeds the Consumer Price Index for the

7

calendar year 1989.

8

(2)  For purposes of this subsection, the Consumer Price

9

Index for any calendar year is the average of the Consumer

10

Price Index for All Urban Consumers, published by the United

11

States Department of Labor, as of the close of the 12-month

12

period ending on August 31 of each calendar year.

13

(3)  The revision of the Consumer Price Index that is

14

most consistent with the Consumer Price Index for calendar

15

year 1989 shall be used.

16

(j)  Categories of fees.--The board may by regulation

17

establish the following categories of fees not related to Title

18

V of the Clean Air Act. Until the regulations are promulgated,

19

stationary air contamination sources shall pay the following

20

fees:

21

(1)  Two hundred dollars for the processing of any

22

application for plan approval.

23

(2)  Two hundred dollars for the processing of any

24

application for an operating permit.

25

(3)  Two hundred dollars for annual operating permit

26

administration fee.

27

In regard to fees established under this subsection, individual

28

sources required to be regulated by Title V of the Clean Air Act

29

shall only be subject to plan approval fees authorized in this

30

subsection.

- 38 -

 


1

(k)  Limitations on collection and use of fees.--No

2

administrative action shall prevent the deposit of the fees

3

established under this section in the Clean Air Fund established

4

in section 2119.2 (relating to disposition of fees, fines and

5

civil penalties) during the fiscal year in which they are

6

collected. The fees shall only be used for the purposes

7

authorized in this section and section 2119.2 and shall not be

8

transferred or diverted to any other purpose by administrative

9

action.

10

(l)  Deposits into Clean Air Fund.--Any fees, penalties and

11

interest owed the Commonwealth for delinquent payment collected

12

under this section shall be deposited in the Clean Air Fund.

13

(m)  Definition.--As used in this section, the term

14

"regulated pollutant" shall mean a volatile organic compound,

15

each pollutant regulated under sections 111 and 112 of the Clean

16

Air Act and each pollutant for which a national primary ambient

17

air quality standard has been promulgated. The term does not

18

include carbon monoxide.

19

§ 2116.4.  Fee for certain ozone areas.

20

(a)  Authorization.--

21

(1)  If an area identified in a State implementation plan

22

or any revision as a severe or extreme ozone nonattainment

23

area has failed to meet the national primary ambient air

24

quality standard for ozone by the applicable attainment date,

25

each major source of volatile organic compounds (VOCs), as

26

defined in the Clean Air Act and the regulations promulgated

27

under the Clean Air Act, located in the area shall, except

28

with respect to emissions during any year treated as an

29

extension year under section 181(a)(5) of the Clean Air Act,

30

pay a fee to the department as a penalty for the failure for

- 39 -

 


1

each calendar year beginning after the attainment date until

2

the area is redesignated as an attainment area for ozone.

3

(2)  The fee shall be assessed and collected following

4

the process for collection and assessment of a civil penalty

5

contained in section 2119.1 (relating to civil penalties).

6

(b)  Amount of fee.--

7

(1)  The fee shall equal $5,000 and shall be adjusted in

8

accordance with paragraph (3), per ton of VOC emitted by the

9

source during the calendar year in excess of 80% of the

10

baseline amount, computed under paragraph (2). The fee shall

11

be in addition to all other fees required to be paid by the

12

source.

13

(2)  (i)  For purposes of this section, the baseline

14

amount shall be computed, in accordance with guidance as

15

the administrator may provide, as the lower of the amount

16

of actual VOC emissions, referred to as actuals, or VOC

17

emissions allowed under the permit applicable to the

18

source or, if no permit has been issued for the

19

attainment year, the amount of VOC emissions allowed

20

under the applicable implementation plan, referred to as

21

allowables, during the attainment year.

22

(ii)  Notwithstanding subparagraph (i), the

23

administrator may issue guidance authorizing the baseline

24

amount to be determined in accordance with the lower of

25

average actuals or average allowables determined over a

26

period of more than one (1) calendar year. This guidance

27

may provide that the average calculation for a specific

28

source may be used if that source's emissions are

29

irregular, cyclical or otherwise vary significantly from

30

year to year.

- 40 -

 


1

(3)  The fee amount under paragraph (1) shall be adjusted

2

annually, beginning 1991 in accordance with section 2116.3(h)

3

and (i) (relating to fees).

4

(c)  Nonapplicability of sanctions.--

5

(1)  For areas with a total population under 200,000 that

6

fail to attain the standard by the applicable attainment

7

date, no sanction under this section or under any other

8

provision of this subchapter shall apply if the area can

9

demonstrate, consistent with guidance issued by the EPA, that

10

attainment in the area is prevented because of ozone or ozone

11

precursors transported from other areas.

12

(2)  The prohibition in paragraph (1) applies only in a

13

case in which the area has met all requirements and

14

implemented all measures applicable to the area under the

15

Clean Air Act.

16

§ 2116.5.  Acid deposition control.

17

(a)  Duty to develop permit program.--The department shall

18

develop a permit program for acid deposition control in

19

accordance with Titles IV and V of the Clean Air Act and submit

20

it to the administrator for approval.

21

(b)  Definitions incorporated by reference.--For purposes of

22

the permit program authorized under subsection (a), the

23

definitions in sections 402 and 501 of the Clean Air Act are

24

incorporated in this subchapter by reference.

25

(c)  Duty to submit permit application and compliance plan.--

26

(1)  The owner or operator or the designated

27

representative of each source affected under section 405 of

28

the Clean Air Act shall submit a permit application and

29

compliance plan for the affected source to the department no

30

later than January 1, 1996.

- 41 -

 


1

(2)  In the case of affected sources for which

2

application and plans are timely received, the permit

3

application and the compliance plan, including amendments to

4

them, shall be binding on the owner or operator or the

5

designated representative of the owners or operators and

6

shall be enforceable as a permit for purposes of this section

7

until a permit is issued by the department.

8

(3)  Any permit issued by the department shall require

9

the source to achieve compliance as soon as possible but not

10

later than the date required by this subchapter, the Clean

11

Air Act or the regulations promulgated under either this

12

subchapter or the Clean Air Act for the source.

13

(d)  Revised application and compliance plan.--At any time

14

after the submission of a permit application and compliance

15

plan, the applicant may submit a revised application and

16

compliance plan. In considering any permit application and

17

compliance plan under this section, the department shall

18

coordinate with the Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission

19

consistent with requirements that may be established by the

20

administrator.

21

(e)  Prohibitions.--In addition to other provisions, permits

22

issued by the department shall prohibit all of the following:

23

(1)  Annual emissions of sulfur dioxide in excess of the

24

number of allowances to emit sulfur dioxide that the owner or

25

operator or designated representative hold for the unit.

26

(2)  Exceedances of applicable emissions rates or

27

standards, including ambient air quality standards.

28

(3)  The use of any allowance prior to the year for which

29

it is allocated.

30

(4)  Contravention of any other provision of the permit.

- 42 -

 


1

§ 2116.6.  Hazardous air pollutants.

2

(a)  Performance and emission standards.--The regulations

3

establishing performance or emission standards promulgated under

4

section 112 of the Clean Air Act are incorporated by reference

5

into the department's permitting program. After the effective

6

date of the performance or emission standard, new,

7

reconstructed, modified and existing sources shall comply with

8

the performance or emission standards under the compliance

9

schedule established under section 112 of the Clean Air Act and

10

the regulations promulgated under the Clean Air Act. The

11

Environmental Quality Board may not establish a more stringent

12

performance or emission standard for hazardous air pollutant

13

emissions from existing sources, except as provided in

14

subsection (d). This section shall not apply to regulations

15

promulgated as final prior to January 8, 1960, and shall not be

16

construed to weaken standards for individual sources or

17

facilities in effect prior to January 8, 1960. The board may

18

establish performance or emission standards for sources or

19

categories of sources that are not included on the list of

20

source categories established under section 112(c) of the Clean

21

Air Act.

22

(b)  Establishment of standards by department.--In the event

23

the administrator has not promulgated a standard to control the

24

emissions of hazardous air pollutants for a category or

25

subcategory of major sources under section 112 of the Clean Air

26

Act, under a schedule established under section 112(c) of the

27

Clean Air Act, the department shall have the authority to

28

establish a performance or emission standard on a case-by-case

29

basis for individual sources or a category of sources. The

30

department shall have the authority to make the determinations

- 43 -

 


1

required by section 112(g)(2) of the Clean Air Act regarding the

2

construction, reconstruction and modification of sources. Any

3

person challenging the performance or emission standards

4

established by the department shall have the burden to

5

demonstrate that the performance or emission standard does not

6

meet the requirements of section 112 of the Clean Air Act. The

7

department shall incorporate the standard to control the

8

emissions of hazardous air pollutants into the plan approval or

9

operating permit of any source within the category or

10

subcategory. The performance or emission standard established on

11

a case-by-case basis by the department shall be equivalent to

12

the limitation that would apply to the source if a performance

13

or emission standard had been promulgated by the administrator

14

under section 112 of the Clean Air Act.

15

(c)  Technology requirement.--The department is authorized to

16

require that new sources demonstrate in the plan approval

17

application that the source will reduce or control emissions of

18

air pollutants, including hazardous air pollutants, by using the

19

best available technology.

20

(d)  Health-risk-based standards and operating practice

21

requirements.--

22

(1)  When needed to protect public health, welfare and

23

the environment from emissions of hazardous air pollutants

24

from new and existing sources, the department may impose

25

health risk-based emission standards or operating practice

26

requirements. In developing the health-risk-based emission

27

standards or operating practice requirements, the department

28

shall provide an explanation and rationale for the standards

29

or requirements and provide for public review and comments on

30

plan approvals, operating permits, guidelines and regulations

- 44 -

 


1

that contain health-risk-based emission standards or

2

operating practice requirements. Standards or requirements

3

promulgated under this subsection shall be developed using an

4

analysis that, among other factors, considers, as appropriate

5

for a source or source category, the criteria set forth in

6

section 112(f)(1) of the Clean Air Act in assessing the

7

proposed risk to the public health, welfare and the

8

environment from the source.

9

(2)  In the case of coke oven batteries, the department

10

may not impose health-risk-based emission standards more

11

stringent than Federal requirements until eight years after

12

promulgation of maximum achievable control technology (MACT)

13

standards and not until the January 1, 2020 for coke oven

14

batteries that satisfy the requirements of section 112(i)(8)

15

(A) of the Clean Air Act.

16

(3)  Notwithstanding the limitation in paragraph (2), if

17

the operation of a coke oven battery would result in serious,

18

substantial and demonstrable harm to public health, welfare

19

and the environment, the department may impose health-risk-

20

based emission standards by regulation that utilize proven,

21

commercially available and economically available methods of

22

technology.

23

(i)  The department shall not impose health-risk-

24

based emission standards until after January 1, 1998, for

25

those coke oven batteries that satisfy the applicable

26

MACT or lowest achievable emission rate (LAER) standards.

27

(ii)  After January 1, 1998, the department shall

28

only impose health-risk-based emission standards adopted

29

under section 112(f) of the Clean Air Act, and, if no

30

emission standards are adopted under section 112(f) of

- 45 -

 


1

the Clean Air Act, the department may promulgate emission

2

standards, provided that the standards are consistent

3

with the criteria and the factors set forth in paragraph

4

(1) and section 112(f) of the Clean Air Act and until

5

health-risk-based standards are enacted by the Federal

6

Government under section 112(f) of the Clean Air Act.

7

(e)  Reporting.--The department shall have the authority to

8

require, in the plan approval and operating permit, reasonable

9

monitoring, recordkeeping and reporting requirements for sources

10

that emit hazardous air pollutants.

11

(f)  Emergency action.--Nothing in this section may preclude

12

the department from taking an emergency action if there is an

13

immediate or potential threat to public health, welfare and the

14

environment from an air pollutant, including a hazardous air

15

pollutant.

16

(g)  Early emissions reduction program.--The early emissions

17

reduction program authorized under section 112(i)(5) of the

18

Clean Air Act is incorporated by reference in the department's

19

permitting program.

20

(h)  Definition.--For purposes of this section, the term

21

"performance standard" includes design, equipment, work practice

22

or operational standards or any combination of them.

23

§ 2116.7.  Control of volatile organic compounds from gasoline-

24

dispensing facilities.--

25

(a)  (Reserved).

26

(b)  (Reserved).

27

(c)  (Reserved).

28

(d)  (Reserved).

29

(e)  (Reserved).

30

(f)  (Reserved).

- 46 -

 


1

(g)  (Reserved).

2

(h)  Functional testing and certification.--The department

3

shall implement the functional testing and certification

4

requirements specified in the EPA's Stage II enforcement and

5

technical guidance documents developed under section 182 of the

6

Clean Air Act to meet the Clean Air Act requirements for areas

7

classified as moderate, serious, severe or extreme ozone

8

nonattainment.

9

§ 2117.  Public hearings.

10

(a)  In general.--Public hearings shall be held by the board

11

or by the department, acting on behalf and at the direction or

12

request of the board, in any region of this Commonwealth

13

affected before any regulations with regard to the control,

14

abatement, prevention or reduction of air pollution are

15

promulgated for that region or subregion. When it becomes

16

necessary to promulgate regulations for the control, abatement,

17

prevention or reduction of air pollution for more than one

18

region of this Commonwealth, the board may hold one hearing for

19

any two contiguous regions to be affected by the regulations.

20

The hearing may be held in either of the two contiguous regions.

21

If it becomes necessary to promulgate regulations for the

22

control, abatement, prevention or reduction of air pollution for

23

any area of this Commonwealth that encompasses more than one

24

region or parts of more than one region, public hearings shall

25

be held in the area concerned.  Full stenographic transcripts

26

shall be taken of all public hearings and shall be made

27

available by the department to any party concerned with the

28

subject matter of the hearing upon the payment of prevailing

29

rates for the transcripts.

30

(b)  Additional input.--In addition to the matters discussed

- 47 -

 


1

at the public hearings, the board may, in its discretion,

2

solicit the views, in writing, of persons who may be affected

3

by, or interested in, proposed regulations.

4

(c)  Notice.--Notice to the public of the time and place of

5

any public hearing shall be given at least 30 days prior to the

6

scheduled date of the hearing by public advertisement in a

7

newspaper or newspapers of general circulation in the region of

8

this Commonwealth affected.

9

(d)  Power to issue notices.--The persons designated to

10

conduct the hearing shall have the power to issue notices of

11

hearings in the name of the board.

12

(e)  Opportunity to be heard.--Full opportunity to be heard

13

with respect to the subject of the hearing shall be given to all

14

persons in attendance, in addition to which persons, whether or

15

not in attendance, may, within 30 days, submit their views to

16

the department, which the department shall transmit to the board

17

with its report.

18

§ 2117.1.  Compliance review.

19

(a)  Action upon violations.--The department shall not issue,

20

reissue or modify any plan approval or permit under this

21

subchapter or amend any plan approval or permit issued under

22

this subchapter and may suspend, terminate or revoke any permit

23

or plan approval previously issued under this subchapter if it

24

finds that the applicant or permittee or a general partner,

25

parent or subsidiary corporation of the applicant or permittee

26

is in violation of this subchapter, or the regulations

27

promulgated under this subchapter, any plan approval, permit or

28

order of the department, as indicated by the department's

29

compliance docket, unless the violation is being corrected to

30

the satisfaction of the department.

- 48 -

 


1

(b)  Intention or ability to comply.--The department may

2

refuse to issue any plan approval or permit under this

3

subchapter if it finds that the applicant or permittee or a

4

partner, parent or subsidiary corporation of the applicant or

5

permittee has shown a lack of intention or ability to comply

6

with this subchapter or the regulations promulgated under this

7

subchapter or any plan approval, permit or order of the

8

department, as indicated by past or present violations, unless

9

the lack of intention or ability to comply is being or has been

10

corrected to the satisfaction of the department.

11

(c)  In performing the compliance review required under this

12

section, the department shall only consider violations arising

13

under this subchapter that occurred or are occurring in this

14

Commonwealth.

15

(d)  Appeal.--A permittee or applicant may appeal any

16

violation arising under this subchapter that the department

17

places on the compliance docket.

18

§ 2117.2.  Permit compliance schedules.

19

In addition to the other enforcement provisions of this

20

subchapter, the department may issue a permit under section

21

2116.1(b)(3) or (4) (relating to  plan approvals and permits) to

22

a source that is out of compliance with this subchapter, the

23

Clean Air Act or the regulations promulgated under either this

24

subchapter or the Clean Air Act. The permit must contain an

25

enforceable schedule requiring the source to attain compliance.

26

The compliance schedule may contain interim milestone dates for

27

completing any phase of the required work, as well as a final

28

compliance date, and may contain stipulated penalties for

29

failure to meet the compliance schedule. If the permittee fails

30

to achieve compliance by the final compliance date, the permit

- 49 -

 


1

shall terminate. The permit shall be part of an overall

2

resolution of the outstanding noncompliance and may include the

3

payment of an appropriate civil penalty for past violations and

4

shall contain other terms and conditions as the department deems

5

appropriate. A permit may incorporate by reference a compliance

6

schedule contained within a consent order and agreement,

7

including all provisions related to implementation or

8

enforcement of the compliance schedule or consent order and

9

agreement.

10

§ 2117.3.  Responsibilities of owners and operators.

11

(a)  Corrective action.--Whenever the department finds that

12

air pollution or danger of air pollution is or may be resulting

13

from an air contamination source in this Commonwealth, the

14

department may order the owner or operator to take corrective

15

action in a manner satisfactory to the department, or it may

16

order the owner or operator to allow access to the land by the

17

department or a third party to take the action.

18

(b)  Collection of costs.--For purposes of collecting or

19

recovering the costs involved in taking corrective action or

20

pursuing a cost recovery action under an order or recovering the

21

cost of litigation, oversight, monitoring, sampling, testing and

22

investigation related to a corrective action, the department may

23

collect the amount in the same manner as civil penalties are

24

assessed and collected following the process for assessment and

25

collection of a civil penalty contained in section 2119.1

26

(relating to civil penalties).

27

§ 2117.4.  Interstate transport commission.

28

(a)  Public review.--The Commonwealth, through its

29

representatives on an interstate transport commission formed

30

under the Clean Air Act, shall provide public review of

- 50 -

 


1

recommendations for additional control measures prior to final

2

commission action consistent with the commission's public review

3

requirements under section 184(c)(1) of the Clean Air Act. The

4

opportunity for public review shall run concurrently with the

5

commission's public comment period established under section

6

184(c)(1) of the Clean Air Act.

7

(b)  Control strategies.--Control strategies approved by an

8

interstate transport commission and by the Commonwealth's

9

representatives and set forth in resolutions or memoranda of

10

understanding shall be considered commitments by the executive

11

to pursue subsequent legislative, regulatory or other

12

administrative actions to implement the control strategies.

13

(c)  Recommendation.--The Commonwealth strongly recommends

14

that an interstate transport commission adopt formal procedures

15

that allow for an open public review and comment period prior to

16

the adoption of resolutions or consideration of memoranda of

17

understanding or other actions that recommend that states adopt

18

control strategies. The Commonwealth's representatives shall

19

take actions consistent with this recommendation.

20

(d)  Pollutants from Ohio.--The General Assembly finds that

21

the interstate transport of pollutants from the State of Ohio

22

contributes significantly to the violation of national ambient

23

air quality standards by the Commonwealth. Therefore, as set

24

forth in section 176A of the Clean Air Act, the Governor, on

25

behalf of the Commonwealth, may petition the Federal EPA

26

Administrator to include the State of Ohio in any interstate

27

transport commission to which this Commonwealth is a member

28

state.

29

§ 2117.5.  Public review of State implementation plans.

30

(a)  Public comment period.--A State implementation plan

- 51 -

 


1

required by the Clean Air Act that commits the Commonwealth to

2

adopt air pollution control measures or procedures shall be the

3

subject of a public comment period. The public comment period

4

shall be not less than 60 days, and the department may, at its

5

discretion, hold public informational meetings or public

6

hearings as part of the comment period.

7

(b)  Notice.--Notice of a proposed State implementation plan

8

shall be published in the Pennsylvania Bulletin and in

9

sufficient newspapers having general circulation in the area

10

covered by the State implementation plan. If the State

11

implementation plan covers the entire State, notice shall be

12

published in at least six newspapers of general circulation

13

throughout this Commonwealth.

14

(c)  Contents.--A State implementation plan subject to this

15

section shall include the following provisions:

16

(1)  Statements clearly indicating the specific

17

provisions of the Clean Air Act with which the State

18

implementation plan is intended to comply.

19

(2)  An analysis of the alternative control strategies

20

considered if applicable in arriving at the recommended

21

control strategies and the reasons the department or other

22

agency selected the final strategy.

23

(3)  An analysis of the economic impact of the

24

alternative control strategies and the selected strategies on

25

the regulated community and local governments.

26

(4)  An analysis of the staff and technical resources

27

needed by the department or other agency to implement the

28

control strategy.

29

(d)  Submission of final plan.--After the public comment

30

period and prior to the submission to EPA of any State

- 52 -

 


1

implementation plan required by the Clean Air Act that commits

2

the Commonwealth to adopt air pollution control measures or

3

procedures, the department shall submit a final State

4

implementation plan to the board for its review together with a

5

document that responds to all comments made during the public

6

comment period.

7

(e)  Implementation plans from other departments.--This

8

section shall also apply in the case of State implementation

9

plans required under the Clean Air Act that are developed by

10

State agencies other than the department that commit the

11

Commonwealth to the adoption of air pollution control measures

12

or procedures.

13

(f)  Applicability.--Subsections (c) and (d) shall not apply

14

to State implementation plans or portions of them comprised of

15

permit, emission offset or reasonably available control

16

technology requirements for individual sources, consent orders

17

and agreements or regulations.

18

(g)  Plan from local air pollution control agency.--The

19

requirements of this section shall not apply to state

20

implementation plans submitted by a local air pollution control

21

agency.

22

§ 2117.6.  Advice to department.

23

(a)  Citizens Advisory Council.--The department shall consult

24

with the Citizens Advisory Council established under section 448

25

of the act of April 9, 1929 (P.L.177, No.175), known as The

26

Administrative Code of 1929, as appropriate, in the

27

consideration of State implementation plans and regulations

28

developed by the department and needed for the implementation of

29

the Clean Air Act. Nothing in this section may limit the

30

council's ability to consider, study and review department

- 53 -

 


1

policies and other activities related to the Clean Air Act

2

implementation as provided under section 1922-A of The

3

Administrative Code of 1929. This section shall not apply to

4

State implementation plans or portions of them comprised of

5

permit, emission offset or reasonably available control

6

technology requirements for individual sources, consent orders

7

and agreements or regulations. The requirements of this section

8

shall not apply to State implementation plans submitted by a

9

local air pollution control agency.

10

(b)  Air technical advisory committee.--

11

(1)  The Secretary of Environmental Resources, within 30

12

days after January 8, 1960, shall designate an air technical

13

advisory committee. The committee shall include at least 11

14

members with technical backgrounds in the control of air

15

pollution from stationary or mobile sources.

16

(2)  The committee, at the request of the department, may

17

be utilized to provide technical advice on department

18

policies, guidance and regulations needed to implement the

19

Clean Air Act. The committee may also request to review a

20

department policy, guidance or regulation needed to implement

21

the Clean Air Act.

22

§ 2117.7.  Small Business Compliance Assistance Program.

23

(a)  Program.--The department shall develop and implement a

24

Small Business Stationary Source Technical and Environmental

25

Compliance Assistance Program that shall include the following:

26

(1)  Adequate mechanisms for developing, collecting and

27

coordinating information concerning compliance methods and

28

technologies for small business stationary sources and

29

programs to encourage lawful cooperation among the sources

30

and other persons to further comply with this subchapter and

- 54 -

 


1

the Clean Air Act.

2

(2)  Adequate mechanisms for assisting small business

3

stationary sources with pollution prevention and accidental

4

release detection and prevention, including providing

5

information concerning alternative technologies, process

6

changes and products and methods of operation that help

7

reduce air pollution.

8

(3)  A compliance assistance program for small business

9

stationary sources that assists small business stationary

10

sources in determining applicable requirements and in

11

receiving permits under this subchapter in a timely and

12

efficient manner.

13

(4)  Adequate mechanisms to assure that small business

14

stationary sources receive notice of their rights under this

15

subchapter and the Clean Air Act in a manner and form as to

16

assure reasonably adequate time for the sources to evaluate

17

compliance methods and relevant or applicable proposed or

18

final rulemaking plan, State implementation plan revision or

19

program issued under this subchapter and the Clean Air Act.

20

(5)  Adequate mechanisms for informing small business

21

stationary sources of their obligations under this subchapter

22

and the Clean Air Act, including mechanisms for referring

23

these sources to qualified auditors or, at the department's

24

option, for providing audits of the operations of the sources

25

to determine compliance with this subchapter.

26

(6)  Procedures for consideration of requests from a

27

small business stationary source for modification of:

28

(i)  any work practice or technological method of

29

compliance; or

30

(ii)  the schedule of milestones for implementing the

- 55 -

 


1

work practice or method of compliance preceding any

2

applicable compliance date based on the technological and

3

financial capability of any small business stationary

4

source. No modification may be granted unless it is in

5

compliance with the applicable requirements of this

6

subchapter and the Clean Air Act, including the

7

requirements of the applicable implementation plan. If

8

applicable requirements are set forth in Federal

9

regulations, only modifications authorized in the

10

regulations may be allowed.

11

(7)  Procedures for soliciting input from and exchanging

12

information with the Office of Small Business Ombudsman

13

regarding compliance requirements for small business

14

stationary sources.

15

(8)  Adequate mechanisms for the collection and

16

dissemination of information to small business stationary

17

sources, including, but not limited to:

18

(i)  Developing of small business stationary sources

19

guidance manuals indicating the categories of small

20

businesses subject to the requirements of this subchapter

21

and the Clean Air Act, specific compliance requirements

22

and options, a schedule of compliance deadlines and other

23

pertinent information.

24

(ii)  Establishment of a toll-free telephone number

25

dedicated to questions involving small business

26

stationary source compliance.

27

(9)  Procedures for assuring the confidentiality of

28

information received from small business stationary sources.

29

(10)  Procedures for conducting confidential, on-site

30

consultations with small business stationary sources

- 56 -

 


1

regarding applicability of compliance requirements.

2

(b)  Administration.--The department shall evaluate the

3

feasibility of contracting with consultants to administer all or

4

part of the Small Business Stationary Source Technical and

5

Environmental Compliance Assistance Program. A third-party

6

consultant will act as a source of confidential support for

7

small business if one is selected by the department.

8

(c)  Consultation.--The department shall consult with the

9

Compliance Advisory Committee established in section 2117.8

10

(relating to compliance advisory committee) and the Office of

11

Small Business Ombudsman established in section 2117.9 (relating

12

to Small Business Ombudsman) in developing the Small Business

13

Stationary Source Technical and Environmental Compliance

14

Assistance Program.

15

(d)  Public comment.--The department shall provide a

16

reasonable opportunity for public comment on the proposed Small

17

Business Stationary Source Technical and Environmental

18

Compliance Assistance Program.

19

(e)  Authorization.--The department is authorized to expend

20

funds from the Clean Air Fund collected under subsection (a),

21

(b) or (c) of section 2116.3 (relating to fees) to support the

22

development and implementation of the Small Business Stationary

23

Source Technical and Environmental Compliance Assistance

24

Program, the Office of Small Business Ombudsman and the

25

Compliance Advisory Committee.

26

(f)  Certain stationary sources.--Upon petition by a source,

27

the department may, after notice and opportunity for public

28

comment, include as a small business stationary source for

29

purposes of this subchapter any stationary source that is not a

30

small business stationary source but that does not emit more

- 57 -

 


1

than 100 tons per year of all regulated pollutants.

2

(g)  Exclusion from definition.--The department, in

3

consultation with the administrator and the Administrator of the

4

Small Business Administration and after providing notice and

5

opportunity for public hearing, may exclude from the definition

6

of "small business stationary source" in section 2103 (relating

7

to definitions) any category or subcategory of sources that the

8

department determines to have sufficient technical and financial

9

capabilities to meet the requirements of this subchapter and the

10

Clean Air Act without the application of this section.

11

(h)  Reduction of fee.--The department may reduce any fee

12

required under this subchapter and the Clean Air Act to take

13

into account the financial resources of small business

14

stationary sources as authorized by the Clean Air Act.

15

§ 2117.8.  Compliance Advisory Committee.

16

(a)  Establishment.--There is established a Compliance

17

Advisory Committee that shall perform all of the following:

18

(1)  Provide guidance and recommendations to the

19

department on the development of the Small Business

20

Stationary Source Technical and Environmental Compliance

21

Assistance Program.

22

(2)  Render advisory opinions concerning the

23

effectiveness of the Small Business Stationary Source

24

Technical and Environmental Compliance Assistance Program,

25

difficulties encountered and degree and severity of

26

enforcement.

27

(3)  Make periodic reports to the administrator

28

concerning the Small Business Stationary Source Technical and

29

Environmental Compliance Assistance Program.

30

(4)  Review information for small business stationary

- 58 -

 


1

sources to assure the information is understandable by the

2

layperson.

3

(5)  Have the Small Business Stationary Source Technical

4

and Environmental Compliance Assistance Program serve as the

5

secretariat for the development and dissemination of the

6

reports and advisory opinions.

7

(6)  Review and advise the department on rulemaking,

8

State implementation plans and programs under this subchapter

9

and the Clean Air Act that affect small business stationary

10

sources.

11

(7)  Make recommendations for the development of programs

12

to assist compliance for small business stationary sources,

13

including technical and financial assistance programs.

14

(b)  Composition.--The committee shall consist of eleven

15

members as follows:

16

(1)  Four members appointed by the Governor, three of

17

whom shall not be owners or representatives of owners of

18

small business stationary sources.

19

(2)  Four members, each of whom shall be an owner or the

20

representative of an owner of a small business stationary

21

source. Of the four members, one shall be appointed by each

22

of the following:

23

(i)  The Majority Leader of the Senate.

24

(ii)  The Minority Leader of the Senate.

25

(iii)  The Majority Leader of the House of

26

Representatives.

27

(iv)  The Minority Leader of the House of

28

Representatives.

29

(3)  The Secretary of Community and Economic Development

30

or his designee.

- 59 -

 


1

(4)  The Secretary of Environmental Protection or his

2

designee.

3

(5)  The Small Business Ombudsman or his designee.

4

(c)  Terms and vacancies.--The terms of appointed members

5

shall be for four years. Vacancies shall be filled by the

6

original appointing member for the remainder of the unexpired

7

term. Initial terms of appointed members shall be as follows:

8

(1)  Of the members appointed by the Governor under

9

subsection (b)(1):

10

(i)  Two members shall be appointed for two years.

11

(ii)  Two members shall be appointed for four years.

12

(2)  Of the members appointed under subsection (b)(2):

13

(i)  The Majority Leader of the Senate shall appoint

14

one member for four years.

15

(ii)  The Minority Leader of the Senate shall appoint

16

one member for two years.

17

(iii)  The Majority Leader of the House of

18

Representatives shall appoint one member for three years.

19

(iv)  The Minority Leader of the House of

20

Representatives shall appoint one member for one year.

21

§ 2117.9.  Small Business Ombudsman.

22

(a)  Establishment.--There is established an Office of Small

23

Business Ombudsman within the Department of Environmental

24

Protection for the purpose of serving as the confidential

25

primary point of contact for small business on issues relating

26

to compliance with this subchapter and the Clean Air Act.

27

(b)  Duties.--The Office of Small Business Ombudsman shall

28

perform all functions necessary to implement the requirements of

29

section 507(a)(3) of the Clean Air Act. The Office of Small

30

Business Ombudsman shall perform all of the following functions

- 60 -

 


1

to the extent they are consistent with the guidelines developed

2

by the EPA:

3

(1)  Solicit input from small businesses regarding

4

compliance with this subchapter and the Clean Air Act and

5

interact with organizations representing small businesses,

6

including Small Business Development Centers, the Small

7

Business Administration, industry and trade associations and

8

other entities.

9

(2)  Provide guidance and recommendations to the

10

department on the development of the Small Business

11

Stationary Source Technical and Environmental Compliance

12

Assistance Program.

13

(3)  Make recommendations to the department regarding the

14

content and operation of the Small Business Stationary Source

15

Technical and Environmental Compliance Assistance Program.

16

(4)  Collect and distribute information and materials on

17

the requirements of this subchapter and the Clean Air Act.

18

(5)  Report to the Small Business Stationary Source

19

Technical and Environmental Compliance Assistance Program on

20

problems and difficulties experienced by small businesses in

21

complying with this subchapter and the Clean Air Act.

22

(6)  Serve on the Compliance Advisory Committee

23

established by section 2117.8 (relating to Compliance

24

Advisory Committee).

25

(7)  Conduct independent evaluations of all aspects of

26

the Small Business Stationary Source Technical and

27

Environmental Compliance Assistance Program.

28

(8)  Review and provide comments and recommendations to

29

the EPA and department regarding the development and

30

implementation of regulations that impact small businesses.

- 61 -

 


1

(9)  Arrange for and assist in the preparation of

2

guidance documents by the Small Business Stationary Source

3

Technical and Environmental Compliance Assistance Program to

4

ensure that the language is readily understandable by the

5

layperson.

6

(10)  Assist small businesses in locating sources of

7

funding for compliance with the requirements of this

8

subchapter and the Clean Air Act.

9

(c)  Annual report.--The Office of Small Business Ombudsman

10

shall report annually to the Governor and General Assembly on

11

the effectiveness of the Small Business Stationary Source

12

Technical and Environmental Compliance Assistance Program and

13

other issues relating to the impact of the Clean Air Act

14

implementation on small businesses in this Commonwealth.

15

(d)  Certain proposed rulemakings.--For each proposed

16

rulemaking significantly affecting small businesses, the Office

17

of Small Business Ombudsman shall prepare a report that contains

18

a detailed analysis of the economic impact of the proposed

19

rulemaking on small businesses. The economic impact report shall

20

be completed not later than 90 days from the date that the board

21

approves the proposed rulemaking and shall be submitted to the

22

board for consideration prior to approval of the final

23

rulemaking package, provided the report is available within the

24

time period prescribed by this section. The department shall

25

provide the ombudsman with a reasonable opportunity to revise

26

the report to reflect any proposed substantial change in the

27

rulemaking that affects the initial report.

28

(e)  Report contents.--The report shall include, but not be

29

limited to:

30

(1)  An analysis of the economic impact of the selected

- 62 -

 


1

control strategies on small business.

2

(2)  Data on comparable regulatory programs or plans

3

administered by other states.

4

(3)  An assessment of the economic impact of alternative

5

control strategies.

6

(4)  All other information that the Office of Small

7

Business Ombudsman considers necessary for the board's

8

review.

9

(f)  Transfer.--All equipment, files, records, contracts,

10

agreements and all other materials and supplies that are used,

11

employed or expended by the Office of Small Business Ombudsman

12

shall be transferred to the Department of Environmental

13

Protection.

14

§ 2117.10.  Transportation management associations.

15

(a)  Authority of department.--The department, in

16

consultation with the Department of Transportation, may, after

17

public notice and comment, designate one or more transportation

18

management associations to serve specific regions of this

19

Commonwealth to provide services to employers required by the

20

Clean Air Act to reduce employee vehicle trips and encourage the

21

use of carpooling, vanpooling and public transportation to

22

reduce air pollution.

23

(b)  Definition.--As used in this section, the term

24

"transportation management associations" shall consist of

25

nonprofit corporations designated by the department to broker

26

transportation services, including, but not limited to, public

27

transportation, vanpools, carpools, bicycling and pedestrian

28

modes, as well as strategies such as flextime, staggered work

29

hours and compressed work weeks for corporations, employees,

30

developers, individuals and other groups.

- 63 -

 


1

§ 2117.11.  Notice of sanctions.

2

(a)  Notification of finding.--Whenever the Commonwealth is

3

notified that the EPA has made a final or proposed finding on a

4

State implementation plan submitted by the Commonwealth or a

5

local air pollution control agency, the department shall notify,

6

within ten working days of receipt of the notice, the

7

Environmental Resources and Energy Committee of the Senate and

8

the Environmental Resources and Energy Committee of the House of

9

Representatives of the agency's findings.

10

(b)  Notification of sanctions.--Whenever the Commonwealth is

11

formally notified that it is subject to discretionary or

12

mandatory sanctions under section 179 of the Clean Air Act, the

13

department shall, within ten working days of the receipt of the

14

notice, notify the Environmental Resources and Energy Committee

15

of the Senate and the Environmental Resources and Energy

16

Committee of the House of Representatives.

17

§ 2117.12.  Missed Federal deadlines.

18

Whenever the EPA has missed a deadline for developing

19

regulations or guidance on which states must rely to comply with

20

deadlines in the Clean Air Act by more than 90 days and, in the

21

opinion of the department, the EPA has failed to provide it with

22

timely guidance needed to comply with the act in a timely

23

manner, the department may bring a legal action against the EPA

24

in a court of competent jurisdiction seeking an injunction to

25

restrain the EPA from enforcing the applicable Clean Air Act

26

deadline on the Commonwealth until and unless the EPA develops

27

the appropriate regulation or guidance that allows the

28

Commonwealth a reasonable opportunity to comply with the Clean

29

Air Act.

30

§ 2118.  Unlawful conduct.

- 64 -

 


1

It shall be unlawful to:

2

(1)  fail to comply with or to cause or assist in the

3

violation of any of the provisions of this subchapter or the

4

regulations adopted under this subchapter or to fail to

5

comply with any order, plan approval, permit or other

6

requirement of the department;

7

(2)  cause a public nuisance;

8

(3)  cause air pollution, soil or water pollution

9

resulting from an air pollution incident;

10

(4)  hinder, obstruct, prevent or interfere with the

11

department or its personnel in its performance of any duty

12

under this subchapter, including denying the department

13

access to the source or facility; or

14

(5)  violate the provisions of 18 Pa.C.S. § 4903

15

(relating to false swearing) or 4904 (relating to unsworn

16

falsification to authorities) in regard to papers required to

17

be submitted under this subchapter.

18

The owner or operator of an air contamination source shall not

19

allow pollution of the air, water or other natural resources of

20

this Commonwealth resulting from the source. For any air

21

pollutant for which the board has set an emissions standard or

22

for any source for which a permit has been issued by the

23

department, a release of the pollutant in accordance with that

24

standard or permit shall not constitute a violation of this

25

subchapter.

26

§ 2119.  Penalties.

27

(a)  Violations and enforcement.--Any person who violates any

28

provision of this subchapter, any regulation promulgated under

29

this subchapter, any order of the department or any condition or

30

term of any plan approval or permit issued under this subchapter

- 65 -

 


1

commits a summary offense and shall, upon conviction, be

2

sentenced to pay a fine of not less than $100 nor more than

3

$2,500 for each separate offense and, in default of the payment

4

of the fine, may be sentenced to imprisonment for 90 days for

5

each separate offense. Employees of the department authorized to

6

conduct inspections or investigations are declared to be law

7

enforcement officers authorized to issue or file citations for

8

summary violations under this subchapter, and the General

9

Counsel is authorized to prosecute these offenses. For the

10

purpose of this subsection, a summary offense may be prosecuted

11

before any district justice in the county where the offense

12

occurred. There is no Accelerated Rehabilitative Disposition

13

authorized for a summary offense.

14

(b)  Specific violations.--

15

(1)  Any person who willfully or negligently violates any

16

provision of this subchapter, any regulation promulgated

17

under this subchapter or any order of the department or any

18

condition or term of any plan approval or permit issued under

19

this subchapter commits a misdemeanor of the second degree

20

and shall, upon conviction, be sentenced to pay a fine of not

21

less than $1,000 nor more than $50,000 for each separate

22

offense or to imprisonment for a period of not more than two

23

years for each separate offense, or both.

24

(2)  Any person who knowingly makes any false statement

25

or representation in any application, record, report,

26

certification or other document required to be either filed

27

or maintained by this subchapter or the regulations

28

promulgated under this subchapter commits a misdemeanor of

29

the second degree and shall, upon conviction, be sentenced to

30

pay a fine of not less than $2,500 nor more than $50,000 for

- 66 -

 


1

each separate offense or to imprisonment for a period of not

2

more than two years for each separate offense, or both.

3

(3)  Any person who negligently releases into the ambient

4

air any hazardous air pollutant listed under section 112 of

5

the Clean Air Act or any extremely hazardous substance listed

6

under section 302(a)(2) of the Superfund Amendments and

7

Reauthorization Act of 1986 (Public Law 99-499, 100 Stat.

8

1613) that is not listed in section 112 of the Clean Air Act

9

and who at the time negligently places another person in

10

imminent danger of death or serious bodily injury commits a

11

misdemeanor of the third degree and shall, upon conviction,

12

be sentenced to pay a fine of not less than $5,000 nor more

13

than $50,000 for each separate offense or to imprisonment for

14

a period of not more than one year for each separate offense,

15

or both.

16

(c)  Knowing release of hazardous air pollutants.--

17

  (1)  Any person who knowingly releases into the ambient

18

air any hazardous air pollutant listed under section 112 of

19

the Clean Air Act or any extremely hazardous substance listed

20

under section 302(a)(2) of the Superfund Amendments and

21

Reauthorization Act of 1986 that is not listed in section 112

22

of the Clean Air Act and who knows at the time that he, by

23

that release, places another person in imminent danger of

24

death or serious bodily injury commits a felony of the first

25

degree and shall, upon conviction, be sentenced to pay a fine

26

of not less than $25,000 nor more than $100,000 per day for

27

each violation or to imprisonment for a period of not less

28

than two years nor more than 20 years, or both. Any person

29

that is an organization committing the violation shall, upon

30

conviction under this paragraph, be subject to a fine of not

- 67 -

 


1

more than $1,000,000 per day for each violation. If a

2

conviction of any person under this paragraph is for a

3

violation committed after a first conviction of the person

4

under this paragraph, the maximum punishment shall be doubled

5

with respect to both the fine and imprisonment. For any air

6

pollutant for which the board has set an emissions standard

7

or for any source for which a permit has been issued by the

8

department, a release of the pollutant in accordance with

9

that standard or permit shall not constitute a violation of

10

this section.

11

(2)  In determining whether a defendant who is an

12

individual knew that the violation placed another person in

13

imminent danger of death or serious bodily injury:

14

(i)  the defendant is responsible only for actual

15

awareness or actual belief possessed; and

16

(ii)  knowledge possessed by a person other than the

17

defendant, but not by the defendant, may not be

18

attributed to the defendant, except that, in proving a

19

defendant's possession of actual knowledge,

20

circumstantial evidence may be used, including evidence

21

that the defendant took affirmative steps to be shielded

22

from relevant information.

23

(3)  It is an affirmative defense to a prosecution under

24

this subsection that the conduct charged was freely consented

25

to by the person endangered and that the danger and conduct

26

charged were reasonably foreseeable hazards of either of the

27

following:

28

(i)  An occupation, a business or a profession and

29

the person had been made aware of the risks involved

30

prior to giving consent.

- 68 -

 


1

(ii)  Medical treatment or medical or scientific

2

experimentation conducted by professionally approved

3

methods and the other person had been made aware of the

4

risks involved prior to giving consent. The defendant may

5

establish an affirmative defense under this subparagraph

6

by a preponderance of the evidence.

7

(4)  All general defenses, affirmative defenses and bars

8

to prosecution that may apply with respect to other State

9

criminal offenses may apply under this paragraph and shall be

10

determined by the courts according to the principles of

11

common law. Concepts of justification and excuse applicable

12

under this section may be developed according to those

13

principles.

14

(5)  For purposes of this subsection, the term

15

"organization" means a legal entity, other than a government,

16

established or organized for any purpose, and the term

17

includes a corporation, a company, an association, a firm, a

18

partnership, a joint stock company, a foundation, an

19

institution, a trust, a society, a union or any other

20

association of persons.

21

(d)  Negligence.--For purposes of this section, a person acts

22

negligently with respect to a material element of an offense

23

when he should be aware of a substantial and unjustifiable risk

24

that the material element exists or will result from his

25

conduct. The risk must be of such a nature and degree that the

26

actor's failure to perceive it, considering the nature and

27

intent of his conduct and the circumstances known to him,

28

involves a gross deviation from the standard of care that a

29

reasonable person would observe in the actor's situation.

30

(e)  Definitions.--The following words and phrases when used

- 69 -

 


1

as indicated shall have the meanings given to them in this

2

subsection unless the context clearly indicates otherwise:

3

"Operator."  For purposes of subsections (b) and (c), the

4

term includes any person who is senior management personnel or a

5

corporate officer. Except in the case of knowing and willful

6

violations, the term shall not include:

7

(1)  Any person who is a stationary engineer or

8

technician responsible for the operation, maintenance, repair

9

or monitoring of equipment and facilities and who often has

10

supervisory and training duties, but who is not senior

11

management personnel or a corporate officer.

12

(2)  For purposes of subsection (b)(3), an employee who

13

is carrying out his normal activities and who is not a part

14

of senior management personnel or a corporate officer.

15

(3)  For the purposes of subsections (b)(1) and (2) and

16

(c), an employee who is carrying out his normal activities

17

and who is acting under orders from the employer.

18

"Person."  The term includes, in addition to the entities

19

referred to in section 2103 (relating to definitions), any

20

responsible corporate officer.

21

"Serious bodily injury."  For purposes of subsections (b) and

22

(c), bodily injury which involves a substantial risk of death,

23

unconsciousness, extreme physical pain, protracted and obvious

24

disfigurement or protracted loss or impairment of the function

25

of a bodily member, organ or mental faculty.

26

§ 2119.1.  Civil penalties.

27

(a)  General rule.--In addition to proceeding under any other

28

remedy available at law or in equity for a violation of a

29

provision of this subchapter or any regulation promulgated under

30

this subchapter or any order, plan approval or permit issued

- 70 -

 


1

under this subchapter, the department may assess a civil penalty

2

for the violation. The penalty may be assessed whether or not

3

the violation was willful. The civil penalty so assessed shall

4

not exceed $10,000 per day for each violation that occurs in the

5

first three years following enactment of this section, $15,000

6

per day for each violation that occurs in the fourth year

7

following enactment of this section and $25,000 per day for each

8

violation that occurs in the fifth year and all subsequent years

9

following enactment of this section. In determining the amount

10

of the penalty, the department shall consider the willfulness of

11

the violation; damage to air, soil, water or other natural

12

resources of this Commonwealth or their uses; financial benefit

13

to the person in consequence of the violation; deterrence of

14

future violations; cost to the department; the size of the

15

source or facility; the compliance history of the source; the

16

severity and duration of the violation; degree of cooperation in

17

resolving the violation; the speed with which compliance is

18

ultimately achieved; whether the violation was voluntarily

19

reported; other factors unique to the owners or operator of the

20

source or facility; and other relevant factors.

21

(b)  Procedure.--If the department proposes to assess a civil

22

penalty, it shall inform the person of the proposed amount of

23

the penalty. The person charged with the penalty shall then have

24

30 days to pay the proposed penalty in full, or, if the person

25

wishes to contest the amount of the penalty or the fact of the

26

violation to the extent not already established, the person

27

shall forward the proposed amount of the penalty to the hearing

28

board within the 30-day period for placement in an escrow

29

account with the State Treasurer or any Commonwealth bank or

30

post an appeal bond to the hearing board within 30 days in the

- 71 -

 


1

amount of the proposed penalty, provided that the bond is

2

executed by a surety licensed to do business in this

3

Commonwealth and is satisfactory to the department. If, through

4

administrative or final judicial review of the proposed penalty,

5

it is determined that no violation occurred or that the amount

6

of the penalty shall be reduced, the hearing board shall, within

7

30 days, remit the appropriate amount to the person with any

8

interest accumulated by the escrow deposit. Failure to forward

9

the money or the appeal bond at the time of the appeal shall

10

result in a waiver of all legal rights to contest the violation

11

or the amount of the civil penalty unless the appellant alleges

12

financial inability to prepay the penalty or to post the appeal

13

bond. The hearing board shall conduct a hearing to consider the

14

appellant's alleged inability to pay within 30 days of the date

15

of the appeal. The hearing board may waive the requirement to

16

prepay the civil penalty or to post an appeal bond if the

17

appellant demonstrates and the hearing board finds that the

18

appellant is financially unable to pay. The hearing board shall

19

issue an order within 30 days of the date of the hearing to

20

consider the appellant's alleged inability to pay. The amount

21

assessed after administrative hearing or after waiver of

22

administrative hearing shall be payable to the Commonwealth and

23

shall be collectible in any manner provided by law for the

24

collection of debts, including the collection of interest at the

25

rate established in section 2116.3(c) (relating to fees), which

26

shall run from the date of assessment of the penalty. If any

27

person liable to pay the penalty neglects or refuses to pay the

28

same after demand, the amount, together with interest and any

29

costs that may accrue, shall constitute a debt of the person, as

30

may be appropriate, to the Clean Air Fund. The debt shall

- 72 -

 


1

constitute a lien on all property owned by the person when a

2

notice of lien incorporating a description of the property of

3

the person subject to the action is duly filed with the

4

prothonotary of the court of common pleas where the property is

5

located. The prothonotary shall promptly enter upon the civil

6

judgment or order docket, at no cost to the department, the name

7

and address of the person, as may be appropriate, and the amount

8

of the lien as set forth in the notice of lien. Upon entry by

9

the prothonotary, the lien shall attach to the revenues and all

10

real and personal property of the person, whether or not the

11

person is solvent. The notice of lien, filed under this

12

subsection, which affects the property of the person, shall

13

create a lien with priority over all subsequent claims or liens

14

which are filed against the person, but it shall not affect any

15

valid lien, right or interest in the property filed in

16

accordance with established procedure prior to the filing of a

17

notice of lien under this subsection.

18

(c)  Definitions.--The following words and phrases when used

19

in this subsection shall have the meanings given to them in this

20

subsection unless the context clearly indicates otherwise:

21

"Operator."  As defined in section 2119(e) (relating to

22

penalties).

23

§ 2119.2.  Disposition of fees, fines and civil penalties.

24

(a)  Clean Air Fund.--Except as provided under subsection

25

(a.1), all fines, civil penalties and fees collected under this

26

subchapter shall be paid into the State Treasury in a special

27

fund known as the Clean Air Fund, established by this

28

subsection, which, along with interest earned, shall be

29

administered by the department for use in the elimination of air

30

pollution. The department may establish separate accounts as may

- 73 -

 


1

be necessary or appropriate to implement the requirements of

2

this subchapter and the Clean Air Act. The board shall

3

promulgate regulations for the management and use of the money

4

in the fund.

5

(a.1)  Procedure.--The following shall apply:

6

(1)  If an incident results in the imposition of a fine

7

or civil penalty of at least $50,000, 25% of the fine or

8

civil penalty collected shall be returned by the department

9

to the municipality in which the violation occurred to be

10

used for projects that eliminate or reduce air pollution or

11

for parks, recreation projects, trails or open spaces.

12

(2)  The department shall notify the municipality in

13

which the violation occurred of the imposition of the fine or

14

civil penalty under subsection (a) within five business days

15

after the expiration of the right to file an appeal of the

16

fine or civil penalty or after all appeals of the fine or

17

civil penalty have been exhausted.

18

(3)  Within 180 days of the department's notification of

19

the municipality under paragraph (2), the municipality shall

20

submit a project proposal to the department for review and

21

approval.

22

(4)  Upon approval of the project, the department shall

23

release 25% of the fine or civil penalty collected to the

24

municipality. If the cost of the project exceeds 25% of the

25

fine or civil penalty, the department may award additional

26

money from the fine or civil penalty to the municipality.

27

(5)  If all fines and civil penalties deposited into the

28

Clean Air Fund are less than $1,850,000 for the previous

29

fiscal year, paragraph (1) shall not apply for the current

30

fiscal year.

- 74 -

 


1

(6)  If the United States Environmental Protection Agency

2

and the department jointly prosecute a violation of the Clean

3

Air Act, this subchapter or a regulation promulgated under

4

this subchapter, the fines and penalties collected shall not

5

be subject to this subsection and subsection (a.2).

6

(7)  A municipality may assign its claim to funding under

7

paragraph (1) to the county in which the violation occurred

8

within the 180-day period specified in paragraph (3). The

9

county shall submit a project proposal in compliance with

10

paragraph (1) to the department for review and approval

11

within 45 days of the expiration of the 180-day period.

12

(8)  If a municipality does not submit a project proposal

13

within the 180-day period specified in paragraph (3) or

14

provides notification of its intent not to file a project

15

proposal during the 180-day period, the county in which the

16

violation occurred may submit a project proposal in

17

compliance with paragraph (1) to the department for review

18

and approval within 45 days of the expiration of the 180-day

19

period.

20

(a.2)  Notification of violation.--Within five business days

21

of imposition of a fine or civil penalty under this subchapter,

22

the department shall notify the municipality in which the

23

violation occurred of the violation.

24

(b)  Supplementation of Clean Air Fund.--The Clean Air Fund

25

may be supplemented by appropriations from the General Assembly,

26

the Federal, State or local government or any private source.

27

(c)  Exemption.--The Clean Air Fund shall not be subject to

28

42 Pa.C.S. Ch. 37 Subch. C (relating to judicial computer

29

system).

30

§ 2119.3.  Continuing violations.

- 75 -

 


1

Each day of continued violation and each violation of any

2

provision of this subchapter, any regulation promulgated under

3

this subchapter or any order of the department or any condition

4

or term of any plan approval or permit issued under this

5

subchapter shall constitute a separate offense and violation.

6

§ 2120.  (Reserved).

7

§ 2120.1.  Enforcement orders.

8

(a)  General rule.--The department may issue orders as are

9

necessary to aid in the enforcement of the provisions of this

10

subchapter. These orders shall include, but shall not be limited

11

to, orders modifying, suspending, terminating or revoking any

12

plan approvals or permits, orders requiring persons to cease

13

unlawful activities or cease operation of a facility or air

14

contamination source that, in the course of its operation, is in

15

violation of any provision of this subchapter, any regulation

16

promulgated under this subchapter or plan approval or permit,

17

order to take corrective action or to abate a public nuisance or

18

an order requiring the testing, sampling or monitoring of any

19

air contamination source or orders requiring production of

20

information. An order may be issued if the department finds that

21

any condition existing in or on the facility or source involved

22

is causing or contributing to or is creating a danger of air

23

pollution or if it finds that the permittee or any person is in

24

violation of any provision of this subchapter or of any

25

regulation or order of the department.

26

(b)  Content.--The department may, in its order, require

27

compliance with conditions as are necessary to prevent or abate

28

air pollution or effect the purposes of this subchapter.

29

(c)  Effectiveness.--An order issued under this section shall

30

take effect upon notice, unless the order specifies otherwise.

- 76 -

 


1

An appeal to the hearing board of the department's order shall

2

not act as a supersedeas, provided, however, that, upon

3

application and for cause shown, the hearing board may issue a

4

supersedeas under rules established by the hearing board.

5

(d)  Applicability.--The authority of the department to issue

6

an order under this section is in addition to any remedy or

7

penalty which may be imposed under this subchapter. The failure

8

to comply with an order is declared to be a public nuisance.

9

§ 2120.2.  Appealable actions.

10

Any person aggrieved by an order or other administrative

11

action of the department issued under this subchapter or any

12

person who participated in the public comment process for a plan

13

approval or permit shall have the right, within 30 days from

14

actual or constructive notice of the action, to appeal the

15

action to the hearing board in accordance with the act of July

16

13, 1988 (P.L.530, No.94), known as the Environmental Hearing

17

Board Act, and 2 Pa.C.S. Ch. 5 Subch. A (relating to practice

18

and procedure of Commonwealth agencies).

19

§ 2120.3.  Limitation on action.

20

The provisions of any other statute to the contrary

21

notwithstanding, actions for civil or criminal penalties under

22

this subchapter may be commenced at any time within a period of

23

seven years from the date the offense is discovered.

24

§ 2131.  Powers reserved to the department under existing laws.

25

Nothing in this subchapter shall limit in any way whatsoever

26

the powers conferred upon the department under laws other than

27

this subchapter, it being expressly provided that all powers are

28

preserved to the department and may be freely exercised by it.

29

No court exercising general equitable jurisdiction shall be

30

deprived of jurisdiction even though a nuisance or condition

- 77 -

 


1

detrimental to health is subject to regulation or other action

2

by the board under this subchapter.

3

§ 2132.  Powers reserved to political subdivisions.

4

(a)  General rule.--Nothing in this chapter shall prevent

5

counties, cities, towns, townships or boroughs from enacting

6

ordinances with respect to air pollution which will not be less

7

stringent than the provisions of this chapter, the Clean Air Act

8

or the regulations promulgated under either this chapter or the

9

Clean Air Act. This chapter shall not be construed to repeal

10

existing ordinances, resolutions or regulations of political

11

subdivisions under this section existing on January 8, 1960,

12

except as they may be less stringent than the provisions of this

13

chapter, the Clean Air Act or the regulations promulgated under

14

either this chapter or the Clean Air Act.

15

(b)  Applicability of administrative procedures provisions.--

16

The administrative procedures for the abatement, reduction,

17

prevention and control of air pollution set forth in this

18

chapter shall not apply to any county of the first or second

19

class which has and implements an air pollution control program

20

that, at a minimum, meets the requirements of this chapter, the

21

Clean Air Act and the regulations promulgated under both this

22

chapter and the Clean Air Act and has been approved by the

23

department.

24

(b.1)  Applicability of provisions relating to dust control

25

measures.--Provisions of this chapter pertaining to dust control

26

measures shall not apply to portions of highways in townships of

27

the second class where no businesses or residences are located.

28

(c)  Notification of violation.--

29

(1)  Whenever, either upon complaint made to or initiated

30

by the department, the department finds that any person is in

- 78 -

 


1

violation of air pollution control standards, or regulations

2

promulgated under the grant of authority made in subsection

3

(b), the department shall give notification of that fact to

4

that person and to the air pollution control agency of the

5

county involved.

6

(2)  If the violation continues to exist after the

7

notification has been given, the department may take any

8

abatement action provided for under the terms of this

9

chapter.

10

(d)  Failure of local county agency to enforce.--Whenever the

11

department finds that violations of this chapter or the

12

regulations promulgated under this chapter are so widespread

13

that the violations appear to result from a failure of the local

14

county control agency involved to enforce those requirements,

15

the department may assume the authority to enforce this chapter

16

in that county.

17

(e)  Department authority.--The department shall have the

18

power to refuse approval, or to suspend or rescind approval,

19

once given, to any county air pollution control agency if the

20

department finds that the county agency is unable or unwilling

21

to conduct an air pollution control program to abate or reduce

22

air pollution problems within its jurisdiction in accordance

23

with the requirements of this chapter, the Clean Air Act or the

24

regulations promulgated under both this chapter and the Clean

25

Air Act.

26

(f)  Notice of department action.--Whenever the department

27

takes action under subsection (d) or (e), it shall give written

28

notification to the air pollution control agency of the county

29

involved and the notification shall be an appealable action.

30

(g)  Uniformity of penalties and remedies.--

- 79 -

 


1

(1)  Irrespective of subsection (b), and in order that

2

the civil and criminal penalties and equitable remedies for

3

air pollution violations are uniform throughout this

4

Commonwealth, the penalties and remedies set forth in this

5

chapter shall be the penalties and remedies available for

6

enforcement of any municipal air pollution ordinance or

7

regulation, and shall be available to any municipality,

8

public official or other person having standing to initiate

9

proceedings for the enforcement of the municipal ordinance or

10

regulation, and the amounts of the fines or civil penalties

11

set forth in this chapter shall be the amounts of the fines

12

or civil penalties assessable and to be levied for violations

13

of any municipal ordinance or regulation.

14

(2)  Any action for the assessment of civil penalties

15

brought for the enforcement of a municipal air pollution

16

ordinance or regulation shall be brought in accordance with

17

the procedures set forth in the ordinance. If a municipal

18

ordinance or regulation does not provide a procedure for the

19

assessment of civil penalties, the provisions related to

20

assessment and collection of civil penalties of section

21

2119.1 (relating to civil penalties) shall apply.

22

(3)  The General Assembly finds and declares that the

23

intent of this section is to enunciate further that the

24

purpose of this chapter is to provide additional and

25

cumulative remedies to abate the pollution of the air of this

26

Commonwealth.

27

(h)  Pennsylvania Municipalities Planning Code not

28

affected.--Nothing in this chapter shall affect the act of July

29

31, 1968 (P.L.805, No.247), known as the Pennsylvania

30

Municipalities Planning Code, unless required by the Clean Air

- 80 -

 


1

Act.

2

§ 2132.1.  Construction.

3

(a)  Proceeding to abate pollution or nuisance.--Nothing in

4

this chapter shall be construed as estopping the Commonwealth,

5

or any district attorney or solicitor of a municipality, from

6

proceeding in a court of competent jurisdiction to abate

7

pollution forbidden under this chapter, or abate a nuisance

8

under existing law.

9

(b)  Right of action.--Nothing contained in this chapter

10

shall in any way abridge or alter any existing right of action

11

or remedy under law, criminal or civil, nor shall any provision

12

of this chapter, or the granting of any plan approval or permit

13

under this chapter, or any act done by virtue of this chapter,

14

be construed as estopping the Commonwealth, persons or

15

municipalities, in the exercise of their rights under law, from

16

proceeding in a court of competent jurisdiction to suppress a

17

nuisance, or to abate any pollution existing, or enforce common

18

law or a statutory right.

19

(c)  Jurisdiction.--No court of this Commonwealth having

20

jurisdiction to abate public or private nuisance shall be

21

deprived of jurisdiction to abate any private or public nuisance

22

instituted by any person for the reason that the nuisance

23

constitutes air pollution.

24

§ 2133.  Public nuisance.

25

(a)  Violation.--A violation of this chapter or of any

26

regulation promulgated under this chapter or any order, plan

27

approval or permit issued by the department under this chapter

28

shall constitute a public nuisance.

29

(b)  Department authority.--The department shall have the

30

authority to order any person causing a public nuisance to abate

- 81 -

 


1

the public nuisance. In addition, the department or any

2

Commonwealth agency that undertakes to abate a public nuisance

3

may recover the expenses of abatement following the process for

4

assessment and collection of a civil penalty contained in

5

section 2119.1 (relating to civil penalties).

6

(c)  Nuisance continued.--Whenever the nuisance is maintained

7

or continued contrary to this chapter or any regulation

8

promulgated under this chapter or any order, plan approval or

9

permit, the nuisance may be abatable in the manner provided by

10

this chapter. Any person who causes the public nuisance shall be

11

liable for the cost of abatement.

12

§ 2133.1.  Search warrant.

13

(a)  General rule.--Whenever an agent or employee of the

14

department, charged with the enforcement of this chapter, has

15

been refused access to property, or has been refused the right

16

to examine any air contamination source, or air pollution

17

control equipment or device, or is refused access to or

18

examination of books, papers and records pertinent to any matter

19

under investigation, the agent or employee may apply for a

20

search warrant to any Commonwealth official authorized by the

21

laws of this Commonwealth to issue the same to enable the agent

22

or employee to have access, examine and seize the property, air

23

contamination source, air pollution control equipment or device

24

or books, papers and records, as the case may be.

25

(b)  Probable cause.--It shall be sufficient probable cause

26

to issue a search warrant that the inspection is necessary to

27

properly enforce this chapter.

28

§ 2133.2.  Confidential information.

29

(a)  General rule.--All records, reports or information

30

obtained by the department or referred to at public hearings

- 82 -

 


1

under this chapter shall be available to the public, except that

2

upon cause shown by any person that the records, reports or

3

information, or a particular portion of them, but not emission

4

data, to which the department has access under this chapter, if

5

made public, would divulge production or sales figures or

6

methods, processes or production unique to the person or would

7

otherwise tend to affect adversely the competitive position of

8

the person by revealing trade secrets, including intellectual

9

property rights, the department shall consider the record,

10

report or information, or particular portion of it, confidential

11

in the administration of this chapter.

12

(b)  Implementation.--The department shall implement this

13

section consistent with sections 112(d) and 114(c) of the Clean

14

Air Act.

15

(c)  Construction.--Nothing in this section shall be

16

construed to prevent disclosure of the report, record or

17

information to Federal, State or local representatives as

18

necessary for purposes of administration of any Federal, State

19

or local air pollution control laws, or when relevant in any

20

proceeding under this chapter.

21

§ 2133.3.  Air contaminant emissions.

22

(a)  Protocols for air contaminant emissions.--No later than

23

three months after the effective date of this section, the

24

department shall publish protocols for the detection,

25

quantification and reporting of air contaminant emissions from

26

unconventional gas production processes including wellhead

27

activities and the storage of unconventional gas prior to

28

processing.

29

(b)  Report on air contaminant emissions.--No later than nine

30

months after the effective date of this section, the department

- 83 -

 


1

shall publish for public comment a draft report quantifying

2

through measurements and calculations the total air contaminant

3

emissions in this Commonwealth from unconventional gas

4

development processes including wellhead activities and the

5

storage of unconventional gas prior to processing. The

6

department shall publish the final report no later than one year

7

after the effective date of this section. The department shall

8

publish a revised report every five years thereafter.

9

(c)  Use of best available scientific principles.--The

10

department shall use best available scientific principles in

11

developing the protocols and reports required by this section.

12

§ 2133.4.  Exemptions from air pollution requirements for

13

unconventional gas production processes prohibited.

14

No later than 90 days after the effective date of this

15

section, the department shall amend its exemption list under 25

16

Pa. Code § 127.14 (relating to exemptions) to ensure that

17

unconventional gas exploration and production processes,

18

including wellhead activities and storage of natural gas prior

19

to processing, are not exempted from the plan approval process

20

and other requirements of this subchapter.

21

§ 2133.5.  (Reserved).

22

§ 2133.6.  Action to abate nuisance and restrain violation.

23

(a)  Abatement action.--Any activity or condition declared by

24

this chapter to be a nuisance or which is otherwise in violation

25

of this chapter shall be abatable in the manner provided by law

26

for the abatement of public nuisance. In addition, in order to

27

restrain or prevent any violation of this chapter or the

28

regulations promulgated under this chapter or any plan approval

29

or permit or orders issued by the department or to restrain the

30

maintenance and threat of public nuisance, an action may be

- 84 -

 


1

instituted in the name of the Commonwealth upon relation of the

2

Attorney General, the General Counsel, the district attorney of

3

any county or the solicitor of any municipality affected after

4

notice has first been served upon the Attorney General of the

5

intention of the General Counsel, district attorney or solicitor

6

to so proceed.

7

(b)  Jurisdiction.--Proceedings may be prosecuted in

8

Commonwealth Court or in the court of common pleas of the county

9

where the activity has taken place, the condition exists or the

10

public is affected, and, to that end, jurisdiction is conferred

11

upon the courts.

12

(c)  Court action.--Except in cases of emergency if, in the

13

opinion of the court, the exigencies of the case require

14

immediate abatement of the nuisance, the court may, in its

15

decree, fix a reasonable time during which the person

16

responsible for the nuisance may make provision for the

17

abatement of the same.

18

(d)  Injunction.--If circumstances require it or the public

19

health is endangered, a mandatory preliminary injunction,

20

special injunction or temporary restraining order may be issued

21

upon the terms prescribed by the court, notice of the

22

application for the injunction having been given to the

23

defendant. The Attorney General, the General Counsel, the

24

district attorney or the solicitor of any municipality shall not

25

be required to give bond. In the proceeding, the court shall,

26

upon motion of the Commonwealth, issue a prohibitory or

27

mandatory preliminary injunction if it finds that the defendant

28

is engaging in unlawful conduct as defined by this chapter or is

29

engaged in conduct that is causing immediate and irreparable

30

harm to the public. In addition to an injunction, the court may

- 85 -

 


1

levy civil penalties in the same manner as the department in

2

accordance with section 2119.1 (relating to civil penalties).

3

(e)  Civil action.--

4

(1)  Except as provided in subsection (f), any person may

5

commence a civil action to compel compliance with this

6

chapter or any regulation, order or plan approval or permit

7

issued under this chapter by any owner or operator alleged to

8

be causing or contributing to a violation of any provision of

9

this chapter or any regulation promulgated under this chapter

10

or any plan approval, permit or order issued by the

11

department.

12

(2)  In addition to seeking to compel compliance, any

13

person may request the court to award civil penalties. The

14

court shall use the factors and amounts contained in section

15

2119.1 in awarding civil penalties under this subsection.

16

Penalties shall be paid into the Clean Air Fund or be used to

17

prevent air pollution in the county where the violation

18

occurred.

19

(3)  Unless otherwise required under 42 Pa.C.S. (relating

20

to judiciary and judicial procedure), the courts of common

21

pleas shall have jurisdiction of actions brought under this

22

subsection.

23

(4)  An action may not be commenced if the department has

24

commenced and is diligently prosecuting a civil action in a

25

Federal or State court or is in litigation before the hearing

26

board to require the alleged violator to comply with this

27

chapter, any regulation promulgated under this chapter or any

28

order, plan approval or permit issued under this chapter,

29

but, in an action in a Federal or State court or before the

30

hearing board, any person having or representing an interest

- 86 -

 


1

that is or may be adversely affected may intervene as a

2

matter of right without posting bond.

3

(f)  Commencement of action.--An action under subsection (e)

4

may not be commenced prior to 60 days after the plaintiff has

5

given notice in writing of the violation to the department and

6

to any alleged violator.

7

(g)  Exception to notice provision.--The notice provision of

8

subsection (f) to the contrary notwithstanding, any action under

9

subsection (e) may be initiated immediately upon written

10

notification to the department if the violation or condition

11

complained of constitutes an imminent threat to the health or

12

safety of the plaintiff or would immediately affect a legal

13

interest of the plaintiff.

14

(h)  Court order.--The court, in issuing any final order in

15

any action brought under subsection (e), may award costs of

16

litigation, including attorney and expert witness fees, to any

17

party whenever the court determines that an award is

18

appropriate. Except as provided in subsection (d), the court

19

may, if a temporary restraining order or preliminary injunction

20

is sought, require the filing of a bond or equivalent security

21

in accordance with the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure.

22

SUBCHAPTER C

23

PERMIT FEES

24

Sec.

25

2141.  General provisions.

26

2142.  Definitions.

27

2143.  Plan approval fees.

28

2144.  Operating permit fees.

29

2145.  Title V operating permit fees.

30

2146.  Emission fees.

- 87 -

 


1

2147.  Philadelphia County and Allegheny County financial

2

assistance.

3

2148.  Failure to pay fee.

4

2149.  Risk assessment.

5

§ 2141.  General provisions.

6

(a)  Scope.--This subchapter establishes fees to cover the

7

direct and indirect costs of administering the air pollution

8

control planning process, operating permit program required by

9

Title V of the Clean Air Act (69 Stat. 322, 42 U.S.C. §§

10

7661-7661f), other requirements of the Clean Air Act, the

11

indirect and direct costs of administering the Small Business

12

Stationary Source Technical and Environmental Compliance

13

Assistance Program, Compliance Advisory Committee and the Office

14

of Small Business Ombudsman and the costs to support the air

15

pollution control program authorized by Subch. B (relating to

16

regulating program).

17

(b)  Fund.--The fees collected under this subchapter shall be

18

made payable to the Pennsylvania Clean Air Fund and deposited

19

into the Clean Air Fund established under section 2119.2

20

(relating to disposition of fees, fines and civil penalties).

21

(c)  Deposit.--Fees collected under this subchapter to

22

implement the requirements of Title V of the Clean Air Act and

23

the Small Business Stationary Source Technical and Environmental

24

Compliance Assistance, Compliance Advisory Committee and the

25

Office of Small Business Ombudsman shall be made payable to the

26

Pennsylvania Clean Air Fund and deposited into a restricted

27

revenue account within the Clean Air Fund.

28

(d)  Evaluation.--At least every five years, the department

29

will provide the board with an evaluation of the fees in this

30

subchapter and recommend regulatory changes to the board to

- 88 -

 


1

address any disparity between the program income generated by

2

the fees and the department's cost of administering the air

3

quality program with the objective of ensuring sufficient fees

4

to meet all program costs.

5

§ 2142.  Definitions.

6

The following words and phrases when used in this subchapter

7

shall have the meanings given to them in this section unless the

8

context clearly indicates otherwise:

9

"Title V facility."  The term shall have the same meaning as

10

in 25 Pa. Code § 121.1 (relating to definitions).

11

§ 2143.  Plan approval fees.

12

(a)  General rule.--Each applicant for a plan approval shall,

13

as part of the plan approval application, submit the application

14

fee required by this section to the department.

15

(b)  Fees.--Except as provided in subsections (c), (d), (e),

16

(f), (g), (h), (i) and (j), the owner or operator of a source

17

requiring approval under 25 Pa. Code Ch. 127 Subch. B (relating

18

to plan approval requirements) shall pay a fee equal to:

19

(1)  One thousand three hundred dollars for applications

20

filed during the 2012—2014 calendar years.

21

(2)  One thousand six hundred dollars for applications

22

filed during the 2015—2019 calendar years.

23

(3)  Two thousand dollars for applications filed for the

24

calendar years beginning in 2020.

25

(c)  New nonattainment sources.--The owner or operator of a

26

source requiring approval under 25 Pa. Code Ch. 127 Subch. E

27

(relating to new source review) shall pay a fee equal to:

28

(1)  Six thousand three hundred dollars for applications

29

filed during the 2012—2014 calendar years.

30

(2)  Seven thousand three hundred dollars for

- 89 -

 


1

applications filed during the 2015—2019 calendar years.

2

(3)  Eight thousand dollars for applications filed for

3

the calendar years beginning in 2020.

4

(d)  New stationary sources.--The owner or operator of a

5

source subject to standards adopted under 25 Pa. Code Ch. 122

6

(relating to national standards of performance for new

7

stationary sources) or 124 (relating to national emission

8

standards for hazardous air pollutants) or section 127.35(b)

9

(relating to maximum achievable control technology standards for

10

hazardous air pollutants) shall pay a fee equal to:

11

(1)  Two thousand dollars for applications filed during

12

the 2012—2014 calendar years.

13

(2)  Two thousand five hundred dollars for applications

14

filed during the 2015—2019 calendar years.

15

(3)  Three thousand dollars for applications filed during

16

the calendar years beginning in 2020.

17

(e)  Hazards.--The owner or operator of a source subject to

18

25 Pa. Code § 127.35(c), (d) or (h) shall pay a fee equal to:

19

(1)  Ten thousand dollars for applications filed during

20

the 2012—2014 calendar years.

21

(2)  Twelve thousand dollars for applications filed

22

during the 2015—2019 calendar years.

23

(3)  Fourteen thousand dollars for applications filed

24

during the calendar years beginning in 2020.

25

(f)  Deterioration.--The owner or operator of a source

26

requiring approval under 25 Pa. Code Ch. 127 Subch. D (relating

27

to prevention of significant deterioration of air quality) shall

28

pay a fee equal to:

29

(1)  Twenty-seven thousand two hundred dollars for

30

applications filed during the 2012—2014 calendar years.

- 90 -

 


1

(2)  Thirty thousand seven hundred dollars for

2

applications filed during the 2015—2019 calendar years.

3

(3)  Thirty-five thousand seven hundred dollars for

4

applications filed during the calendar years beginning 2020.

5

(g)  Changes.--Except as provided in subsection (h), the

6

owner or operator of a source proposing a modification of a plan

7

approval, extension of a plan approval or transfer of a plan

8

approval due to a change of ownership, shall pay a fee equal to:

9

(1)  Four hundred dollars for applications filed during

10

the 2012—2014 calendar years.

11

(2)  Five hundred dollars for applications filed during

12

the 2015—2019 calendar years.

13

(3)  Six hundred fifty dollars for applications filed

14

during the calendar years beginning in 2020.

15

(h)  Reassessment.--The amendment of a plan approval or

16

revision of an application by the applicant that requires the

17

reassessment of a control technology determination or of the

18

ambient impacts of the source is a significant modification of

19

the plan approval or application.

20

(1)  The applicant proposing an amendment of the plan

21

approval or revision to an application that requires

22

reassessment of a control technology determination shall pay

23

fees as established under subsections (b), (c), (d), (e) and

24

(f).

25

(2)  The applicant proposing an amendment of a plan

26

approval or revision to an application that requires changes

27

to the ambient impact analysis or department reanalysis of

28

the ambient impacts of the source to meet the requirements of

29

40 CFR 51, Appendix W (relating to guideline on air quality

30

models), shall pay fees in accordance with the following:

- 91 -

 


1

(i)  For modeling using a screening technique as

2

defined in 40 CFR 51, Appendix W:

3

(A)  Three thousand five hundred dollars for

4

applications filed during the 2012—2014 calendar

5

years.

6

(B)  Four thousand five hundred dollars for

7

applications filed during the 2015—2019 calendar

8

years.

9

(C)  Six thousand dollars for applications filed

10

for calendar years beginning in 2020.

11

(ii)  For all other modeling as defined in 40 CFR 51,

12

Appendix W:

13

(A)  Seven thousand five hundred dollars for

14

applications filed during the 2012—2014 calendar

15

years.

16

(B)  Nine thousand dollars for applications filed

17

during the 2015—2019 calendar years.

18

(C)  Eleven thousand dollars for applications

19

filed for the calendar years beginning in 2020.

20

(i)  Multiple location sources.--The department may establish

21

application fees for general plan approvals and plan approvals

22

for sources operating at multiple temporary locations that will

23

not be greater than the fees established under this section.

24

These fees will be established at the time the plan approval is

25

issued and will be published in the Pennsylvania Bulletin as

26

provided in 25 Pa. Code §§ 127.612 (relating to public notice

27

and review period) and 127.632 (relating to public notice and

28

review period).

29

(j)  Determination.--The owner or operator of a source that

30

submits a request for determination for:

- 92 -

 


1

(1)  A plan approval application shall pay a fee equal

2

to:

3

(i)  Four hundred dollars for requests for

4

determination filed during the 2012—2014 calendar years.

5

(ii)  Five hundred dollars for requests for

6

determination filed during the 2015—2019 calendar years.

7

(iii)  Six hundred fifty dollars for requests for

8

determination filed for the calendar years beginning in

9

2020.

10

(2)  Both a plan approval under this section and an

11

operating permit under 2144 (relating to operating permit

12

fees) shall pay one request for determination fee.

13

(k)  Publication of fees.--The owner or operator of a source

14

proposing to use a general plan approval under 25 Pa. Code Ch.

15

27 Subch. H (relating to general plan approvals and operating

16

permits) shall pay a fee that will not be greater than the fees

17

established under this section. The department will establish

18

these fees at the time the general plan approval is issued and

19

will publish the fees in the Pennsylvania Bulletin as provided

20

in 25 Pa. Code §§ 127.612 and 127.632.

21

§ 2144.  Operating permit fees.

22

(a)  General rule.--Each applicant for an operating permit

23

which is not a Title V facility shall, as part of the operating

24

permit application and as required on an annual basis, submit

25

the fees required under this section to the department. These

26

fees apply to an administrative amendment, extension, minor

27

modification, revision, renewal, reissuance or transfer due to a

28

change of ownership of each operating permit or part thereof.

29

(b)  Processing fees.--The fee for processing an application

30

for an operating permit is:

- 93 -

 


1

(1)  Five hundred dollars for applications filed during

2

the 2012—2014 calendar years.

3

(2)  Six hundred dollars for applications filed during

4

the 2015—2019 calendar years.

5

(3)  Eight hundred fifty dollars for applications filed

6

for the calendar years beginning in 2020.

7

(c)  Administration fee.--The annual operating permit

8

administration fee is due on or before March 1 of each year for

9

the current calendar year.

10

(1)  Five hundred dollars for the 2012—2014 calendar

11

years.

12

(2)  Six hundred dollars for the 2015—2019 calendar

13

years.

14

(3)  Seven hundred fifty dollars for the calendar years

15

beginning in 2020.

16

(d)  Establishment.--The department may establish application

17

fees for general operating permits and operating permits for

18

sources operating at multiple temporary locations that will not

19

be greater than the fees established under this section. These

20

fees will be established at the time the operating permit is

21

issued and will be published in the Pennsylvania Bulletin as

22

provided in 25 Pa. Code §§ 127.612 (relating to public notice

23

and review period) and 127.632 (relating to public notice and

24

review period).

25

(e)  Determination fees.--The owner or operator of a source

26

that submits a request for determination for:

27

(1)  An operating permit shall pay a fee equal to:

28

(i)  Four hundred dollars for requests for

29

determination filed during the 2012—2014 calendar years.

30

(ii)  Five hundred dollars for requests for

- 94 -

 


1

determination filed during the 2015—2019 calendar years.

2

(iii)  Six hundred fifty dollars for requests for

3

determination filed for the calendar years beginning in

4

2020.

5

(2)  Both an operating permit under this section and a

6

plan approval under 25 Pa Code § 127.702 (relating to plan

7

approval fees) shall pay one request for determination fee.

8

(f)  General plans and permits.--The owner or operator of a

9

source proposing to use a general plan approval under 25 Pa.

10

Code Ch. 127 Subch. H (relating to general plan approvals and

11

operating permits) shall pay a fee that will not be greater than

12

the fees established under this section. The department will

13

establish these fees at the time the general plan approval is

14

issued and will publish the fees in the Pennsylvania Bulletin

15

provided in 25 Pa. Code §§ 127.612 and 127.632.

16

§ 2145.  Title V operating permit fees.

17

(a)  General rule.--Each applicant for an operating permit

18

which is a Title V facility shall, as part of the operating

19

permit application and as required on an annual basis, submit

20

the fees required under this section to the department. These

21

fees apply to an administrative amendment, extension, minor

22

modification, revision, renewal, reissuance or transfer due to a

23

change of ownership of each operating permit or part thereof.

24

(b)  Fee.--The fee for processing an application for an

25

operating permit is:

26

(1)  Nine hundred dollars for applications filed during

27

the 2012—2014 calendar years.

28

(2)  One thousand one hundred dollars for applications

29

filed during the 2015—2019 calendar years.

30

(3)  One thousand five hundred dollars for applications

- 95 -

 


1

filed for the calendar years beginning in 2020.

2

(c)  Administration fee.--The annual operating permit

3

administration fee to be paid by a facility identified in

4

subparagraph (iv) of the definition of a Title V facility in 25

5

Pa. Code § 121.1 (relating to definitions):

6

(1)  Nine hundred dollars for applications filed during

7

the 2012—2014 calendar years.

8

(2)  One thousand one hundred dollars for applications

9

filed during the 2015-2019 calendar years.

10

(3)  One thousand three hundred dollars for applications

11

filed for the calendar years beginning in 2020.

12

(d)  Temporary locations.--The department may establish

13

application fees for general operating permits and operating

14

permits for sources operating at multiple temporary locations

15

that will not be greater than the fees established under this

16

section. These fees will be established at the time the

17

operating permit is issued and will be published in the

18

Pennsylvania Bulletin as provided in 25 Pa. Code §§ 127.612

19

(relating to public notice and review period) and 127.632

20

(relating to public notice and review period).

21

(e)  Establishment of fees.--The owner or operator of a

22

source proposing to use a general plan approval under 25 Pa.

23

Code Ch. 127 Subch. H (relating to general plan approvals and

24

operating permits) shall pay a fee that will not be greater than

25

the fees established under this section. The department will

26

establish these fees at the time the general plan approval is

27

issued and will publish the fees in the Pennsylvania Bulletin as

28

provided in Pa. Code §§ 127.612 and 127.632.

29

§ 2146.  Emission fees.

30

(a)  General rule.--Beginning January 1, 2010, the owner or

- 96 -

 


1

operator of a Title V facility including Title V facilities

2

located in Allegheny County and Philadelphia County, except a

3

facility identified in subparagraph (iv) of the definition of a

4

Title V facility in 25 Pa. Code § 121.1 (relating to

5

definitions), shall pay an annual Title V emission fee of $70

6

per ton for each ton of a regulated pollutant actually emitted

7

from the facility. The owner or operator will not be required to

8

pay an emission fee for emissions of more than 4,000 tons of

9

each regulated pollutant from the facility. Sources located in

10

Philadelphia County and Allegheny County shall pay the emission

11

fee to the county program if the county Title V program has

12

received approval under section 2132 (relating to powers

13

reserved to political subdivisions), and 25 Pa. Code § 127.706

14

(relating to Philadelphia County and Allegheny County financial

15

assistance).

16

(b)  Fees.--The emissions fees required by this section shall

17

be due on or before September 1 of each year for emissions from

18

the previous calendar year. The fees required by this section

19

shall be paid for emissions occurring in calendar year 2009 and

20

for each calendar year thereafter.

21

(c)  Definition.--As used in this section, the term

22

"regulated pollutant" means a VOC, each pollutant regulated

23

under sections 111 and 112 of the Clean Air Act (69 Stat. 322,

24

42 U.S.C. §§ 111—112) and each pollutant for which a national

25

ambient air quality standard has been promulgated, except that

26

carbon monoxide shall be excluded from this reference.

27

(d)  Increased fees.--The emission fee imposed under

28

subsection (a) shall be increased in each calendar year after

29

2010, by the percentage, if any, by which the Consumer Price

30

Index for the most recent calendar year exceeds the Consumer

- 97 -

 


1

Price Index for the previous calendar year.

2

§ 2147.  Philadelphia County and Allegheny County financial

3

assistance.

4

(a)  General rule.--Philadelphia and Allegheny Counties shall

5

submit their local air pollution control program including Title

6

V operating permit program implementation plan to the department

7

for review and approval. The plan shall include the elements

8

necessary for approval of a Title V program under the Clean Air

9

Act (69 Stat. 322, 42 U.S.C. §7401 et seq.) and shall be

10

consistent with the department's regulations for implementation

11

of the air pollution control program, including the Title V

12

operating permit program.

13

(b)  Report.--On an annual basis according to a schedule

14

established by the department, Philadelphia County and Allegheny

15

County shall submit a description of the implementation of the

16

local air pollution control program including the Title V

17

operating permit program in the county along with a detailed

18

accounting of the costs of implementation.

19

(c)  Title V.--On an annual basis according to a schedule

20

established by the department, the department may provide

21

payment of a portion of the Title V emission fees collected by

22

the department as necessary, appropriate and available to

23

Philadelphia and Allegheny Counties to assist in implementation

24

of the Title V operating permit program in the counties. The

25

department may withhold this financial assistance if the county

26

has not implemented the Title V program in the manner required

27

by this section.

28

(d)  Restricted account.--The fees imposed by Philadelphia

29

and Allegheny Counties shall be deposited in a restricted

30

account established by the governing body authorizing the local

- 98 -

 


1

program for use by that program to implement the provisions of

2

Subch. B (relating to regulatory program) for which they are

3

responsible. The governing body shall annually submit to the

4

department an audit of the account in order to insure that the

5

funds were properly spent.

6

§ 2148.  Failure to pay fee.

7

An air contamination source that fails to pay the fees within

8

the time frame established by this chapter shall pay a penalty

9

of 50% of the fee amount, plus interest on the fee amount

10

computed in accordance with 26 U.S.C. § 6621(a)(2) (relating to

11

determination of rate of interest) from the date the fee was

12

required to be paid. In addition, the source may have its

13

operating permit terminated or suspended. The fee, penalty and

14

interest may be collected following the process for assessment

15

and collection of a civil penalty contained in section 2119.1

16

(relating to civil penalties).

17

§ 2149.  Risk assessment.

18

(a)  General rule.--Each applicant for a risk assessment

19

shall, as part of the plan approval application, submit the

20

application fee required by this section to the department.

21

(b)  With screening model.--The owner or operator of a source

22

applying for a risk assessment that is inhalation only with a

23

screening model shall pay a fee equal to:

24

(1)  Five thousand dollars for applications filed during

25

the 2012—2014 calendar years.

26

(2)  Six thousand dollars for applications filed during

27

the 2015—2019 calendar years.

28

(3)  Seven thousand two hundred dollars for applications

29

filed for the calendar years beginning in 2020.

30

(c)  Inhalation only assessment.--The owner or operator of a

- 99 -

 


1

source applying for a risk assessment that is inhalation only

2

for all other modeling shall pay a fee equal to:

3

(1)  Nine thousand dollars for applications filed during

4

the 2012—2014 calendar years.

5

(2)  Eleven thousand dollars for applications filed

6

during the 2015—2019 calendar years.

7

(3)  Thirteen thousand dollars for applications filed for

8

the calendar years beginning in 2020.

9

(d)  Multipathway risk assessment.--The owner or operator of

10

a source applying for a risk assessment that is multipathway

11

shall pay a fee equal to:

12

(1)  Ten thousand dollars for applications filed during

13

the 2012—2014 calendar years.

14

(2)  Twelve thousand dollars for applications filed

15

during the 2015—2019 calendar years.

16

(3)  Fourteen thousand five hundred dollars for

17

applications filed for the calendar years beginning in 2020.

18

Section 2.  Repeals are as follows:

19

(1)  The General Assembly declares that the repeal under

20

paragraph (2) is necessary to effectuate the addition of 35

21

Pa.C.S. Ch. 21.

22

(2)  The act of January 8, 1960 (1959 P.L.2119, No.787),

23

known as the Air Pollution Control Act, is repealed.

24

Section 3.  The addition of 35 Pa.C.S. Ch. 21 is a

25

continuation of the act of January 8, 1960 (1959 P.L.2119,

26

No.787), known as the Air Pollution Control Act. The following

27

apply:

28

(1)  Except as otherwise provided in 35 Pa.C.S. Ch. 21,

29

all activities initiated under the Air Pollution Control Act

30

shall continue and remain in full force and effect and may be

- 100 -

 


1

completed under 35 Pa.C.S. Ch. 21. Orders, regulations, rules

2

and decisions which were made under the Air Pollution Control

3

Act and which are in effect on the effective date of section

4

3(2) of this act shall remain in full force and effect until

5

revoked, vacated or modified under 35 Pa.C.S. Ch. 21.

6

Contracts, obligations and collective bargaining agreements

7

entered into under the Air Pollution Control Act are not

8

affected nor impaired by the repeal of the Air Pollution

9

Control Act.

10

(2)  Except as set forth in paragraph (3), any difference

11

in language between 35 Pa.C.S. Ch. 21 and the Air Pollution

12

Control Act is intended only to conform to the style of the

13

Pennsylvania Consolidated Statutes and is not intended to

14

change or affect the legislative intent, judicial

15

construction or administration and implementation of the Air

16

Pollution Control Act.

17

(3)  Paragraph (2) does not apply to the addition of the

18

following provisions:

19

(i)  35 Pa.C.S. § 2133.3.

20

(ii)  35 Pa.C.S. § 2133.4.

21

(iii)  35 Pa.C.S. Ch. 21 Subch. C.

22

Section 4.  This act shall take effect in 60 days.

- 101 -