PRIOR PRINTER'S NOS. 1118, 1204, 2062

PRINTER'S NO.  2077

  

THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF PENNSYLVANIA

  

SENATE BILL

 

No.

929

Session of

2009

  

  

INTRODUCED BY DINNIMAN, PICCOLA AND WILLIAMS, JUNE 5, 2009

  

  

AS AMENDED ON SECOND CONSIDERATION, JUNE 21, 2010   

  

  

  

AN ACT

  

1

Providing for the sale of certain course materials at

2

institutions of higher education, for responsibilities of

3

faculty and institutions of higher education and for college

4

textbook rental pilot programs; and establishing the College

5

Textbook Policies Advisory Committee.

6

The General Assembly of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania

7

hereby enacts as follows:

8

Section 1.  Short title.

9

This act shall be known and may be cited as the College

10

Textbook Affordability, Accountability and Accessibility Act.

11

Section 2.  Definitions.

12

The following words and phrases when used in this act shall

13

have the meanings given to them in this section unless the

14

context clearly indicates otherwise:

15

"Advisory committee."  The College Textbook Policies Advisory

16

Committee established under this act.

17

"Bundle."  One or more college textbooks or other

18

supplemental materials that may be packaged together to be sold

19

as course materials for one price.

20

"Campus."  The grounds and buildings of an institution of

 


1

higher education that are designated as such by the institution

2

of higher education.

3

"Campus bookstore."  The bookstore on the campus of, or

4

otherwise associated with, an institution of higher education.

5

"College textbook."  A textbook or set of textbooks used for,

6

or in conjunction with, a course in postsecondary education at

7

an institution of higher education.

8

"Custom textbook."  A college textbook that is compiled by a

9

publisher at the direction of a faculty member or other person

10

or adopting entity in charge of selecting course materials at an

11

institution of higher education and may include, alone or in

12

combination, items, such as selections from original instructor

13

materials, previously copyrighted publisher materials or

14

copyrighted third-party works. This term does not include purely

15

aesthetic changes to a textbook when compared with a prior

16

edition, such as a commemorative edition.

17

"Institution of higher education" or "institution."  Any of

18

the 14 State-owned universities that are part of the

19

Pennsylvania State System of Higher Education, including the

20

four State-related universities. The term also includes

21

community colleges that are members of the Pennsylvania

22

Commission for Community Colleges and independent or private

23

colleges or universities that receive an assistance grant under

24

the act of July 18, 1974 (P.L.483, No.174), known as The

25

Institutional Assistance Grants Act.

26

"Integrated textbook."  A college textbook that is:

<--

27

(1)  combined with supplemental materials developed by a

28

third party and that, by third-party contractual agreement,

29

may not be offered by publishers separately from the college

30

textbook with which the supplemental materials are combined;

- 2 -

 


1

or

2

(2)  combined with supplemental materials that are so

3

interrelated with the content of the textbook that the

4

separation of the textbook from the supplemental materials

5

would render the textbook unusable for its intended purpose.

6

"ISBN."  International Standard Book Number.

7

"Publisher."  An entity that publishes college textbooks or

8

supplemental materials and markets college textbooks or

9

supplemental materials to faculty members at institutions of

10

higher education. The term does not include a wholesaler.

11

"Substantial content."  Parts of a college textbook, such as

12

new chapters, additional eras of time, new themes or new subject

13

matter.

14

"Supplemental material."  Educational material developed to

15

accompany a college textbook, which may include printed

16

materials, computer disks, Internet website access and

17

electronically distributed materials.

18

Section 3.  Publisher requirements.

19

(a)  Pricing information disclosure.--When a publisher

20

provides a faculty member or entity in charge of selecting

21

course materials at an institution of higher education with

22

information regarding a college textbook or supplemental

23

material, the publisher shall include, in writing or

24

electronically, the following:

25

(1)  The price at which the publisher would make the

26

college textbook or supplemental material available to the

27

campus bookstore of the institution of higher education.

28

(2)  The copyright dates of the three previous editions

29

of the college textbook or supplemental material in the

30

preceding ten years, if any.

- 3 -

 


1

(3)  The substantial content revisions made between the

2

current edition of the college textbook or supplemental

3

material and the previous edition, if any.

4

(4)  Whether the college textbook or supplemental

5

material is available in any other format, including

6

paperback and unbound, and the price at which the publisher

7

would make the college textbook or supplemental material in

8

the other format available to the campus bookstore of such

9

institution of higher education.

10

 (b)  Unbundling of college textbooks from supplemental

11

materials.--

12

(1)  A publisher that sells a college textbook and any

13

supplemental material accompanying the college textbook as a

14

bundle or as an integrated textbook shall also make available

<--

15

the college textbook and each supplemental material as

16

separate and unbundled items, each separately priced.

17

(2)  A publisher is not required to make available

18

supplemental items developed by a third party and that, by

19

third-party contractual agreement, may not be offered by the

20

publisher separately from the college textbook.

21

 (c)  Custom textbooks.--When a faculty member or entity in

22

charge of selecting course materials at an institution of higher

23

education directs a publisher to compile a custom textbook, the

24

publisher shall provide, in writing or electronically, prior to

25

accepting an order for the custom textbook, the price at which

26

the publishers would make the custom textbook available to the

27

campus bookstore.

28

Section 4.  Faculty responsibilities.

29

(a)  General duties.--A faculty member or entity in charge of

30

selecting college textbooks, supplemental materials or bundled

- 4 -

 


1

textbook packages for an institution of higher education shall:

2

(1)  Consider the least costly practices in assigning

3

college textbooks, consistent with educationally sound

4

practices as determined by the appropriate faculty or entity.

5

(2)  Consider the use of college textbooks, supplemental  

6

materials and bundled textbook packages for a longer period

7

of time, to the extent they are not outdated.

8

(3)  Work with bookstores to review timeliness and the

9

processes involved in ordering and stocking selected course

10

materials, disclose college textbook costs to students and

11

actively promote and publicize book buyback programs.

12

(4)  Provide a statement to the entity designated by the

13

president or chancellor of the institution to disseminate the

14

information required under section 5(a) detailing college

15

textbooks or supplemental learning materials, whether bundled

16

or unbundled, that are required or recommended for the

17

course. Where possible, the statement shall indicate if an

18

earlier edition may be effective for use by a student.

19

(5)  Encourage participation in college textbook rental

20

programs that exist or may exist in the future.

21

(b)  Prohibited conduct by faculty and academic

22

departments.--

23

(1)  No faculty member or academic department may demand

24

or receive any payment, loan, subscription, advance, deposit

25

of money, services or any thing, present or promised, as an

26

inducement for requiring students to purchase a specific

27

college textbook required for coursework or instruction.

28

(2)  Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraph (1),  a

29

faculty member or academic department may receive:

30

(i)  Sample copies, instructor's copies or

- 5 -

 


1

instructional material.

2

(ii)  Royalties or other compensation from the sale

3

of college textbooks that include the writing or work of

4

the particular faculty member or academic department.

5

(3)  A violation of this subsection may result in the

6

institution taking disciplinary action, subject to any

7

contractual requirements, against the faculty member or

8

academic department, including, where appropriate, referral

9

to law enforcement.

10

(c)  Construction.--Nothing in this section shall be

11

construed:

12

(1)  To prohibit a faculty member or academic department

13

from requiring the most recent edition of a college textbook.

14

(2)  To supersede the institutional autonomy or academic

15

freedom of instructors, faculty members or academic

16

departments involved in the selection of college textbooks,

17

supplemental materials and other classroom materials.

18

Section 5.  Responsibilities of institutions of higher

19

education.

20

(a)  General rule.--Except as otherwise provided in this

21

section, each institution shall make available at student

22

registration and throughout the year on its Internet website and

23

upon written request a listing of all college textbooks and

24

supplemental materials, including the ISBN, required and

25

recommended for courses to be offered during the upcoming term,

26

provided that:

27

(1)  If the ISBN is not available, the institution shall

28

include the author, title, edition, publisher and copyright

29

date for the college textbook or supplemental material.

30

(2)  If the institution determines that the disclosure of

- 6 -

 


1

the information relating to a college textbook or

2

supplemental material is not practicable, then the

3

institution shall so indicate by placing the designation "To

4

Be Determined" in lieu of the information required in

5

paragraph (1). As this information becomes available, it

6

shall be posted on the institution's Internet website and

7

provided as soon as possible to students and those who have

8

previously requested such information.

9

(b)  Publication.--The institution shall provide the

10

information required under subsections (a) and (d) to existing

11

and accepted incoming students by posting the information on the

12

institution's Internet website used for course scheduling,

13

preregistration and registration. The institution shall inform,

14

in writing, students and all others who make a written request

15

for such information of the availability of the information. The

16

posting of this information on the Internet website of the

17

campus bookstore shall satisfy the provisions of this section

18

provided that such information is freely available to students

19

and the general public.

20

(c)  Information to bookstore.--An institution of higher

21

education shall make available to a bookstore that is operated

22

by, or in a contractual relationship or otherwise affiliated

23

with, the institution, and shall also make available to off-

24

campus bookstores upon request, as soon as practicable after the

25

request of the bookstore, the most accurate information

26

available relating to:

27

(1)  The institution's course schedule for the subsequent

28

academic period.

29

(2)  For each course or class offered by the institution

30

for the subsequent academic period:

- 7 -

 


1

(i)  The information required by subsection (a) for

2

each college textbook or supplemental material required

3

or recommended for the course or class.

4

(ii)  The number of students enrolled in such course

5

or class.

6

(iii)  The maximum student enrollment for such course

7

or class.

8

(d)  Dissemination of other information to students.--An

9

institution of higher education is encouraged to disseminate to

10

students information relating to:

11

(1)  Available programs for renting college textbooks or

12

for purchasing used college textbooks.

13

(2)  Available college textbook buyback programs.

14

(3)  Available alternative content delivery programs,

15

including digital textbooks.

16

(4)  Other available cost-saving strategies for acquiring

17

college textbooks and supplemental materials.

18

(5)  Campus and off-campus bookstore information, to the

19

extent available, including location, hours and Internet

20

website information.

21

(e)  Textbook information.--Nothing in this section shall be

22

construed to prohibit or restrict the ability of a bookstore

23

from also providing textbook information to students.

24

Section 6.  College textbook rental program.

25

(a)  General rule.--An institution of higher education may,

26

with the approval of the administration, authorize the

27

establishment of a college textbook rental program for the

28

students of any campus. Programs may receive and use Federal,

29

State and private funding to aid in the establishment of such

30

programs.

- 8 -

 


1

(b)  Task force.--The administrators of a campus with a

2

college textbook rental program may convene a task force to

3

determine recommended policies and procedures to establish and

4

operate a college textbook rental pilot program. The task force

5

must include students, faculty, administrators and bookstore

6

managers.

7

(c)  Textbook selection.--The program may not limit the

8

rights of faculty to select appropriate textbooks in accordance

9

with established policies and procedures.

10

(d)  Powers of campuses with college textbook rental

11

programs.--The administrators of a campus with a college

12

textbook rental program may:

13

 (1)  Establish policies for the program, including, but

14

not limited to, implementing practices to achieve the best

15

possible purchase price for college textbooks and for the

16

provision of rental services. Such policies shall be

17

developed with the input of faculty, students and bookstores.

18

 (2)  Institute other procedures necessary to establish

19

and operate the program in accordance with the provisions of

20

this act.

21

 (3)  Charge students a fine for any late, lost or

22

damaged books, as determined by the program, provided that

23

students may not be charged a fine for normal textbook wear

24

and tear.

25

(4)  Students shall not be required to participate in a

26

textbook rental program.

27

(e)  Construction.--Nothing in this section shall be

28

construed to:

29

(1)  change or limit any textbook rental program or

30

program in existence at an institution of higher education

- 9 -

 


1

prior to the enactment date of this act; or

2

(2)  restrict an institution of higher education from

3

establishing or piloting other textbook rental models or

4

programs as deemed appropriate by the institution of higher

5

education.

6

Section 7.  Electronic versions of college textbooks.

7

(a)  General rule.--No later than January 1, 2020, an

8

individual, firm, partnership or corporation that publishes

9

college textbooks offered for sale at institutions of higher

10

education shall, to the extent practicable, make the college

11

textbooks available, in whole or in part, for sale in an

12

electronic format when commercially reasonable.

13

(b)  Construction.--Nothing in this section shall be

14

construed to authorize any use of instructional materials that

15

would constitute an infringement of copyright under Federal law.

16

(c)    Definition.--For purposes of this section, "college

17

textbook" means a book, not including a novel, that contains

18

printed material and is intended for use as a source of study

19

material for a class or group of students, a copy of which is

20

expected to be available for the use of each of the students in

21

that class or group.

22

Section 8.  College textbook adoption policies.

23

(a)  General rule.--An institution of higher education may

24

implement policies, procedures and guidelines that promote

25

efforts to minimize the cost of college textbooks for students

26

at the institution while maintaining the quality of education

27

and academic freedom. The policies, procedures and guidelines

28

shall ensure that:

29

(1)  The adoption of a college textbook by a faculty

30

member is made with sufficient lead time so as to confirm

- 10 -

 


1

availability of the requested materials and, where possible,

2

ensure maximum availability of used college textbooks.

3

(2)  (i)  During the college textbook adoption process,

4

the intent to use all items ordered, particularly each

5

individual item sold as part of a bundled package, is

6

affirmatively confirmed before the adoption is finalized

7

by the faculty member.

8

(ii)  If the faculty member does not intend to use

9

each item in a bundled package, the faculty member shall

10

notify the bookstore, and the bookstore shall order the

11

individualized items if:

12

(A)  Procurement of the individualized items is

13

cost effective for both the institution and the

14

students.

15

(B)  The individualized items are made available

16

by the publisher.

17

(3)  Faculty members affirmatively acknowledge the quoted

18

retail price to the bookstore of any college textbook

19

selected for use in each course.

20

(4)  Faculty members shall give due consideration to both

21

the educational value and cost of new edition college

22

textbooks and any supplemental materials when previous

23

editions do not significantly differ in a substantive way, as

24

determined by the appropriate faculty member.

25

(5)  Required or assigned college textbooks are made

26

available to students who are otherwise unable to afford the

27

cost.

28

(6)  Decisions regarding textbook adoption are made in a

29

timely manner to ensure a bookstore's ability to have

30

textbooks available for the first day of class.

- 11 -

 


1

Section 9.  College Textbook Policies Advisory Committee.

2

(a)  Establishment.--A standing committee of the State Board

3

of Education to be known as the College Textbook Policies

4

Advisory Committee is established. The Department of Education

5

shall provide staff support for the advisory committee.

6

(b)  Membership.--The advisory committee shall be comprised

7

of:

8

(1)  The Deputy Secretary for Higher Education of the

9

Department of Education or a designee.

10

(2)  The chairman of the State Board of Education Higher

11

Education Council or a designee.

12

(3)  One faculty member representing the State System of

13

Higher Education as recommended by the Chancellor of the

14

State System of Higher Education.

15

(4)  One faculty member representing each of the State-

16

related institutions as recommended by the chancellors of the

17

State-related institutions.

18

(5)  One faculty member representing community colleges

19

as recommended by the Commission for Community Colleges.

20

(6)  One faculty member representing private and

21

independent colleges and universities as recommended by the

22

Association of Independent Colleges and Universities of

23

Pennsylvania.

24

(7)  The chairman and minority chairman of the Education

25

Committee of the Senate and the chairman and minority

26

chairman of the House of Representatives or their designees.

27

(8)  Nine members appointed by the chairman of the State

28

Board of Education as follows:

29

(i)  Three members representing college bookstores,

30

with one representing campus bookstores, one representing

- 12 -

 


1

off-campus bookstores and one representing online

2

bookstores that focus primarily on the sale of college

3

textbooks.

4

(ii)  Two members representing textbook publishers.

5

(iii)  Four student members representing college

6

students, of whom one must attend a State System of

7

Higher Education institution, one must attend a

8

State-related institution, one must attend a community

9

college and one must attend an independent or private

10

college or university within this Commonwealth. The

11

student members shall be appointed, respectively, by the

12

chairman from a list of students recommended by the

13

Chancellor of the State System of Higher Education, the

14

chancellors of the State-related institutions, the

15

Commission for Community Colleges or the Association of

16

Independent Colleges and Universities of Pennsylvania.

17

(9)  One member possessing a background in information

18

technology-electronic media appointed by the chairman of the

19

State Board of Education.

20

(c)    Recommendations.--The advisory committee shall examine

21

national and international efforts relating to college textbook

22

affordability and accessibility and make recommendations that:

23

(1)  Ensure that students have access to affordable

24

course materials by decreasing costs to students and

25

enhancing transparency and disclosure with respect to the

26

selection, purchase, sale and use of course materials.

27

(2)  Identify ways to decrease the cost of college

28

textbooks and supplemental materials for students while

29

supporting the academic freedom of faculty members to select

30

high quality course materials for students.

- 13 -

 


1

(3)  Encourage college textbook publishers and

2

distributors to work with faculty to promote understanding of

3

the cost to students of purchasing faculty-selected college

4

textbooks, including the disclosure of prices and bundling

5

practices.

6

(4)  Encourage innovation in the development and use of

7

course materials, including open-source college textbooks and

8

other open-source educational resources, that can help

9

students receive the full value of their educational

10

investment without excessive cost.

11

(5)  Ensure that faculty members are informed of accurate

12

and relevant pricing information for course materials and

13

that students are protected as a consumer group.

14

(6)  Make recommendations to the General Assembly and the

15

State Board of Education to strengthen existing State laws

16

and regulations and to propose any additional and necessary

17

State laws and regulations.

18

(d)  First meeting.--  The advisory committee shall hold its

19

first meeting within 60 days of the effective date of this

20

section. The advisory committee shall meet at least once

21

quarterly. Members of the advisory committee shall serve without

22

compensation. The deputy secretary for Higher Education of the

23

Department of Education shall serve as committee chair.

24

(e)    Report.--No later than 18 months after the effective

25

date of this section, the advisory committee shall make a report

26

to the State Board of Education that outlines its findings and

27

recommendations. The report shall also be delivered to the

28

Governor's Office, members of the Education Committee of the

29

Senate and members of the Education Committee of the House of

30

Representatives. The report shall be updated every three years

- 14 -

 


1

and may also be posted on the Department of Education's Internet

2

website.

3

Section 10.  Effective date.

4

This act shall take effect July 1, 2010, or immediately,

5

whichever is later.

- 15 -