PRINTER'S NO. 1959
No. 1559 Session of 2007
INTRODUCED BY KENNEY, DONATUCCI, J. TAYLOR, WATERS, OLIVER, BISHOP, CRUZ, YOUNGBLOOD, M. O'BRIEN, W. KELLER, KORTZ AND PAYNE, JUNE 18, 2007
REFERRED TO COMMITTEE ON TRANSPORTATION, JUNE 18, 2007
AN ACT 1 Amending Title 75 (Vehicles) of the Pennsylvania Consolidated 2 Statutes, further providing for automated red light 3 enforcement systems in first class cities; and providing for 4 automated speed timing systems in first class cities. 5 The General Assembly of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania 6 hereby enacts as follows: 7 Section 1. Section 3116(e) and (q) of Title 75 of the 8 Pennsylvania Consolidated Statutes are amended to read: 9 § 3116. Automated red light enforcement systems in first class 10 cities. 11 * * * 12 (e) Limitations.-- 13 (1) No automated red light enforcement system shall be 14 utilized in such a manner as to take a frontal view 15 photograph of the vehicle as evidence of having committed a 16 violation. 17 (2) Notwithstanding any other provision of law, camera 18 equipment deployed as part of an automated red light
1 enforcement system as provided in this section must be 2 incapable of automated or user-controlled remote intersection 3 surveillance by means of recorded video images. Photographs 4 collected as part of the automated red light enforcement 5 system [must be 35-millimeter film only,] must only record 6 traffic violations and may not be used for any other 7 surveillance purposes. The restrictions set forth in this 8 paragraph shall not be deemed to preclude a court of 9 competent jurisdiction from issuing an order directing that 10 the information be provided to law enforcement officials if 11 the information is reasonably described and is requested 12 solely in connection with a criminal law enforcement action. 13 (3) Notwithstanding any other provision of law, 14 information prepared under this section and information 15 relating to violations under this section which is kept by 16 the city of the first class, its authorized agents or its 17 employees, including photographs, written records, reports or 18 facsimiles, names, addresses and the number of violations 19 under this section, shall be for the exclusive use of the 20 city, its authorized agents, its employees and law 21 enforcement officials for the purpose of discharging their 22 duties under this section and under any ordinances and 23 resolutions of the city. The information shall not be deemed 24 a public record under the act of June 21, 1957 (P.L.390, 25 No.212), referred to as the Right-to-Know Law. The 26 information shall not be discoverable by court order or 27 otherwise, nor shall it be offered in evidence in any action 28 or proceeding which is not directly related to a violation of 29 this section or any ordinance or resolution of the city. The 30 restrictions set forth in this paragraph shall not be deemed 20070H1559B1959 - 2 -
1 to preclude a court of competent jurisdiction from issuing an 2 order directing that the information be provided to law 3 enforcement officials if the information is reasonably 4 described and is requested solely in connection with a 5 criminal law enforcement action. 6 (4) Photographic evidence obtained through the use of 7 automated red light enforcement systems deployed as a means 8 of promoting traffic safety in a city of the first class 9 shall be destroyed within one year of final disposition of 10 any recorded event. The city shall file notice with the 11 Department of State that the records have been destroyed in 12 accordance with this section. 13 (5) Notwithstanding any other provision of law, 14 registered vehicle owner information obtained as a result of 15 the operation of an automated red light enforcement system 16 under this section shall not be the property of the 17 manufacturer or vendor of the automated red light enforcement 18 system and may not be used for any purpose other than 19 prescribed in this section. 20 * * * 21 (q) Expiration.--This section shall expire December 31, 22 [2007] 2009. 23 Section 2. Title 75 is amended by adding a section to read: 24 § 3369. Automated speed timing systems in first class cities. 25 (a) General rule.-- 26 (1) Except as otherwise provided in subsection (b), a 27 city of the first class, upon passage of an ordinance, is 28 authorized to enforce section 3362 (relating to maximum speed 29 limits) by recording violations using an automated speed 30 timing system approved by the department, which may include 20070H1559B1959 - 3 -
1 electronic devices such as radio-microwave devices, commonly 2 referred to as electronic speed meters or radar, restricted 3 to use by members of the Pennsylvania State Police pursuant 4 to section 3368(c) (relating to speed timing devices). 5 (2) Except as otherwise provided in subsection (b), this 6 section shall only be applicable at State and local highways 7 in a city of the first class agreed upon by the system 8 administrator and the secretary. 9 (b) Emergency implementation.--The system administrator and 10 the secretary shall implement an automated speed timing system 11 at locations deemed necessary for public safety on U.S. Route 1 12 (Roosevelt Boulevard) between Broad Street and the Philadelphia 13 County line shared with Bucks County, State Route 3025 14 (Lindbergh Boulevard) and State Route 3019 (Passyunk Avenue) 15 without need of an ordinance under subsection (a)(1). 16 (c) Owner liability.--For each violation pursuant to this 17 section, the owner of the vehicle shall be liable for the 18 penalty imposed unless the owner is convicted of the same 19 violation under another section of this title or has a defense 20 under subsection (g). 21 (d) Certificate as evidence.--A certificate, or a facsimile 22 of a certificate, based upon inspection of photographs produced 23 by an automated speed timing system and sworn to or affirmed by 24 a police officer employed by a city of the first class or a 25 member of the Pennsylvania State Police shall be prima facie 26 evidence of the facts contained in it. The system administrator 27 must include written documentation that the automated speed 28 timing system was operating correctly at the time of the alleged 29 violation. A photograph evidencing a violation of section 3362 30 shall be admissible in any judicial or administrative proceeding 20070H1559B1959 - 4 -
1 to adjudicate the liability for the violation. 2 (e) Penalty.-- 3 (1) The penalty for a violation under subsections (a) 4 and (b) shall be a fine of: 5 (i) $125, if the speed recorded is six to ten miles 6 per hour in excess of the legal speed limit. 7 (ii) $150, if the speed recorded is 11 to 15 miles 8 per hour in excess of the legal speed limit. 9 (iii) $200, if the speed recorded is 16 to 20 miles 10 per hour in excess of the legal speed limit. 11 (iv) $300, if the speed recorded is 21 to 25 miles 12 per hour in excess of the legal speed limit. 13 (v) $400, if the speed recorded is 26 to 30 miles 14 per hour in excess of the legal speed limit. 15 (vi) $500, if the speed recorded is 31 or more miles 16 per hour in excess of the legal speed limit. 17 (2) A fine is not authorized during the first 30 days of 18 operation of the automated system at each location. 19 (3) A warning may be sent to the violator under 20 paragraph (2). 21 (4) A penalty imposed under this section shall not be 22 deemed a criminal conviction and shall not be made part of 23 the operating record under section 1535 (relating to schedule 24 of convictions and points) of the individual upon whom the 25 penalty is imposed, nor may the imposition of the penalty be 26 subject to merit rating for insurance purposes. 27 (5) No surcharge points may be imposed in the provision 28 of motor vehicle insurance coverage. Fines collected under 29 this section shall not be subject to 42 Pa.C.S. § 3571 30 (relating to Commonwealth portion of fines, etc.) or 3573 20070H1559B1959 - 5 -
1 (relating to municipal corporation portion of fines, etc.). 2 (6) No person may be found liable upon evidence obtained 3 through the use of devices authorized by this section unless 4 the speed recorded is six or more miles per hour in excess of 5 the legal speed limit. 6 (f) Enforcement.-- 7 (1) As part of a system to collect fines issued pursuant 8 to this section and remaining in an unpaid or uncontested 9 status after the applicable due date, the system 10 administrator may assess reasonable fees, including late 11 fees, as follows: 12 (i) $100 for fines unpaid or uncontested for a 13 period of 15 days after the date listed on the citation. 14 (ii) $125 for fines unpaid or uncontested for a 15 period of 30 days after the date listed on the citation. 16 (iii) $150 for fines unpaid or uncontested for a 17 period of 45 days after the date listed on the citation. 18 (iv) $200 for fines unpaid or uncontested for a 19 period of 60 days after the date listed on the citation. 20 (2) In addition to the penalties otherwise provided in 21 this section, fines issued pursuant to this section and 22 remaining in an unpaid or uncontested status for 30 or more 23 days after the applicable due date may subject the vehicle or 24 combination to immobilization and impoundment by the system 25 administrator. In the event of such immobilization and 26 impoundment the system administrator shall tow and store the 27 vehicle or combination and provide notice by first class 28 mail, proof of mailing, of the towing, storage and location 29 of the vehicle or combination to the owner and the lienholder 30 of the vehicle or combination using a reasonably available 20070H1559B1959 - 6 -
1 State database. The owner or lienholder of any vehicle or 2 combination which has been towed and stored under this 3 section may obtain possession of the vehicle or combination 4 by: 5 (i) furnishing proof of valid registration and 6 financial responsibility; and 7 (ii) paying all fines and costs associated with the 8 towing and storage of the vehicle or combination and 9 fines associated with citations issued pursuant to this 10 section or otherwise due to the system administrator or 11 City of Philadelphia related to violations of any local 12 parking regulation or ordinance or applicable section of 13 this chapter or Chapter 61 (relating to powers of 14 department and local authorities). 15 (3) Any vehicle or combination not recovered under this 16 subsection may be sold as an unclaimed vehicle, combination 17 or load under section 6310 (relating to disposition of 18 impounded vehicles, combinations and loads). 19 (g) Limitations.-- 20 (1) Notwithstanding any other provision of law, camera 21 equipment deployed as part of an automated speed timing 22 system as provided in this section must be incapable of 23 automated or user-controlled remote intersection surveillance 24 by means of recorded video images. Photographs collected as 25 part of the automated speed timing system must only record 26 traffic violations and may not be used for any other 27 surveillance purposes. The restrictions set forth in this 28 paragraph shall not be deemed to preclude a court of 29 competent jurisdiction from issuing an order directing that 30 the information be provided to law enforcement officials if 20070H1559B1959 - 7 -
1 the information is reasonably described and is requested 2 solely in connection with a criminal law enforcement action. 3 (2) Notwithstanding any other provision of law, 4 information prepared under this section and information 5 relating to violations under this section which is kept by 6 the city of the first class, its authorized agents or its 7 employees or the system administrator, including photographs, 8 written records, reports or facsimiles, names, addresses and 9 the number of violations under this section, shall be for the 10 exclusive use of the city, its authorized agents, its 11 employees and law enforcement officials for the purpose of 12 discharging their duties under this section and under any 13 ordinances and resolutions of the city. The information shall 14 not be deemed a public record under the act of June 21, 1957 15 (P.L.390, No.212), referred to as the Right-to-Know Law, 16 except as to statistical information related to the operation 17 of the automated speed timing system. The information shall 18 not be discoverable by court order or otherwise, nor shall it 19 be offered in evidence in any action or proceeding which is 20 not directly related to a violation of this section or any 21 ordinance or resolution of the city. 22 (3) Photographic evidence obtained through the use of 23 automated speed timing systems deployed as a means of 24 promoting traffic safety in a city of the first class shall 25 be destroyed within one year of final disposition of any 26 recorded event. The city or the system administrator, as the 27 case may be, shall file notice with the Department of State 28 that the records have been destroyed in accordance with this 29 section. 30 (4) Notwithstanding any other provision of law, 20070H1559B1959 - 8 -
1 registered vehicle owner information obtained as a result of 2 the operation of an automated speed timing system under this 3 section shall not be the property of the manufacturer or 4 vendor of the automated speed timing system and may not be 5 used for any purpose other than prescribed in this section. 6 (h) Defenses.-- 7 (1) It shall be a defense to a violation under this 8 section that the person named in the notice of the violation 9 was not operating the vehicle at the time of the violation. 10 The owner may be required to submit evidence that the owner 11 was not the driver at the time of the alleged violation. The 12 city of the first class may not require the owner of the 13 vehicle to disclose the identity of the operator of the 14 vehicle at the time of the violation. 15 (2) If an owner receives a notice of violation pursuant 16 to this section of a time period during which the vehicle was 17 reported to a police department of any state or municipality 18 as having been stolen, it shall be a defense to a violation 19 pursuant to this section that the vehicle has been reported 20 to a police department as stolen prior to the time the 21 violation occurred and had not been recovered prior to that 22 time. 23 (3) It shall be a defense to a violation under this 24 section that the person receiving the notice of violation was 25 not the owner of the vehicle at the time of the offense. 26 (i) Department approval.--No automated speed timing system 27 may be used without the approval of the department, which shall 28 have the authority to promulgate regulations for the 29 certification and use of such systems. 30 (j) Postings.--An automated speed timing system may not be 20070H1559B1959 - 9 -
1 used unless there is posted an appropriate sign in a conspicuous 2 place before the area in which the automated speed timing system 3 is to be used notifying the public that an automated speed 4 timing system is in use immediately ahead. 5 (k) System administrator.--The Philadelphia Parking 6 Authority shall be the system administrator as to any automated 7 speed timing system implemented in a city of the first class. 8 The following apply: 9 (1) The system administrator may hire and designate 10 personnel as necessary or contract for services to implement 11 this section. 12 (2) The system administrator shall process fines issued 13 pursuant to this section. 14 (3) The system administrator shall file an annual report 15 to the chairman and the minority chairman of the 16 Transportation Committee of the Senate and the chairman and 17 minority chairman of the Transportation Committee of the 18 House of Representatives. The report shall include for the 19 prior year: 20 (i) The number of violations and fines issued. 21 (ii) A compilation of fines paid and outstanding. 22 (iii) The amount of money paid to a vendor or 23 manufacturer under this section. 24 (l) Notice to owner.-- 25 (1) The system administrator shall prepare a notice of 26 violation to the registered owner of a vehicle identified in 27 a photograph produced by an automated speed timing system as 28 evidence of a violation of the posted speed limit. The 29 issuance of the notice of violation must be completed by a 30 police officer. The issuance of a violation pursuant to this 20070H1559B1959 - 10 -
1 section by a police officer shall not be deemed a violation 2 of section 3368(c). The notice of violation shall have 3 attached to it a copy of the recorded image showing the 4 vehicle; the registration number and state of issuance of the 5 vehicle registration; the date, time and place of the alleged 6 violation; that the violation charged is under this section; 7 and instructions for return of the notice of violation. The 8 notice of violation must be mailed within 30 days after the 9 commission of the violation or within 30 days after the 10 discovery of the identity of the registered owner, whichever 11 is later, and not thereafter to the address of the registered 12 owner as listed in the vehicle registration records of the 13 applicable jurisdiction. In any event, a notice of violation 14 under this section must be provided to an owner within 90 15 days of the commission of the offense. The text of the notice 16 must be as follows: 17 This notice shall be returned personally, by mail or 18 by an agent duly authorized in writing, within 30 19 days of issuance. A hearing may be obtained upon the 20 written request of the registered owner. 21 (2) In the case of a violation involving a motor vehicle 22 registered under the laws of this Commonwealth, the notice of 23 violation must be mailed within 30 days after the commission 24 of the violation or within 30 days after the discovery of the 25 identity of the registered owner, whichever is later, and not 26 thereafter to the address of the registered owner as listed 27 in the records of the department. In the case of motor 28 vehicles registered in jurisdictions other than this 29 Commonwealth, the notice of violation must be mailed within 30 30 days after the discovery of the identity of the registered 20070H1559B1959 - 11 -
1 owner, whichever is later, and not thereafter to the address 2 of the registered owner as listed in the records of the 3 official in the jurisdiction having charge of the 4 registration of the vehicle. A notice of violation under this 5 section must be provided to an owner within 90 days of the 6 commission of the offense. 7 (m) Mailing of notice and records.--Notice of violation must 8 be sent by first class mail. A manual or automatic record of 9 mailing prepared by the system administrator in the ordinary 10 course of business shall be prima facie evidence of mailing and 11 shall be admissible in any judicial or administrative proceeding 12 as to the facts contained in it. 13 (n) Payment of fee.-- 14 (1) An owner to whom a notice of violation has been 15 issued may admit responsibility for the violation and pay the 16 fine provided in the notice. 17 (2) Payment must be made personally, through an 18 authorized agent or by mailing both payment and the notice of 19 violation to the system administrator. Payment by mail must 20 be made only by money order, credit card or check made 21 payable to the system administrator. 22 (3) The system administrator shall remit the fine, less 23 the operational and maintenance costs of the system 24 administrator and, if necessary, the city, necessitated by 25 this section, to the department for deposit into the Motor 26 License Fund to be used for safety improvements to Roosevelt 27 Boulevard by the department or the City of Philadelphia as 28 determined by the department. 29 (4) Payment of the established fine and applicable 30 penalties shall operate as a final disposition of the case. 20070H1559B1959 - 12 -
1 (o) Hearing.-- 2 (1) An owner to whom a notice of violation has been 3 issued may, within 30 days of the mailing of the notice, 4 request a hearing to contest the liability alleged in the 5 notice. A hearing request must be made by appearing before 6 the system administrator during regular office hours either 7 personally or by an authorized agent or by mailing a request 8 in writing. 9 (2) Upon receipt of a hearing request, the system 10 administrator shall in a timely manner schedule the matter 11 before a hearing officer. In the event the hearing relates to 12 a violation issued pursuant to this section and the city of 13 the first class has not passed an ordinance pursuant to 14 subsection (a), the hearing officer shall be appointed by the 15 system administrator; otherwise the hearing officer shall be 16 designated by the city of the first class. Written notice of 17 the date, time and place of hearing must be sent by first 18 class mail to the owner. 19 (3) The system administrator shall be considered a local 20 agency for the purposes of 2 Pa.C.S. Chs. 5 (relating to 21 practice and procedure) and 7 (relating to judicial review), 22 except that the provisions of 2 Pa.C.S. § 555 (relating to 23 contents and service of adjudications) requiring that hearing 24 determinations contain findings and reasons for the 25 determination shall not be applicable. The system 26 administrator and a city of the first class shall not be 27 required to issue a formal decision containing findings and 28 reasons for the hearing decision. 29 (4) The hearing shall be informal; the rules of evidence 30 shall not apply; and the decision of the hearing officer 20070H1559B1959 - 13 -
1 shall be final, subject to the right of the owner to appeal 2 the decision to the traffic court. 3 (5) If the owner requests in writing that the decision 4 of the hearing officer be appealed to the traffic court, the 5 system administrator shall file the notice of violation and 6 supporting documents with the traffic court, which shall hear 7 and decide the matter de novo. 8 (p) Compensation to manufacturer or vendor.--If an automated 9 speed timing system is deployed in a city of the first class as 10 a means of promoting traffic safety and the enforcement of the 11 traffic laws of this Commonwealth or the city, the compensation 12 paid to the manufacturer or vendor of the automated speed timing 13 system may not be based upon the number of traffic citations 14 issued or a portion or percentage of the fine generated by the 15 citations. The compensation paid to the manufacturer or vendor 16 of the equipment shall be based upon the value of the equipment 17 and the services provided or rendered in support of the 18 automated speed timing system. 19 (q) Revenue limitation.--A city of the first class may not 20 collect an amount equal to or greater than 5% of its annual 21 budget from the collection of revenue from the issuance and 22 payment of violations under this section. 23 (r) Expiration.--This section shall expire December 31, 24 2012. 25 Section 3. This act shall take effect immediately. F11L75SFL/20070H1559B1959 - 14 -